Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    H&M and Wal-Mart destroy and trash unsold goods

    Cynthia Magnus holds up unworn, destroyed clothing she found in the garbage. Photo by Suzanne DeChillo/New York Times Cynthia Magnus holds up unworn, destroyed clothing she found in the garbage. Photo by Suzanne DeChillo/New York …This week the New York Times reported a disheartening story about two of the largest retail chains. You see, instead of taking unsold items to sample sales or donating them to people in need, H&M and Wal-Mart have been throwing them out in giant trash bags. And in the case that someone may stumble on these bags and try to keep or re-sell the items, these companies have gone ahead and slashed up garments, cut off the sleeves of coats, and sliced holes in shoes so they are unwearable.

    This unsettling discovery was made by graduate student Cynthia Magnus outside the back entrance of H&M on 35th street in New York City. Just a few doors down, she also found hundreds of Wal-Mart tagged items with holes made in them that were dumped by a contractor. On December 7, she spotted 20 bags of clothing outside of H&M including, "gloves with the fingers cut off, warm socks, cute patent leather Mary Jane school shoes, maybe for fourth graders, with the instep cut up with a scissor, men's jackets, slashed across the body and the arms. The puffy fiber fill was coming out in big white cotton balls."

    The New York Times points out that one-third of the city's population is poor, which makes this behavior not only wasteful and sad, but downright irresponsible. Wal-Mart spokeswoman, Melissa Hill, acted surprised that these items were found, claiming they typically donate all unworn merchandise to charity. When reporters went around the corner from H&M to a collections drop-off for charity organization New York Cares, spokesperson Colleen Farrell said, "We'd be glad to take unworn coats, and companies often send them to us."

    After several days of no response from H&M, the company made a statement today, promising to stop destroying the garments at the midtown Manhattan location. They said they will donate the items to charity. H&M spokeswoman Nicole Christie said, "It will not happen again," and that the company would make sure none of the other locations would do so either. Hopefully that's the final word. [NY Times][Huff Post]

     
    • Kathy W.  •  Columbia, Maryland  •  29 days ago
      I think logistics of labor and transportation should help like a shout out to charities to load and truck the stuff out. I am waiting for the dog and cat people to come forward for the animal bedding next. However humans first please.
    • pinky  •  Baltimore, Maryland  •  4 months ago
      The freaking human race sucks.No one ever ever thinks about the underprivileged. Tons of food is thrown out because no one will give it to the poor. I can't believe this at all.
      • FRANK E 4 months ago
        Food is thrown out, unfortunately it's true. However, it's become a liability issue there. People have a tendency to sue at the drop of a dime. And a first year law student can come up with a victim at the drop of a hat.
      • oranges 4 months ago
        PInky, nobody is going to give a crap about you and your obviously mediocre to pathetic life, and your an idiot for thinking they will.
      • Louise 4 months ago
        The freaking human race DOES suck, but not because tons of food is thrown OUT, but because ONE freaking idiot will try to sue because they SAID they got sick from the donated food. One bad apple...so to speak.
    • Dee  •  4 months ago
      This is a common practice for most retailers. It's similar to 'return to vendor.' Basically, retailers agree to purchase a set amount of a particular product from a vendor. In return, if the retailer doesn't sell at least X number of those units within a certain time frame, the vendor will credit the retailer the difference for the unsold units. Per the vendor/retailer contract, the retailer agrees to destroy and discard the merchandise instead of shipping it back. Per the agreements, retailers cannot donate, wholesale or resell the merchandise, lest they forfeit payment.

      While donating should definitely be considered, many non-profits won't always accept the items. Salvation Army and Goodwill have policies in place that state they won't accept donations of any clothing with statements or designs they deem objectionable or profane. Also, if there isn't a need for the item in question, they won't accept it.
      • Joe A 4 months ago
        Let's talk about Goodwill....the workers there go through the items that are donated and take what they want first before selling it at a discount to the needy. Nice huh. Also, we have a shelter in my town for battered women. Annually they put out a list of items that they need for their shelter, one year they were asking for cell phones, batteries, gas cards just to name a few. Their workers also take what they want first. So just who do you trust?
      • Val 4 months ago
        If you work at Goodwill, you ARE "the needy"!!! Goodwill is OK, at least they try to do some kind of good. Next you'll complain about the Salvation Army!

