Love + Sex

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

In Sickness and in Health ... But Hold the Sickness

By: The Love Goddess


When illness strikes, a new study shows that men are more likely to run for the hills.

This just in: When men receive a diagnosis of brain cancer, their wives give them the nurturance and support they need. But women who get a similar diagnosis often face separation or divorce, according to Tara Parker-Pope’s blog in The New York Times.

Now that, my darling lovers down there on earth, is information that upsets our whole galaxy. Divorce, we all know, can make you seriously ill. So why would any man, even an unhappy one, even an overwhelmed one, allow his already desperately sick wife to face the additional stress of separation or divorce? Yet, among 515 patients in a study conducted by Dr. Marc Chamberlain, a Seattle oncologist, and his colleagues, the women receiving these life-threatening diagnoses were seven times more likely to become separated or divorced than men who received the same diagnoses.
   
I suppose we can come up with all kinds of easy answers. For example, perhaps these men simply can’t handle the onslaught of emotion and disruption their wives’ illnesses cause, in themselves, in their wives, in their children. But the question is: Why not? Men are strong and tough and courageous, right? They save lives every second of the day when they’re at war. They nurture and support each other selflessly. They sacrifice their own lives in battle with a love that is beyond extraordinary.

Stupidly Standing By Your Man?

So what makes this battle so different? Is it that some men, like the tired stereotype suggests, never get the hang of nurturing their lovers, as if hardwired to receive selfless love from women but not to give it? And if it is a Guy Thing (we can’t be sure, after all, who’s initiating these separations and why), then what, precisely, can’t men handle that women can?

It could be that it’s not the men who decide to leave their sick spouses, but the women who end the relationship. In all the statistics I’ve seen, women initiate divorce far more often than men do. If that’s the case, why would they do so at a time of such unimaginable stress? Is it possible that the wives in these studies actually feel better going it alone than facing deterioration or death with spouses who can’t rise to the occasion? Is it for them a more desperate feeling to be emotionally abandoned at such a time, when their survival might be in question, than to be literally alone?

Toxic Divorces We Thank Goodness We Weren't Part Of

And finally, how do circumstances that we vow to be prepared for (the "thick or thin" part of love; the "in sickness and in health" clause) become nothing more than just wishful thinking, a ghost of marriage past, as dated and extinct as the notion of loving one person forever?

I would love to hear from you, my smart and loving readers, about this. In my eons of experience with couples, this one has me stymied. And heartsick.

12 Vampires We Love


[Photo Credit: © Shutterstock]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 134
  • kirby's Avatar
    Posted by kirby Fri Nov 20, 2009 11:45am PST

    that is such bull s---!! that utterly pisses me off dude forreal

    Report Abuse
  • Laura's Avatar
    Posted by Laura Fri Nov 20, 2009 11:49am PST

    Could be that when a wife becomes ill her husband looks for satisfaction elsewhere. Having a cheating husband when you are ill is worse than being ill alone.

    Report Abuse
  • Robin's Avatar
    Posted by Robin Fri Nov 20, 2009 12:16pm PST

    I will share with the readers my experience that involves my parnets. My mother was diagnosed with breast cancer for the first time when she was 35. My father was supportive and at every and I mean every doctor's appointment. Over the next 11 years the cancer would show up in different areas of her body. Not once did I see my father behave in a nonloving manner. There were certain things he could not deal with, mostly the side affects of the chemo. That is when I stepped in and helped. Most of the recovery from surgery's was him being a loving husband. So I think that maybe there is an issue with the women's husbands.

    Report Abuse
  • hskrfn24's Avatar
    Posted by hskrfn24 Fri Nov 20, 2009 12:17pm PST

    I was thinking the exact same thing as Laura

    Report Abuse
  • emerald-mist's Avatar
    Posted by emerald-mist Fri Nov 20, 2009 12:34pm PST

    well i think maybe men abandon the ill wife because of a feeling of failure..men are depicted as providers and protectors,these are physical attributes. not emotional.women are nesters,care givers....i think women can multi-task better. meaning even in her illness she has a family to watch over and care for,as long as possible.the men[GOD love-um]feel at a lose on what to say.he in turn feels his hands are tied as he can not protect his mate or family from an unseen enemy. maybe he may think, she feels he has let her down.women are very verbel. men not so much. this is the time for lots of talking between both parties.women also need lots of cuddling. makes her feel protected wraped in strong arms. this is not a sexual thing guys..he may become aroused and feel guilty because of it.knowing his wife is not on that level,hampered by her illness.men you are wonderful just being men. just lend us your strong arms,we will make it thru. if we do not recover,know that you where there holding us in our darkest hour.have know guilt know remorse. a new page in your life has begun. use it well.

    Report Abuse
  • Walter's Avatar
    Posted by Walter Fri Nov 20, 2009 12:45pm PST

    my wife (39) died 9 mos ago after an 8 mos battle. not once did i leave her side nor did it ever cross my mind. in fact most of the time i felt that i was not doing enough. she asked one time why and the exact words out my mouth were "richer or poorer, in sickness and health till death do us part". not once did it ever cross my mind to leave no matter how hard or ugly it got. when the day came i spoke the hardest words in my entire life, "i can't stand to see you suffer anymore" and i finally said the words that she had been needing to hear me say during the whole...don't worry i'll be all right.

    point is 515 ppeople is not a justifiable study.

    Report Abuse
  • Kim's Avatar
    Posted by Kim Fri Nov 20, 2009 12:46pm PST

    When my doctor said I neede a biopsy for cysts in my uterus, I decided life was too short to spend miserably married. I didn't have cancer, but I did get a divorce I wouldn't have had the courage to get without the mortality check. It's not always the guy who wants out.

    Report Abuse
  • Maria's Avatar
    Posted by Maria Fri Nov 20, 2009 1:04pm PST

    I dont think that study is excactly accurate, honestly I have known men that would do anything for their wives when they got sick. We had a family friend whose wive had been sick for the last 5 years of her life, she was only 42 when she died,but that man did everything he could for her and their kids.

    Report Abuse
  • Zom-B's Avatar
    Posted by Zom-B Fri Nov 20, 2009 1:16pm PST

    I don't know...my ex-wife couldn't handle any sort of stress or difficulty without freaking out and abandoning the person in question (and don't dare call her on it unless you wanted to be subjected to a torrent of verbal abuse) but I personally, though I AM a man, can't even fathom abandoning someone with a potentially terminal illness.

    So I don't know who these idiots are, but screw it. I don't appreciate the kind of generalizing that's going to be applied to me as a man because of stupid articles like this. Then again, I have no intention of getting into another relationship, anyway. No one is trustworthy. Much better to just go it all alone.

    Report Abuse
  • Joy in Seattle's Avatar
    Posted by Joy in Seattle Fri Nov 20, 2009 1:37pm PST

    NUMBERS!!!

    This article has no data, no numbers, nothing to back itself up with. It does not say where the study came from or who these people were. Did they look at two couples or two hundred? Did men stay 9/10 times while woman stayed 9.5/10 times or was it more significant?

    Do not believe the stuff in this article unless it comes with facts to back it up with. For all you know, this is an experiment to see how woman react to the claim that men split.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 134

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Help! My close friend keeps flirting with my spouse!