Love + Sex

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Should I Breakup with My College Boyfriend?

Dear Em & Lo,

Some may call us v-card clingers, but my boyfriend and I have been together for three years now. Giving our virginity to each other was not our first first--we were incredibly inexperienced before meeting. Although the relationship began out of lust it has blossomed into much more. He's my best friend, and without him I would be devastated. We currently attend the same college, and I sometimes feel as if my potential (sexual, personal, academic) can sometimes be limited by our relationship. I have passed on opportunities to study abroad, to fully explore my sexuality in my prime, and to make male friends. I am the type of person who is tortured by the "what-ifs." I just want to know if there are any solutions where I can have the best of both worlds--a loving relationship with my best friend and the maximization of my potential.

-- I Want a Pony Too


Dear IWAPT,

"V-card clingers" -- that's good! But if you have a loving, satisfying relationship that works for both of you, then it's not clinging, it's just common sense.

Unfortunately, your letter sure sounds like you're not quite satisfied. We're all for serious, long-term commitments, even among young adults like yourselves. But there's something to be said for opening yourself up to new experiences in college. We certainly don't see why a committed relationship means you can't study abroad or make male friends -- just because you're occasionally connected at the hip in bed doesn't mean you should be connected at the hip.

Of course, there is a chance that spending less time with each other will only fuel your sexual curiosity -- out of sight, out of mind, into someone else's pants. And having sex with other people while in a committed relationship can get a little tricky. Unless you have an open relationship, it's not going to work. You can certainly try to negotiate that kind of situation with your boyfriend, so you can have your cake and eat it too, but it takes a certain breed of evolved, jealousy-free human to make that work and you don't find many of them in college. (Drunk douches who never commit on the other hand...)

More...

We'd recommend just taking a break, with the understanding that you're free to see other people, and the option of getting back together if you can't live without each other. Actually, that option always exists -- and almost every advice column and your mother will tell you that if it's meant to be, you'll eventually end up together, even after some time apart. Which is just code for "you're too young to be so serious so break up with him!" Chances are you won't end up back together, but that's not a good enough reason to indefinitely stick with this guy. You've got a lot of living to do before you settle down and get married, and you're certainly not going to get hitched to this guy without ever taking a break, right? (Talk about a lifetime of what-ifs!) So why postpone the inevitable, especially when you're in an environment with so many awesome opportunities to take advantage of? (Seriously, hooking up will never be easier than it is in school.)

But be warned: You WILL have regrets about breaking up with an awesome guy who loved you, especially when you start exploring your sexuality with those drunken douches. And when you see him holding someone else's hand. And when you just want to watch a movie and cuddle. On second thought...

Em & LoMORE FROM EM & LO:

photo by jeroen_bennink

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 38
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Mon Nov 9, 2009 2:32pm PST

    Geezus, people, if true love is love, it will remain it, NEVER EVER pass up opportunities like traveling to other countries, or a good job, etc, I hate it when people put their life on hold for someone, you should not have to do it, especially being young, take that studying abroad opportunity! Um why aren't you allowing yourself to have male friends? That sounds extreme, you should be able to have male and female friends and gasp! A life out of your boyfriend, what is up with that? Here in this state, it is some kind of pattern that once you are dating, everyone stops having a life and all friends are supposed to disappear while you are dating, this is soo wrong and why relationships fizzle out, you are allowed to have your own life and old life, of course you are goint 2 want to spend time with this person, but you shouldn't have to give up your passions, wow, I have been writing books lately LOL! If you keep suppressing yourself, you will grow to hate him, and while the other side isn't always greener, you should meet different peoples.

    Report Abuse
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Mon Nov 9, 2009 2:34pm PST

    Also, why do you want to sleep with other men? If you two are open, why not experiment together?

    Report Abuse
  • Teenie's Avatar
    Posted by Teenie Mon Nov 9, 2009 3:19pm PST

    I can so relate to your situation, having been with my boyfriend since we were 17 (we are now 26), and were eachothers firsts in many ways as well. Although I have felt th same pangs of regret when I hear about friends traveling abroad, or the different guys they have dated, and wondered who would I be if I hadn't been in this relationship for so many years, at the end of the day I know the grass may seem greener, but it is not. When I think of all the wonderful things we have shared together, and all the heartache I have been spared from, and all the love that has steadily continued in its place, I never regret sticking with him for all these years.

    I find it fun to live vicariously through my single girfriends and hear about all their crazy antics, but I love knowing that at the end of the day I can fall asleep in the arms of a man who I know loves every part of me without condition, and I would not trade that for any other "life experience".

