Love + Sex

Monday, November 30, 2009

User post: 4 Types Of Infidelity & How Affairs Help Marriage

Unless you're inclined towards polyamory, extramarital relations are generally frowned upon. Monogamy is accepted and expected; infidelity is harmful. Right? Not so fast, says Michael J. Formica, a Psychology Today blogger. In a post on the "Enlightened Living" blog, Formica makes the case that thinking about cheating—and even stepping out on your sweetie—can potentially help your relationship.

First Formica identifies four basic types of affairs: object affairs, sexual affairs, emotional affairs and full-blown secondary relationships. In object affairs the cheating partner neglects the relationship to focus on something else—work, a video game, an intense involvement in floral arrangement—to the detriment of his or her love life.

A sexual affair is exactly what it sounds like: the adulterer rents cheap hotel rooms for sex—but not emotional intimacy. A sexual affair is strictly about nookie, nothing more.

An emotional affair is when there's no smooching, but lots of sentiment. You're spending hours on IM with someone who's not your boyfriend, spilling your secrets to a woman who's not your wife, turning to someone else instead of your partner in times of need. Clearly not good for your primary relationship.

The last type of affair is the traditional kind of cheating, where you have two parallel partnerships that are both sexual and emotional, and it's this kind of liaison that Formica says can actually help a marriage.

First, he says, an affair can add fizz to a flat partnership—what was once stale gets refreshed by a new energy.

Second if you're having an affair you're probably doing it because you're missing something in your first relationship. If you analyze the affair you might be able to see what it is that you lack, and address that problem.

Finally, people tend to get into the same kind of relationship over and over again, but affairs are different—according to Formica they can be "a more authentic barometer for what we actually need in our relationships."

Right about now you're probably thinking this is one messed up dude who's just making excuses for cheating. But Formica qualifies his analysis:

The "good" that might come out of an affair is clearly not the affair or its potential consequences. But, as I often say, everything is material for change. If we look at our choices and examine ourselves in an honest and forthright way, we just might find one of the keys to prompt our own evolution. That evolution might lead us back to a more authentic relationship with our primary relationship, or it might lead us to a more authentic understanding of ourselves that leads us away from that primary relationship. Either way, there is positive growth.

Readers, what do you think? Can infidelity ever lead to positive change? Or is the damage wrought by cheating too harmful to ever be good?

Written by Sarah Harrison for YourTango.com

More From YourTango.com:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 18
  • L.B.'s Avatar
    Posted by L.B. Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:16pm PST

    Yeah, and crack don't smoke itself.

    Report Abuse
  • JOJO's Avatar
    Posted by JOJO Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:41pm PST

    Are you freakin kidding me my wife cheated on me 3 times oh yeh i was exstatic, what that does to a person is mind shredding!!!!!!!! all that made me want to do is do a lot of damage to the other people and that my friends is not good.i know it takes 2 but it only takes 1 to say no!!!! If you or your mate have to do that to one another then get the hell out of your marriage!!!!!!!!

    Report Abuse
  • frustrated20091's Avatar
    Posted by frustrated20091 Tue Jan 27, 2009 11:02am PST

    Mr. Formica is just trying to make excuses for cheating!! It truly disgusts me. Before I got married, I was in 2 different relationships where I found out that they were cheating on me with other women and couldn't understand why I broke it off. It's never appropriate to cheat on the person you are in a relationship with--it means that you don't respect them at all or truly care about them (i.e. healthwise or emotionally). It means that you shouldn't have made a commitment to be with one person in a relationship/marriage until you are ready to truly commit and foresake all others. That past relationship baggage can sometimes cause me to think he'll do the same--though I do trust him. I've always told my husband that if he ever wants to be with someone else that he should respect me enough to not drag me into bed with them. Make the clean break from me first. Don't ever think that he can have his cake and eat it too because that would truly crush me. I'll go away quietly and he can do whatever or have whomever makes him happy. I never forget how dirty I felt after I discovered they were sleeping with people when we were supposed to be exclusive. My husband and I made the commitment to each other emotionally, mentally and physically - without anyone else in the mix. And while sometimes he frustrates me with his quirks I love and respect him too much to ever cheat or stray. I put my faith in him and trust him to not cheat/stray either.

    Report Abuse
  • frustrated20091's Avatar
    Posted by frustrated20091 Tue Jan 27, 2009 11:02am PST

    Mr. Formica is just trying to make excuses for cheating!! It truly disgusts me. Before I got married, I was in 2 different relationships where I found out that they were cheating on me with other women and couldn't understand why I broke it off. It's never appropriate to cheat on the person you are in a relationship with--it means that you don't respect them at all or truly care about them (i.e. healthwise or emotionally). It means that you shouldn't have made a commitment to be with one person in a relationship/marriage until you are ready to truly commit and foresake all others. That past relationship baggage can sometimes cause me to think he'll do the same--though I do trust him. I've always told my husband that if he ever wants to be with someone else that he should respect me enough to not drag me into bed with them. Make the clean break from me first. Don't ever think that he can have his cake and eat it too because that would truly crush me. I'll go away quietly and he can do whatever or have whomever makes him happy. I never forget how dirty I felt after I discovered they were sleeping with people when we were supposed to be exclusive. My husband and I made the commitment to each other emotionally, mentally and physically - without anyone else in the mix. And while sometimes he frustrates me with his quirks I love and respect him too much to ever cheat or stray. I put my faith in him and trust him to not cheat/stray either.

    Report Abuse
  • Chick's Avatar
    Posted by Chick Sun Feb 1, 2009 8:06am PST

    This is just more quack Physchology, The damage this causes is far worst than any perceived benefit.

    Report Abuse
  • REI M's Avatar
    Posted by REI M Sun Feb 8, 2009 8:53am PST

    Can infidelity ever lead to positive change? Yeah!! It can get you to a divorce court quick before he gives you an STD or a baby to support!~ If you need to be with someone else to get your marriage off the rocks then you shouldn't be in the marriage in the first place. This man is an idiot and I really hope that all men don't think the same way.

    That's like saying when a car has an oil leak- "let's take it all apart, smash it piece by piece and then fix the leak" By the time you get to the problem there is nothing to save...you've killed the marriage.

    Report Abuse
  • FiorellaT's Avatar
    Posted by FiorellaT Sun Feb 8, 2009 2:28pm PST

    I'd rather walk out than cheat. It leaves bitter feelings, I know if my husband cheated on me for these reasons. I'LL HURT HIM BAD!!!!!!!!!

    Report Abuse
  • FiorellaT's Avatar
    Posted by FiorellaT Sun Feb 8, 2009 2:29pm PST

    Is he mentally impaired or what!!!! YEAH AND CRACK DOESN'T KILL!!!!!!!!?????

    Report Abuse
  • Mystery's Avatar
    Posted by Mystery Mon Feb 9, 2009 11:06am PST

    This article was the biggest load of BS that I have ever read. While we may live in an increasingly immoral society, that doesn't excuse immoral acts. The only thing adultery succeeds in doing is wrecking individual lives and marriages.

    There is never an excuse good enough for cheating. If you are married and want to cheat get a divorce. It's that simple. If you can't afford a divorce then you just have to accept your marital responsibilities until you can save up enough money to divorce.

    Report Abuse
  • A.WOODSZ's Avatar
    Posted by A.WOODSZ Mon Feb 9, 2009 11:18am PST

    yeah sure

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 18

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?