Tuesday, November 24, 2009

9 signs your friend is toxic

Susan Shapiro Barash, author of Toxic Friends: The Antidote for Women Stuck in Complicated Friendships, on how to tell when your friendship is unhealthy … and how to disengage.


The colloquial term "frenemy" was coined to describe a complicated relationship wherein a person causes a friend such pain and anguish that there is a blur between this person being your "friend" or "enemy." Why is it so hard to tell the difference between the two opposite words that society had to create a fuzzy word to describe a shade of gray? For one, our parents didn’t raise us with built-in "bad friend sensors" because our girlfriends are different to us than they were to our mothers or grandmothers, explains Susan Shapiro Barash, a nationally regarded gender expert and author of Toxic Friends: The Antidote for Women Stuck in Complicated Friendships , an upcoming tome on dealing with female relationships.

With advances in communication technologies, such as Skype and Facebook , women have been able to move farther away from their mothers and siblings in pursuit of their careers and families. And during the process, women sought the comfort of nearby friends on whom to depend, as though they shared the same DNA.

"My grandmother didn’t need a book like this,” Shapiro tells us. "Her family didn’t live three thousand miles away. Today, what women look for in female friendships is what they would look for in a relationship with their mother or sister."

Additionally, our grandmothers weren’t going to restaurants to meet with girlfriends to talk about their sex lives, careers and health. According to Barash, it appears that these types of gatherings grew from women who sought the deep connections seen on popular television series, such as "Sex & The City" and "Friends." Shows that highlighted female kinships that are just as strong — if not tighter — than family ties have become a model for real-life social circles and in turn women have grown to trust friends with very private matters. It’s also natural for women to turn to the comfort of friends when they grow older and lose their mothers, sisters and significant others.

Hence, friends have become a fabric of our lives — which also explains why it hurts us so when a friendship is fraught with confusion, heartache and tears. Let’s face it: A mean friend is just as scarring as a bad mother or husband. This is similar to the conclusion made by Barash, which compelled her to explore the key components of damaging relationships and also provide women advice on how to detect such harmful friendships. Here we asked Barash to share with us the signs of a toxic friendship — and how to disengage.

The 9 Signs You’re in a Toxic Friendship

1) Your friend is jealous of you. Jealousy is different than envy and the first can be very toxic for the relationship. Jealousy is: "I want what you have and I want you dead or disappeared." Envy is just: "I want what you have." A jealous friend will want to cut you out of her life because she really wants what you have and can’t stand to be around you anymore. An envious friend will want what you have, but will look to you as her inspiration or role model, and compete with you to get in the lead.

2) Your friend is a "doormat": It’s tiring to always be with someone who is so malleable.

3) Your friend wasn’t there for you. It’s sometimes hard to see if a friend is really a true pal until there is a life-changing moment in your life that requires the person’s support. This eye-opening event is called The Inciting Incident, which is when everything is going along fine, until wham! someone gets sick, or loses their job, or gets married or loses a loved one, and you find that the friend you thought would be by your side isn’t there for you at all. She doesn’t celebrate your good news nor does she help you in times of need. For some women it takes an "inciting incident" to finally notice that a friend is toxic.

4) Your friend is draining you: You feel you’re psychologically and emotionally giving all your energy to her and receiving nothing in return.

5) You don’t share the same values or the same world view: It’s a red flag that this isn’t the right friend for you if you don’t respect her for who she is. I interviewed a woman who wished her friend’s husband ill. It made the married woman realize that her friend’s behavior is nothing like her own. 

6) You are using one another: This type of toxic relationship develops among socialites. You want to be friends with your neighbor because your children attend the same private school and you can coordinate a carpool. Will the friendship last? Maybe. Is there really a friendship between the mothers or is it just using? Is it worth turning this friendship into anything more than an agreement?

7) The relationship offers no return on investment: This is similar to a friend who is draining you – but this isn’t just an emotional give and take. If you are the one calling your friend to make plans and going out of your way to be with her, but she makes no attempt to go out of her way for you, then she’s not meeting you halfway.

8) Your friend is harming someone else or doing something illicit. Do you want to be associated with someone who is morally unjust? That’s a judgment call on your part.

9) Your friend burdens you with a secret: Your friend trusts you by sharing the details of her affair, but keeping the secret has weighed on you emotionally. You might want to keep your distance. If you’re too close to this woman and the secret is really impacting your life for the worse, it’s time to disengage yourself.

How to Disengage: If any of these signs describes one of your friendships, it’s likely to be a toxic relationship that’s burdensome to not just your sanity but hers as well. You could deliberately distance yourself and let the relationship fizzle into oblivion. If you would like to renegotiate the relationship and improve the friendship, have an honest conversation to reveal how you feel. You’ll risk losing this person, but the reward could be improving the quality of the friendship. Honesty is the best policy. Say: "I’m really upset you didn’t do this and this. And I needed you there to do this and this."

Tell us: Is there a 10th sign of a toxic friend? Have you been in a toxic relationship? If so, how did you break it off?

More From wowOwow.com:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 380
  • Lucky's Avatar
    Posted by Lucky Fri Sep 11, 2009 12:03pm PDT

    #10 The friend never picks up the phone, always lets it go to voice mail and to add insult to injury, does not respond for 3-4 days. Like you are an after thought or just someone to call when she has nothing to do.

    Report Abuse
  • ShelleyBean's Avatar
    Posted by ShelleyBean Fri Sep 11, 2009 1:06pm PDT

    AHHHH my roomate is every single one of those except #2. I wouldn't necessarly call her a friend, more of an acquaintance but she is so toxic! How am I suppossed to Disengage from that relationship??

