Wednesday, February 10, 2010

3 reasons why gift cards are a terrible idea this year

Getty Images

Getty Images

Even though they're admittedly pretty lame presents, gifts cards have become a staple of the holiday season. They're a quick fix, perfect for when you absolutely have to buy something for someone but only have a superficial understanding of what that person likes—be it movies, electronics, or, in the case of my grandmother's boyfriend, prescription drugs (the man loves CVS gift cards, at least I think he does). Gift cards say, "I care enough to not just give you money, but not quite so much to figure out who you really are."  It's a little sad, but it works.

However, this year, every lazy man's favorite gift, the buy-20-bucks-worth-of-crap-at-this-store plastic credit, may be in trouble. 

According to astory today on MSN Money, consumers are poised to lose around $75 million in gift cards this year due to rampant company bankruptcies. That's because when a restaurant or store chain declares bankruptcy, cardholders, for the most part, have no rights and card values are completely wiped out. So, anyone with a gift credit for a place like the Sharper Image, Circuit City, or Bennigan's, is basically carrying the worth of my student ID card from 1992.

That's the first reason to avoid gift cards.

The second is, even if the company remains open, in this incredibly shaky economy many of its locations may shut down, making it inconvenient for your gift recipient to redeem his or her card. Stores like Pier 1, Disney, Loews, Foot Locker, and even Macys are all rumored to close outposts this year.

But the last reason to stop giving gift cards might be the most important: People don't use them.

The MSN story reports that one in four 2007 holiday gift card recipients hadn't used their present by October 2008, and that an estimated $8 billion in gift cards sold last year has yet to be spent. Even when the cards do get cashed in, high fees and strict expiration dates often render them useless.

So, what does this mean for us lazy gift givers? Sadly, it appears we should all stop with the "thoughtful" plastic card ruse and just give cash in a cheesy Santa card. Or actually think about what we're giving this year and buy people something they might actually love and use. (See our gift guide for ideas.)

For an interesting list of major company's gift card rules, check out this survey from creditcards.com.

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 53
  • MochaMama42's Avatar
    Posted by MochaMama42 Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:08am PST

    Very true. I have a JCrew gift card for $20 that I've NEVER used; I like the store, I just don't think about the gift card.

    Report Abuse
  • MissK's Avatar
    Posted by MissK Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:15am PST

    I can't believe people don't use gift cards. It's all I can do to not leave Christmas early to go shopping right then and there. Believe me, they are gone before new year's every time.

    Report Abuse
  • Black Cat's Avatar
    Posted by Black Cat Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:21am PST

    Its true that since many companies filed bankruptcy and will probably close their stores, that giving a gift card doesn't make much sense these days. But, don't knock gift cards because you think someone doesn't know the person their giving it to. So what? I've given gift cards to my family and close friends - who love them b/c they'd rather go shopping for themselves then have me pick out something that's too big/small, or not exactly their taste. I mean, I'm me - not my sister!

    Report Abuse
  • Renaissancegirl's Avatar
    Posted by Renaissancegirl Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:35am PST

    I love gift cards! I can go get exactly what I want in the color and size that I need. I mean, my dad knows I love to read and I love perfume, but he has no idea what fragrance I like or what latest novel I want to check out, so a gift card is the perfect gift for me. I don't think they are thoughtless at all. As far as all those people who never use their gift cards, send them my way! I'll make sure they get spent! LOL

    Report Abuse
  • Jenn K's Avatar
    Posted by Jenn K Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:52am PST

    I've never had trouble using gift cards for stores either. Come the after Christmas sales I'm there! But cards for restuarants and such those are the ones I tend to forget about for some reason... and its not like I don't like to eat, haha.

    Report Abuse
  • mom of 3's Avatar
    Posted by mom of 3 Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:54am PST

    i actually ASK for gift cards, save me the hassle of return, my favorite is Target, and if my kids need something more than me, i can use it for them, instead of a trinket that will just collect dust in my apt!

    Report Abuse
  • pixie's Avatar
    Posted by pixie Mon Nov 24, 2008 9:58am PST

    Let's first of all start out saying my family only wanted gift cards this year,and no they are not lame,everyone can use a gift card to get what ever they want. Second most stores have online stores so even if a location in your area goes out of business you can still use the card online. And really now not many big name place are going out of business or filing for bankruptcy. The cards I got are pretty damn safe,Target,Lowe's, Bass Pro!!! So don't poo poo my Festivus!!! I'm sure gift card are safe. Stop instilling unneeded fear in people,calm down,don't freak out, buy gift cards and be merry.

    Report Abuse
  • Jezabel's Avatar
    Posted by Jezabel Mon Nov 24, 2008 10:24am PST

    Personally I would prefer good old-fashioned cash in my Xmas cards. No ties to one store, no ill-fitted sweaters in putrid colors bought at TJ Maxx, no silver plated jewlery that will never see the light of day, no perfumes that can bring the dead back to life, no dvds so lame you can't regift without the risk of ending a friendship.

    Yep give me those Bennies any birthday or holiday and trust me you are nothing short of the greatest relative ever. For some reason though people have it in their heads its a tacky present, but why? I mean if you're going to spend $40 dollars on my gift, why get something I will most likely hate when I can take the $40 and spend it on something I like. I mean think about it if you have 5 people giving you gifts that total $20 each you would have $100 right there. I can think of a million ways to better spend that $100 than ways to wear the rudolf sweater (which is going to the salvation army).

    Report Abuse
  • Lolo's Avatar
    Posted by Lolo Mon Nov 24, 2008 10:30am PST

    while i can see the truth in the three reasons not to do gift cards. you're pretty high on your horse to say how thoughtless people are to give a giftcard in the first place!

    Report Abuse
  • WENDY's Avatar
    Posted by WENDY Mon Nov 24, 2008 10:36am PST

    Ugh one of the things I absolutely abhor are the friends and relatives that buy me lotions and bath washes. I can't use them and they know this! I have to end up giving the gift away to someone else!! I would much rather get a gift card to Wal-Mart or Target than get something that I can't even use!

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 53

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

holiday gift byte

The greatest gift exchanges require thoughtfulness, listening, and really understanding who another person is and what they like and need—that's what I always strive for in giving and it's the only thing I hope for in receiving.