        Not working, Repukelican chump(s)!
      • Cathy 4 months ago
        I won't donate to Salvation Army any more. My friend needed some help so she wouldn't be evicted from her home. Her husband, who was disabled and needed full time care, which she provided, died. They had been living on his SS check. Salvation Army not only refused, but then had the nerve to tell her to call them when she was evicted so they could pick up her stuff and sell it - so they could help others! This is the truth.
    • Phyl E.R Upp  •  Bloomington, Indiana  •  4 months ago
      I am proud to say I have been boycotting Walmart for years. This company profitted by touting the fact that their merchandise was American Made. Then they ran every Mom & Pop store out of business. They forced American manufacturers to go overseas to keep costs down. Now most everything they sell comes from China. I will pay a little more and feel good about it.
      • WABDXN 4 months ago
        blame the greedy unions for the loss of jobs to china.....
      • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
        Not just the unions, but also shareholders who want to see a return on investment -- an always increasing return on investment, no matter the state of the economy.
    • Jessica  •  Oklahoma City, Oklahoma  •  4 months ago
      Stores are not the only ones that do it, everyday people do too. If there kid outgrows something and it is still in great to decent shape or even a few small stains or even little holes, other kids could use those for their kids that can't buy them. The small stains and holes could be used for play clothes. I have gotten a lot of clothes for my kids that way as well as shoes. When my kids out grow the stuff I either give it to friends with kids or to churches or other charities that give the clothes to those who need it, never to thrift stores where people have to pay for it. The stuff was free to me so I want it to be free to others. My youngest son even got a Harley power wheel for free. A lady was throwing it out and he saw it and asked if he could have it. She said yeah, she thought it just needed new batteries and she did not want to buy them. So we took it home a month later got 2 batteries and a charger for it and it works still and that was 5 yrs ago and he and my daughter still ride it. It only cost like 60 for all compared to what the Harley would have cost new. I would say we made out on that one. I could never buy the power wheel itself, too much money.. Most of the things my lids have have been given to them or taken from trash or charities and churches.
      • Lisa Farnhill 4 months ago
        that is so great. i agree. thirft stores aren't the only place some of them charge too much. their are churches and free clothing places, friends, friends of friends. glad that lady was nice. my mom got yelled at once for trying to take something out of the trash so it owuldn't go to waste and they called the cops. sad really. i've gotton tshirts on the ground outside of the thirft store bins so people i know could have something.
      • ISABELLA 4 months ago
        I WOULD DONATE A LOT MORE,BUT IT SEEMS LIKE EVERYTHING IS SO POST TO BE ABOUT NEW.LOOK AT THE TOY DRIVE BEFORE X-MAS.ITS NEW AND PACKED THAT THEY WONT.
      • teepee 4 months ago
        You know, I used to separate the "good stuff" from the "bad stuff" when taking donations to my local Goodwill... But now that I know how their program works, I send everything... Goodwill's way of recycling things like books, electronics, and damaged clothing (they turn these into rags and sell them to companies!) affords me the peace of mind in knowing that it (hopefully) won't ALL go to the landfill...
    • Hi there  •  4 months ago
      Lowes does the same thing. they will throw away the older items that don't sell. I worked there for a short time and my manager told me to discard the items ie: wallpaper, brackets, curtain rods, etc. I told him that I could not do that and that these items should be donated to the thrift stores or another special cause. He just got someone from another department to do it. i was really upset. there are ways to get around all of this wastefulness. they are just to lazy to deal with it.
      • Holly 4 months ago
        All they have to do is mark it low enough and people will scoop it up! The store gets some money and the customer comes back for other bargains regularly! Its just so stupid not to mark them down as "bargain basement" deals! People will always come back and buy something that is not marked down as well!
      • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
        Very true, Holly!!! I love a good bargain, even if I end up never using the item! lol. I appreciate and patronize stores who mark down merchandise that is around longer then they wish -- very I'll buy both marked down item(s) I want in addition to the regularly-priced items for which I came to the store. So, the retailer will get rid of an albatross or 2 and still come out ahead.
