What Guys Don't Tell You About Your Shoes

A recent conversation with my boyfriend while shoe shopping:

Me: Do you like these buckles?

BF: (affirmative?) grunt

Me: Do these fit OK?

BF: shrug

Me: What do you think about the heel?

BF: blank stare

All I wanted was his opinion on a pair of riding boots, ones like these. Sounds simple, right? Wrong. Lesson learned: Never take BF shoe shopping, or so I thought …


That is, until my fellow editor Jane told me about this study where guys offered their opinions on shoes, and the women who wear 'em. It turns out they actually do notice our shoes. Surprise, surprise. It was so fascinating that we decided to try our own little study (see it here).


Let's just say, we got to the bottom of the guy/shoe equation. (One great male comment about booties? "Hoof feet." For real.) Click here to see the full report, or just scroll down to get started.


However, while this might have changed my mind about guys and shoes, I still think shoe shopping is better with a girlfriend. At least they don't grunt.


What Guys Think: Clogs

Score: 1 (on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being the worst)

The good:

"Looks cool, but must be difficult to walk in."

The bad:

"Hideous," "Not practical," "Looks painful," "You're going to break your neck."

The just plain weird:

"Reminds me of an African tribe."


What Guys Think: Mary Janes

Score: 2

The good:

"Simple and sensible."

The bad:

"Too plain," "Boring," "Looks like they'd go well with a school girl uniform," "Librarian," "Old lady."

The just plain weird:

"Matilda has a shoe line?"


What Guys Think: Booties

Score: 2

The good:

"She has a punk/goth sense of style."

The bad:

"Hey there, Elvira," "Trying too hard," "A little trashy," "Hoof feet," "Lacks class."

The just plain weird:

"Why is the big toe just hanging out there? I don't like when feet can give a thumbs up."


What Guys Think: Wedges

Score: 3

The good:

"Those are impressively high."

The bad:

"Are you kidding?" "Looks dangerous to walk in," "Ew, platforms," "Over the top."

The just plain weird:

"You ripped up the floorboards [to make these]!"


What Guys Think: Loafer flats

Score: 3

The good:

"Sensible," "Adventurous."

The bad:

"Tacky," "Secretly trying too hard," "Looks like something an older woman would wear."

The just plain weird:

"They definitely don't match the blue pants."

Click here to see the final 9 shoes and what our guys had to say about them.


More on BeautyRiot.com:

Quiz: What's Your Shoe Personality?

Best Boots for Your Body Type

We Test & Rate Online Fashion Clubs


For more fashion fun, follow us on Twitter and like us on Facebook.