Love + Sex

Saturday, November 28, 2009

The Guilt Bank: Why Someone is Always in Relationship Debt

user

New ways couples divide household duties -- and why someone is always in debt
by Marissa Rothkopf Bates

Let me start off by saying, my husband is a very, very nice man. Sweet and thoughtful, he's even been known to buy me flowers on occasion. I lucked out in the husband department.

But when I am an overtired, often-cranky, stressed mess (which is a lot of the time, I'll admit), even Prince Charming himself would annoy me. His horse would be too stompy, or his crown would get in the way. More than likely, I'd be jealous he had all that time to look after his appearance.

My husband tries to soothe me in these moments. He suggests yoga, or a nap, or a walk around the block. Like I said, he's very nice. But this niceness appears to come with a price.

The cost: Points.

Now, just as a refresher, let's discuss how the point system works. Simply put: Your Loving Partner offers to let you unload one of your tasks onto him. Or perhaps he suggests you take an hour or two off and have a pedicure/curl up with a book/lock yourself in the basement cupboard. These may be offered with the most generous of spirits. He knows that a relaxed woman is a better wife and mother. He knows that if you have to juggle one more thing it's going to get seriously ugly. He wants to help. He may even be really nice about it, like my husband.

But beware. You're going to owe him.

That hour spent getting a pedicure will come back to haunt you. Those nights he lets you get your beauty rest when Junior squalls will cost you. Sometimes it will be overt: "You got to take a nap, now I'm going to watch football for the rest of the afternoon." Or it may be subtle. Men don't tend to ask for permission to go off and surf the Internet for 45 minutes. You do, I bet. Am I right? And then you feel guilty. And then he ends up earning points for helpful behavior.

When the kids were little babies and even less sleeping went on, we were really tit-for-tat. I finally lost it one day when I returned home from the grocery store. As soon as I was in the door, my husband poured himself a cup of coffee and slunk off to watch soccer. When I—left with six bags of groceries to unload, dinner, to make and a wide-awake infant—questioned his whereabouts, he replied that I had my break, and now he needed his. He had cashed in his points earned only moments before.

And this is when I explained something very important. Going to the grocery store is not a break. It may be easier for me to go by myself. I may enjoy a cup of coffee as I stroll the aisles, or a few minutes of leisurely People magazine reading as I wait to pay for the groceries—but it is still a household chore.

But that didn't matter in the end, because I still felt badly that he had "covered for me" so I could go out. In the end, this points system that has become part of our lives ends up benefiting him. If this were truly a bilateral arrangement, it would be fair. But it's not. While my husband earns points and keenly cashes them in, I just seem to acquire guilt.

Maybe I feel guilt because that's just who I am. Maybe I feel guilt because I am a woman. Maybe it's because of the woman I am. It doesn't matter that I can't do it alone: Somehow I feel I should be able to. That's why the point system exists. That's why it's so insidious.

I have modernized every other aspect of my life as a woman. But I somehow can't seem to shake the guilt that comes with getting help. And I vow right here and now to commit the ultimate woman's liberation: kiss the guilt goodbye and kick the points system out of our marriage.

Just after I ask my husband if it's okay if I go and get a pedicure.

Do you and your spouse operate on a "points system"? Tell us about it in the comments below.

Related Links:

More Love and Sex on Facebook! Follow us here!
Is Money Hurting Your Relationship?
She's The Breadwinner, He's Not Happy
You're Perfect But...

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-2 of 2
  • Sandy's Avatar
    Posted by Sandy Tue Nov 3, 2009 6:43am PST

    Guess I thought relationships were built on wanting to share responsibility and give and take. Guess after reading this I'm wrong....if you help someone out, they 'owe' you. Wow....maybe you married the wrong man, no matter how sweet and kind he may have appeared. With that way of thinking...I'm going to send all my kids a letter listing all the things they NEED to do for me now because of all the time I gave to them and all I got was a slammed door or dirty look. Most times now they tell me they love me, but those teenage years were not always pleasant. They now OWE me....BIG TIME. I'm also going to sit down and write out a list of all the things I like to do in a relationship and put a price tag on it...and when I meet that right man...I'm going to hand him that list and tell him....go ahead, pick any of those things you'd like to do on there, and then choose which payment plan you'd like...I'm sure we can work something out. That would take all the guess work out of the whole arrangement now wouldn't it, plus, it'd stop the wondering as to whether this new man would be willing to 'give' you what you are 'owed'. I've really learned something here....this could be the start of a whole new way of dating. Relationship menu's with payment plans....kinda catchy isn't it?

    Report Abuse
  • Sandy's Avatar
    Posted by Sandy Tue Nov 3, 2009 6:59am PST

    Sorry about the harshness...but this just struck a chord with me. I've always thought it was better to give than to receive. Not be taken advantage of, no one should EVER be taken advantage of, but not hold up a scorecard to see who has given more than the other. Who's turn is it to _________. (fill in the blank). At the end of the day, I'd rather be saying...wow, I had a fun day, or today sucked, but tomorrow will be better. I don't want to think...ok, I made dinner, took care of the kids, helped the oldest with homework, folded laundry....so now my husband OWES me the time to go get a pedicure. And stand in the bathroom washing my face and brushing my teeth before bed with a pencil and paper with tally marks on it. Then when I slide into bed next to him that night and he tries to make advances...pull out that paper and say...sorry, you're on the owing side of the list tonight...sucks to be you, then roll over and turn off the light. I just don't see that as healthy. Making mental lists, comparing, holding the other person accountable for what and when they give to you....sounds a bit selfish, and maybe that is the reason for your guilt? Just a thought.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-2 of 2

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?