    Report Abuse
  • E. Boost's Avatar
    Posted by E. Boost Mon Nov 9, 2009 3:19pm PST

    Reading this letter made me feel lucky that my boyfriend and I are not attending the same college. Even if we are in the same city, see each other at least 2-3 days in a week, I think that gives us enough space for our own things. People do change, especially when you reach college- I am going through it and I see myself changing a lot. I want to try new things, and go to new places, but I will def. love to go along with my boyfriend If I can. I know whatever happens, I will support him and he will support me. If something is meant for you, it will not leave your life- and if it ever does, it will come back to you. Now for my own personal advice to this girl (if she ever does read this) is to take a break! Go out on dates and remember why you fell in love with this guy. Remember all of your good times and learn to see the pros in people, not the cons. When it comes to having guy friends, I'm sure you can meet guys on your campus or make nice friends even if you're in a relationship. It doesn't mean you will sleep with them or be flirty with the wrong intentions. Unless your guy is extremely jealous, I doubt you will have a problem. It seems like you two are attached at the hip; which is nice but yes, we all need space. Maybe you guys can have a weekend thing, or start by having 2-3 days apart and spend those days doing the stuff you both like-alone.

    I wish you best of luck, breaking up is hard, and unfortunately, we never see what we had, until it's gone. And then it's really hard to form that again. Love is truly like a plant, you can nourish it but when you finally stop and don't care for it, it won't ever be the same plant again. It can try to nourish and grow again, but you will probably never feel the same for it again. I'm not saying it's not impossible, many relationships can work out with counseling, healing, time together, etc. But the thing is, that most people don't bother to try. Most people jump to break ups and divorces over silly things. If you truly care for a person, you will try and fight whatever comes between you.

    My boyfriend and I made a promise to each other. We will fight anything in our way, and everyone that tries to come between us. Any obstacles, together, always. Fighting through it. The day one of us loses hope, is the day we lose our battle. At that point, we either get up and keep fighting or walk away.

    Report Abuse
  • Coug Girl's Avatar
    Posted by Coug Girl Mon Nov 9, 2009 3:36pm PST

    You're still young, and you don't want to regret not doing things because you feel your relationhsip held you back. But you can't have your cake and eat it too. You either need to stick out the relationship and forget about the "what ifs," or you need to let go and spread your wings. Personally, I would elect for the wing spreading because there is a world out there and plenty of options, but don't wrongfully string around your boyfriend because you feel obligated to.

    Report Abuse
  • M22's Avatar
    Posted by M22 Mon Nov 9, 2009 3:45pm PST

    If he's for real, he will support you in your decision to pass abroad or even move with you. Sounds to me like you are torn by the what ifs, are happy with him, but feel like perhaps you may be happier with someone else, or he is holding you back. My suggestion is to do whatever it is that makes you happy, with or without him. If he is the one he will tag along. Of course do this in a curteous way. Keep in mind that if you meet another who you may be attracted to, you must ask yourself wether or not it is worth it. If you are in love with the man you are with, you may want to consider learning why you were attracted to someone else and apply it to your man, talk to him...

    Communication is key. See how he feels. Never ever let a man hold you back. We meet our soulmates when we follow our hearts and do what we love.

    Report Abuse
  • Mysterious Gryphon's Avatar
    Posted by Mysterious Gryphon Mon Nov 9, 2009 4:14pm PST

    Wow. Why did you give up studying abroad - so you could babysit his male butt? Boys who think that they can "allow" their girlfriends to have separate experiences SUCK. Drop him.

    Okay, and now I will be nicer. I had a friend when I was on my study abroad who had actually gone there *with* her boyfriend. They had different host families and went to different American schools, but they hung out every night and had the chance to meet each other's new friends. It worked out well and they didn't have to give up anything to do it.

    Report Abuse
  • Irene's Avatar
    Posted by Irene Mon Nov 9, 2009 5:16pm PST

    Hmmm...have you even broached the subject with your boyfriend? It is quite possible that he may be having similar thoughts. Just ask him casually if he ever feels that he is missing out on some key aspects of the college experience because he is in a relationship with you? This should open the topic up for discussion. Be honest with him and tell him what/how you are feeling. If the two of you are able to have an honest and open discussion about the issues of concern, then perhaps, the two of you can make some adjustments and compromises in your current relationship. If, on the other hand, the topic causes your boyfriend to get angry, accusatory or jealous and he is unable to understand your perspectives or have a reasonable discussion...then break up with him and go on a solo adventure!

    Report Abuse
  • Missy's Avatar
    Posted by Missy Mon Nov 9, 2009 6:26pm PST

    Why are you misssing opportunities to travel? If he truly supported you-you would be able to study, travel, have male friends..etc(everything but sleeping with other people. I am in a committed relationship and in college myself, and I have my bf's blessing to do anything. And I don't have that urge to want to be with other people. However, I agree that maybe yyou should spend some time apart. *In absence the heart grows fonder.

    Report Abuse
  • Heidi's Avatar
    Posted by Heidi Mon Nov 9, 2009 7:22pm PST

    Im on a study abroad right now and also am in a committed relationship. It has done wonders for us! We miss each other so much and it has proven how strong our relationship is. I am having a great experience and i thank everyday that he is so willing to give a little bit of time without me in order for me to grow. A relationship based on working love should be able to last anything you may want to do such as a study abroad. Love should advance your life not hinder it!

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 38

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Help! My close friend keeps flirting with my spouse!