    Report Abuse
  • Sheila's Avatar
    Posted by Sheila Sat Sep 12, 2009 7:41am PDT

    Looking at this list there are a few numbers I can see happening with a friend. I was there when she needed me and my Friend was there when I needed her but, lately she has shut me out...divioce... doing things I do not understand. Never returning calls, never emails unless I do. Tells me she is changing, going through a hard time but, refuses me help or a chance to talk. She is hanging out with others now and I feel as though she has moved on. It's time I do too.

    Report Abuse
  • Tori's Avatar
    Posted by Tori Sat Sep 12, 2009 3:32pm PDT

    I tried to let a girl go because her morals didnt fit mine. I used #10 and she STILL hung around. The same for other people i did that to. It seems as if they hang around more if you try to ignore them. Sometimes you have to speak up. I had to.

    Report Abuse
  • Samantha Ann's Avatar
    Posted by Samantha Ann Sat Sep 12, 2009 9:58pm PDT

    OMG I have been dealing with this for the past year with my ex best friend of 20 years! In all that time, we never fought once either! So here is my number 10 based on what I went thru with her...

    #10-When your friend starts to date or gets engaged to a man that does not like you 2 hanging out. You know what I mean ladies? They don't want any single friends around there woman putting any advice in there ear. Esp. if your independent!! Well not only am I single but I'm very independent ! I have met her man once and he does not like me! The real reason is ...he knows I can see right thru him and that he isn't good for my close girlfriend. Now my old best friend acts like he has brain washed her!

    She wasn't there for me when I went thru hell last year but She got engaged and preg after 6 months of seeing him and totally cut me off. She posted the news on a blog! She didn't even call me to tell me herself! I was tore up over it! I wasn’t even asked to attend the wedding but I was asked to the baby shower but I didn’t go. I wasn’t asked by her and I still had not heard a word from her so why would I go? A few months ago out of no where she calls me when her child is born and leaves me a message saying she wants our friendship back and she wants to apologize and yada yada.. I took a while to think things over and she asked me to meet up with her so we could talk. I ended up forgiving her and things went well for a few weeks. Then she started to back out of plans at the last second and I was the one making the effort. She told me she didn’t have time to work on things so here I am burned again. Even tho I was so mad I just told her that all I could do was to be here even tho I didn’t understand why she was being this way. I quit trying and its been 3 months since she has reached out to me. I usually never let anyone back in after they hurt me so deeply... but I am trying to be more forgiving these days. I mean the ball is in her quart if she throws it back then I will make a decision but for now I try not to think about it. I don’t get why some people make friendship such a complicated thing

    Report Abuse
  • Chelsey's Avatar
    Posted by Chelsey Sun Sep 13, 2009 12:35pm PDT

    10. They put their boyfriend before you and lets the guy rule over them every time.

    Report Abuse
  • Hannah's Avatar
    Posted by Hannah Sun Sep 13, 2009 3:17pm PDT

    Well its nice to know that about HALF my friend are like this. i think it is time to stop drinking..

    Report Abuse
  • Southern Belle's Avatar
    Posted by Southern Belle Sun Sep 13, 2009 4:51pm PDT

    10 TH TOXIN-HAVING A BEST FRIEND IS A PART YOU DO NOT WANT YOUR ENTIRE FAMILY TO BE INVOLVED WITH EVERY DETAIL OF YOUR SECRET LIFE.YOU INTRODUCE THEM TO FRIENDS PRIOR TO THEM THEY NEVER KNEW ANY OF THEM BEFORE.ALL OF A SUDDEN THEY ACT AS THO THEY INTRDUCED YOU TO THEM.THEY GET CLOSE TO YOUR FAMILY,SHARE TOO MUCH OF YOUR PRIVATE LIFE.IF I WANTED ALL TO KNOW MY EVERY MOVE I'D TELL THEM.

    A GOOD FRIEND KNOWS YOU HAVE A LIFE AND THEY DON'T NEED TO BE INVOLVED IN ALL YOU DO.YOU,DIDN'T CALL ME BACK-EXPLAINING ALL-AS THO YOU'RE MARRIED.TOXIC BE MY FAMILY'S BEST FRIEND,I DO NOT TELL YOUR FAMILY MORE THAN HELLO AND GOOD CONVERSATION-NOT PRIVATE LIFE,THEN YOU'RE RIDICULED AND TELLING ABOUT YOUR FRIENDS AND OUTINGS THAT DON'T INVOLVE YOU....THERE'S YOUR SIGN.POISON..

    Report Abuse
  • laurarocks's Avatar
    Posted by laurarocks Mon Sep 14, 2009 6:35am PDT

    How about the friend whose opinion is always the right one, even if it's steeped in ignorance? Or the one who is overly critical about your life or decisions but turns a blind eye to her own?. I had a friend who was both, and it was so tiring to have a conversation with her. I am so glad I broke it off!

    Report Abuse
  • promise's Avatar
    Posted by promise Mon Sep 14, 2009 6:48am PDT

    someone who is ALWAYS trying to COMPETE. my "bff" since grade school was always trying to find ways to be "better" than me, she was more muscular than me (3 brothers) so she would always feel that she had to prove that. and she always had the better bike, the better grades, the better jokes even...

    and being POSSESIVE. this is what broke our 14 year friendship appart, when we were kids i could never have any other friends, if i wanted to be with just my family on the weekend instead of staying over at her house she would say "what the hell, i dont mean nothing to you?!" in highschool my family moved and we didnt keep in touch as often, so 5 yrs later i try to go visit her, when things didnt go according to plan exactly she freaked out and stopped talking to me

    im so mad at her, we are grown ups now and she hasnt changed one bit or matured at all. i dont know if we'll ever be friends again.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 380

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up