Love + Sex

Friday, May. 16, 2008

Leading cancer experts call for males to share the responsibility for HPV Prevention

DM_Immunization_5357836.jpg
While America is still deciding whether girls should routinely get HPV vaccinations, an expert from Cancer Research UK is calling for boys to be vaccinated too. “It is a bad public health message to be giving out that you should only vaccinate girls and not boys against a sexually transmitted disease,' said Dr Anne Szarewski, a clinical consultant for Britain’s leading cancer charity, in an interview with GP Magazine.


In trials Gardasil, an HPV vaccination manufactured by Merk & Co., was found to be 100% effective against the four most common strains of HPV, which cause 70% of cervical cancers and 90% of genital warts. The drug received FDA approval in June of last year, but states are still struggling to implement vaccination programs because of pressure from the conservative right who are concerned that vaccinating young girls against HPV will somehow encourage promiscuity (which is akin to saying seat belts encourage road accidents).


The issue of vaccinating boys is all the more relevant since many states are including opt out clauses in their HPV vaccination legislation; In a country where religious convictions prevent so many girls from getting the lifesaving vaccination, it becomes all the more important to vaccinate as many potential carriers as possible, with males being described as a ‘hidden reservoir’ for the disease. In addition, studies with rubella found that it was only when males were vaccinated too that a herd immunity developed.


It is estimated that men and women have an 80% lifetime risk of contracting HPV. As well as protecting against cervical cancer and genital warts, the HPV vaccine can also prevent both anal and penile cancers. And a recent John Hopkins study found that HPV infection via oral sex was the leading cause of throat cancer, which affects 11,000 Americans each year, adding further weight behind the argument to approve the vaccination for use in males, and include young men in public HPV vaccination programs.

[Ed note: See also "Infuriating, bogus claim: HPV vaccine promotes sexual promiscuity"]



www.dailymantra.com

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 19
  • kat81886's Avatar
    Posted by kat81886 Fri May 9, 2008 7:50am PDT

    I strongly agree that BOTH women and men should get the HPV vaccine. Acouple years ago, I was diagnosed with HPV. I was dumbfounded mainly because I had never heard of the virus; however, I have educated myself thoroughly since then about this virus. Men are the main carrier of HPV which means they will not get the symptoms but can pass it on to every woman and man they have sexual intercourse with. So, giving a man the choice to be vaccinated or not is a great idea!

    Report Abuse
  • beautiful_curse07's Avatar
    Posted by beautiful_curse07 Fri May 9, 2008 8:22am PDT

    I am 18 and i have been diagnosed with dysplasia and hpv. And my fiance that i have been with for a year now was the carrier. If the vaccine was available for men to take then we could have avoided this situation completely.

    Report Abuse
  • Kelly's Avatar
    Posted by Kelly Fri May 9, 2008 8:33am PDT

    I think there should be something out there that tests/prevents HPV from being passed from the male. Currently they don't test for HPV in males so they never know if they have it. Even in a full STD test, HPV is not included when it comes to males. There needs to be a way to test this.

    Unfortunately, HPV can stay dormat in your system for a few years before you get any symptoms so you will never really know which sexual partner you transmitted it from.

    Report Abuse
  • Strawberry's Avatar
    Posted by Strawberry Fri May 9, 2008 9:36am PDT

    I recently had the leap surgery and came very close to cervical cancer. I know my boyfriend has the hpv so yeah i think he should have the shot as well. Its already showing again and if he had the shot i think it would lower my chances of getting cervical cancer even more...

    Report Abuse
  • Amy Ann's Avatar
    Posted by Amy Ann Fri May 9, 2008 10:23am PDT

    Um, I thought that the HPV vaccine was only effective for women and last I heard since the vaccine is so young that it is iffy as to what it's effects are on girls. I mean, wouldn't we want to see what the effects are on boy in clinical trials before we start claiming sexism? These are kids we are talking about here. The industry and the public should not be so damn gungho about making our youth into guinea pigs.

    Report Abuse
  • KBB's Avatar
    Posted by KBB Fri May 9, 2008 11:03am PDT

    This is basic disease prevention. In order to limit/erradicate the disease as many people as possible should be vaccinated. A vaccine is a preventative measure, not a cure, so people need to be vaccinated BEFORE they contract the disease. If this was not a sexually transmitted disease I don't think there would be any argument. I'm glad there is finally some public discussion about this. Some boys are getting vaccinated. I applaud them and their parents for doing their part to prevent the spread of this disease.

    Report Abuse
  • Kev's Avatar
    Posted by Kev Fri May 9, 2008 7:36pm PDT

    i think std's and all that r nasty, if people would jus wait until marriage there wouldn't b any problem. they're gonna find out more about how more and more diseases causes cancers. ewww

    Report Abuse
  • Barbarian's Avatar
    Posted by Barbarian Sat May 10, 2008 6:16am PDT

    Do a search on HPV vaccinations and death. Check on the real numbers of women that would be saved with this stuff. Vaccinating the boys is ludicrous. All this is is a money maker for big pharma. All they really care about is profits.

    Report Abuse
  • tndrhrt516's Avatar
    Posted by tndrhrt516 Sat May 10, 2008 11:41am PDT

    I agree. It is irresponsible to vaccinate only the girls. Boys can get it too, and pass it on. This is not a gender based disease. Both sexes can catch it.

    Report Abuse
  • tndrhrt516's Avatar
    Posted by tndrhrt516 Sat May 10, 2008 11:43am PDT

    I agree. It is irresponsible to vaccinate only the girls. Boys can get it too, and pass it on. This is not a gender based virus. Both sexes can catch it.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 19

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up