Love + Sex

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Why He Dumped You: 5 Potential Reasons

It's been years since we all watched in horror as Jack Berger explained to Miranda she would never hear from the guy she was hoping would call her back. That guy was, in fact, just not that into her. "Fascinating," Miranda told Berger. "Tell me more."

The Sex and The City episode that started the whole He's Just Not That Into You bandwagon has yet to lose speed. In fact, women are more eager than ever to get to the bottom of why they were dumped. Dumped? 10 Healthy Ways To Heal

No longer content to just smile and start over, women want answers from the men who waved them goodbye. Luckily, one male writer was brave enough to tell Cosmopolitan why men break up with women. Inspired by the article, we've added a few of our own theories to why guys dump girls they dig. Most of the time, it really isn't you, it's him, his friends and his stage in life. Seriously.

1. Bad timing.

If we had a dime for every time the timing was off for something—the subway, the stock market, the Superbowl—we'd be rich. Men claim, however, that timing is everything when it comes to settling down. There seems to be a specific time in a man's life when he thinks all his ducks are in order and only then is he ready to get serious. If you catch a guy before he thinks he's ready for long-term, he's likely to think he needs a little more money in the bank, a better position with the company or just a few more one-night stands before he gets exclusive. Sure, he won't say all of this outright, he'll just blame the breakup on bad timing.

2. His best friend just got married.

Men tend to freak out when the first of their pals start settling down. Especially if that pals is their best friend since grade school who just got hitched to a woman they've now taken to calling, "The b---- ." Don't be surprised if you find yourself suddenly single as soon as your boyfriend's friends start getting married. He's simply in shock over loosing his drinking buddies and he doesn't want to put the concept of married in your head as well until he's damn well ready. Read: 5 Things He Doesn't Think You Can Handle

3. He's too into you.

According to Cosmopolitan, guys are protective of their emotions.

"So, if we start to feel like we're getting into a situation where we'll be destroyed if you dump us," admits one male expert, "we might launch a preemptive strike and yank the plug first." Sound phony? Perhaps men are the sensitive creatures we so desperately want them to be. Perhaps they, too, worry about falling hard for a woman who seems too good to be true. If you are that woman, you should spend five seconds congratulating yourself for being too perfect and then promptly move on to a man who isn't such a baby.

4. You're too maternal/not maternal enough.

Speaking of babies, men don't melt at the sight of a small child quite in the same way some women do. If a man thinks you're treating him too much like a baby or have housekeeping and other assorted domestic desires too much on your mind, he's likely to akin you to his mother and not his lover. On the other hand, if you reject anything that has to do with feeding, grooming or taking care of him, he may think that a long-term relationship with you will be like living in a bachelor pad without the Playboy subscription. A man may love a woman who can cook but also wants a woman who is willing to get down and dirty, minus the Mr. Clean, if you know what we mean. The balance between domestic goddess and sexual diva is difficult to obtain. Tilt the scales just so, and he's likely to trash the relationship.

5. His best friend saw you first.

Men don't gossip the same way that women do. If your boyfriend finds out one of his pals had a crush on you or worse, hooked up with you before he called first dibs, he will forfeit the game without putting up a fight. It's fine if his friends think you're hot, occasional jealousy is even welcomed, but sloppy seconds or stealing someone else's girl is a total man rule that is never meant to be broken. It's easier to date a woman that your friend can only dream about seeing naked than suffer with the knowledge that his best friend saw you first.

Need advice on how to deal with your breakup? Ask YourTango and get real-time responses to your questions!

Read More From YourTango:
Written by Anne-Marie Scali for YourTango.com
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 61
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Thu Jul 23, 2009 9:09am PDT

    You are crazy LOL

    Report Abuse
  • Melissa's Avatar
    Posted by Melissa Thu Jul 23, 2009 11:32am PDT

    I do believe they act on number 3.

    Report Abuse
  • lizzy's Avatar
    Posted by lizzy Thu Jul 23, 2009 11:56am PDT

    I am a victim of #5.

    I knew this guy (he worked for the same company I work for). Unknown to me, he liked me more than a friend. Well, some time later, I met his friend. We completely hit it off! It was seriously the best first date I have EVER had. We talked as though we've known each other for years; perfect chemistry. Although he did mention a couple of times that his friend really liked me and wanted to date me, even though his friend never asked me out on a date. Well, lo and behold, that was back in March. We are in July now, and no, I am not dating the guy I had the amazing first date with. I am still single. And aggravated with the whole situation. I am frustrated; I've tried to go on other dates, but I always seem to compare it to that awesome first date I had. None of them come close. I know I sound pathetic, but it's the truth.

    Report Abuse
  • Guadalupe's Avatar
    Posted by Guadalupe Thu Jul 23, 2009 12:27pm PDT

    you guys are crazy.

    Report Abuse
  • petite's Avatar
    Posted by petite Thu Jul 23, 2009 12:31pm PDT

    Silly...... I'll add one reason : You are not hot or he finds someone hotter than you

    Report Abuse
  • get with the program's Avatar
    Posted by get with the program Thu Jul 23, 2009 2:24pm PDT

    THIS from the same author who writes "Etiquette For Oral Sex"?????? lmao Uhm, no other comment.

    Report Abuse
  • KittyKat's Avatar
    Posted by KittyKat Thu Jul 23, 2009 5:27pm PDT

    Why does YourTango still write for yahoo shine cuz I'm sorry but they dont make no sense.

    Report Abuse
  • Claire's Avatar
    Posted by Claire Thu Jul 23, 2009 5:40pm PDT

    i suspect that in a few cases it was #3, but isn't that what "he's not that into you" is trying to tell you DOESN'T happen?

    Report Abuse
  • fools_and_sages's Avatar
    Posted by fools_and_sages Thu Jul 23, 2009 6:39pm PDT

    Basically, it all comes down to he's too immature to handle an adult relationship. And what woman needs Baby Huey?

    If he's going to freak over the fact that his friends are getting married, he's too into you, or he's set in his ways or not set enough yet,then he's not ready for commitment., If he lives by the "dibs" system, then neither he nor his best friend have any long-term potential in my book because I don't want to feel like the first guy who yelled "SHOTGUN" won me. Lack of maturity is his problem, not mine. I don't want to be involved with a guy who is incapable of being a mature adult in any way, shape, or form. So, no skin off my nose there if he dumps me. In fact, odds are I dumped him before her could dump me.

    If he's going to dump me because I'm not doing enough to take care of him, I don't have an issue with that either. I don't get involved to be a man's f*ck doll, maid, secretary, or mama. I work 40-60 hours a week, volunteer, and have friends. If he expects to do nothing but go to work and come home to a perfectly clean house, with dinner ready when he walks through the door, clean clothes ready all the time, and me wearing nothing but a smile and ready to totally dote on him, he's not living in reality. If he expects me to keep track of his appointments and mine, he needs to get a date book or learn to use outlook. He's an adult. He should be able to feed and clean himself, help with chores, and keep track of his own schedule. If he requires inordinate amounts of maternal care, odds are I dumped him before he even thought of dumping me anyways.

    And, if I'm involved with a guy who does any of these things, then somebody needs to shoot me. THESE GUYS are the reason I stopped dating. I can't find a man who doesn't expect to be tended to like he's an infant who requires sex on demand. And I won't put up with that crap. I would rather be alone than play mama, wh*re, secretary, and maid to a man.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Thu Jul 23, 2009 7:46pm PDT

    anywayssss this is a bunch of bull.if he leaves,who cares.life changes can be for the best:)

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 61

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?