Love + Sex

Friday, December 11, 2009

Is Marriage Dying? Why Today's Couples Are Skipping the Church and Vows

Love and marriage, love and marriage, they say it goes together like a horse and carriage. Well, perhaps it did in times gone by, when things like "horses" and "carriages" were relevant.

Unless you're living in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, they just aren't anymore, are they?

If you count yourself in the under-30 crowd then you're sure to agree: One-third of young Americans (18-29) believe that marriage is an "antiquated institution," according to a newly released Zogby/Scoop44 interactive survey.

Contrast that against the 30-49, 50-64, and 65+ brackets—which definitively answered "not antiquated" (less than a quarter of people 30-49 and only 12 percent of senior citizens think marriage needs an update).

What's with all this? Could it be, as some suggest, "a fundamental cultural liberal-conservative split between the young and old demographics?" Is the sentiment a product of the divorced home? Is it the gays? Proof that recent same-sex in-roads are destroying the sanctity of marriage? Or, is FOX's prime-time programming is the more likely culprit?

Seriously, who is to blame for the sorry state of marriage? What else has changed within American cultural fabric that could answer for this? Read: Full Disclosure: His Finances, His Health

Exhibit A: The lyrics to that free credit report commercial.

I married my dream girl.
But, she didn't tell me her credit was bad.
So now, instead of living in a pleasant suburb,
we're living in the basement at her mom and dad's.
No, we can't get a loan
for a respectable home
just because my girl defaulted
On some old credit card
If we'd gone to Free Credit Report dot com
I'd be a happy bachelor with a dog and a yard.

Debt. We all have it, and it's only getting worse, especially so for the younger generations slated to bear the full burden of the current financial catastrophe.

Would you marry someone with $100K in student loan debt? Mounting credit card bills? With unlikely prospects of securing a job that makes more than $30K in the foreseeable future? Read: How Marriage Got Me Out of Debt

Think about it, there is absolutely no incentive for the young ones to hitch themselves to another person's bad credit, and to this LoveBuzzer that's the real reason behind the survey results.

Agree, disagree? What are your thoughts: Is marriage so last generation?

More relationship & love advice from YourTango.com:


Written by Claire Daniel for YourTango.com.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 42
  • Gina's Avatar
    Posted by Gina Wed Oct 21, 2009 9:25am PDT

    I could care less about debt unless its lack of trying, what i see as a problem is trust and honesty and selfishness, i thought I had it and the person I married said he would never leave me and we could get through anything, what a bunch of crap that ended up being.

    Report Abuse
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Wed Oct 21, 2009 9:26am PDT

    Sure is, no one is truly in love anymore, its just convenience, loneliness, money, etc.

    Report Abuse
  • another hockey fan's Avatar
    Posted by another hockey fan Wed Oct 21, 2009 9:32am PDT

    I agree with the younger set so long as they include not having children out of wedlock too. ;-) Save marriage for:

    1. When you are more experienced in life (ie older)

    2. When you are financially sound (no high debt) and/or have a good paying job

    3. When you are truly ready to remain in a committed relationship and have stopped dating losers

    4. When you can provide a stable environment (ie a home) to raise children, if you choose to have them.

    If you don't agree with or like any of those four items above, don't ever get married :-)

    Report Abuse
  • Elm's Avatar
    Posted by Elm Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:10am PDT

    People nowadays are to selfish to get married. It's all become too "it's all about me" to work. Marriage is giving 110% and truly be willing to work on the "for better or WORSE" vow. If you can't do that then do not get married.

    Report Abuse
  • Katie B's Avatar
    Posted by Katie B Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:34am PDT

    Would you marry someone with $100K in student loan debt?

    ~~~

    Um, my husband did... and not reluctantly either, because we met before I had that debt and we talked about it... A LOT.... as I was accruing it... it was for a good reason, it wasn't just borrowing money for the short run.

    My husband and I love each other, we are both under 30 and we want to start a family... our faith supports the idea of marriage, but it's so much more than a piece of paper and financial security and I think people forget that.

    Report Abuse
  • Natasha's Avatar
    Posted by Natasha Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:37am PDT

    Wow. Out of the four people who commented above, how many have been married? How many of those marriages ended in divorce?

    Here's my take; You only get one shot at life. If you love someone, and feel that a marriage is important to you, do it. If you don't feel that marriage is important, don't do it. Live your life how YOU want to live it. Who cares about the reasoning either way. It's your life, do with it as you please. Regardless, there is no wrong answer.

    Also, if you don't agree with me, that's your call. Unlike Hockey Fan up there, I am happy that you can make your own decisions and don't depend on a stranger from a internet site to draw out guidelines for you to follow.

    Report Abuse
  • DAVID G's Avatar
    Posted by DAVID G Wed Oct 21, 2009 11:21am PDT

    No, I would not marry someone with $100k student loan debt and mounting credit card debt. Once we are married, that debt becomes my debt as well which means that it will effect everything in our lives from where we live to where our children will go to school. A truely responsible person doesn't acrue mounting credit card debt. Marriage is not a bail-out package. It is an institution in which both people involved bring everything they have to the table, put it together and build a life together. With that much debt and very little prospects in the future, that person isn't bringing much to the table, Which means more problems for me. no thank you.

    Report Abuse
  • Mysterious Gryphon's Avatar
    Posted by Mysterious Gryphon Wed Oct 21, 2009 12:07pm PDT

    Would you marry someone with $100K in student loan debt?

    Yep. My fiance is going to be some $150K in debt pretty soon as he finishes up optometry school. We'll be married halfway through his third year out of four. But we have a plan for paying it back, and, frankly, we consider this debt to be a shared burden because the results of his schooling will benefit us both.

    The problem with marriage today is that people don't get the "for better or for worse" part. They don't understand what "forever" means. A lot of people our age (including my fiance) have watched their parents get divorced, and many no longer see marriage as a permanent state. They just stick around until it no longer benefits them. They don't stay with their partner "for richer or for poorer". I love my fiance, debt or no debt.

    I take him as he is.

    Report Abuse
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Wed Oct 21, 2009 12:27pm PDT

    Totally agree with "Another Hockey Fan 100% in all the things they said," if you have debts, why can't you wait till you get that debt down? Are you that confident that this person who loves you so much won't turn on you in a second and then divorce you and pile that debt onto you? People be realistic, get pre-nups, you have to protect yourself even in the name of love, what is the rush to get married? Kids yup, always married, should never be out of wedlock and environment stable, just like sex, to me, should be done when you are done with school, have a good job, financially, emotionally, mentally, stable, responsible adult,If it's meant to be, it will.

    Report Abuse
  • Jennifer's Avatar
    Posted by Jennifer Wed Oct 21, 2009 12:53pm PDT

    Go Natasha!

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 42

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?