      • D 4 months ago
        That just goes to show the utter selfisness of big business. Citrus crops are burned, food is literlly thrown away when people in this country are going hungery. So many people don't have clothes for the winter months ahead,boots, coats, gloves, and you mean to tell me these selffish bast!!!are throwing clothes a way destroying things pepple could actually have ? How Godless are we?
    • Brenda  •  New Hartford, New York  •  4 months ago
      It's a shame that they have to take and destroy these clothes. Are they that hard up as not to give them to people who so desperately in need of clothing. It's like being selfish in not wanting someone else to have them.
    • Becky D.  •  Augusta, Georgia  •  4 months ago
      I worked for a retail clothing store as manager once. I was shocked at the store's policy that when the final markdowns had been taken and merchandise still wasn't sold we were to add it up, pull it and take scissors to it. I couldn't believe we couldn't donate it to a women's shelter or another good cause. If I had not been fired I would have done it myself.
    • Nancy  •  3 months ago
      ALL retailers do this. It's a 3 way issue: 1st is the possibility of being sued by someone eating "bad" food or getting hurt using a donated product of any kind. 2nd, theft issues. There was a time when stores would give their employees and customers a discount bin for damaged merchandise...until employees and customers started denting cans and scratching items on purpose to get them at pennies on the dollar. And 3rd, who would buy anything at regular price if they knew they could get just about anything for free if you waited long enough? People who accuse retailers of greed...look in the mirror, because the greed works BOTH ways. And dispite all of this, countries that are classified as capitalist also have the highest donation and charity rates on the planet....bashing capitalism and profits may be the popular thing to do today, but it has improved the living standards of everyone in the western world.
    • Catlin  •  New Bern, North Carolina  •  4 months ago
      Seriously... is history repeating itself? Wasn't Wal-Mart and one other company accused of this very same thing several years ago? I am sorry. I shop at Wal-Mart, because I cannot afford the same item at a HIGH-DOLLAR department store, but that doesnt give them any right to intentionally DESTROY thousands of dollars of clothing when it could go to charity. Sorry, I have no feeling for their BOTTOM line, because it is ALL bottom line.
    • PJ  •  St Louis, Missouri  •  4 months ago
      I KNOW THAT WALMART HAS BEEN THROWING AWAY LARGE QUANITIES IN THE GARGAGE. THESE ITEMS COULD HAVE BEEN DONATED. I WITNESSED EMPLOYEES DOING THIS. THIS WAS EVEN BEFORE THEY WERE SLASHING THEM. WHEN I ASKED IF I COULD TAKE THEM TO A LOCAL CHARITY I WAS TOLD NO. I WAS ALSO TOLD THAT THERE WAS A CAMERA AIMED AT THE DUMPSTER SO IF I TRIED TO REMOVE THE ITEMS IN THE DUMPSTER TO DONATE I WOULD BE ARRESTED BECAUSE THEY WOULD CONSIDER THIS THEFT. I WAS EVEN WILLING TO BRING A RECEIPT BACK TO THEM AS PROOF OF THE DONATION. SHAME ON WALMART. THIS WAS A WALMART LOCATED IN WISCONSIN.
    • Capricorn Princess  •  Houston, Texas  •  4 months ago
      iuse to work at bath&body works and they did the same thing when ever a customer would return anything luquid they would pour it down the drain everynight after closing and some of the items would be never open or never use.
    • Donna  •  Roanoke, Virginia  •  4 months ago
      At least Walmart should send the meat products that are out of date to the SPCA..or animal shelters...that would be a very nice gesture.
    • marci  •  Sacramento, California  •  4 months ago
      wastefull, wastefull, wastefull!!!
    • Maryam B  •  Galloway Twp, New Jersey  •  4 months ago
      Yet another reason I NEVER, EVER shop at Walmart.
    • julia  •  Randolph, New Jersey  •  4 months ago
      in defense of these retailers,i just want to comment about something important......i worked for a large company that donated clothes to people in need, but some people brought the merchandise back, saying the were damaged and wanted a refund. the company was talking a double loss.its because of the greddy people, that the honest suffer
    • normaprattno...  •  Toronto, Canada  •  4 months ago
      just another way of saying we got you don't .so #$%$ as we will not give anything for free ,if you cant pay then we wreck it suffer people
    • Lonnie  •  Irvine, California  •  4 months ago
      THE GREEDIEST PEOPLE ON PLANET:CHINMART OWNERS
    • Malik  •  4 months ago
      You people act surprised. like you really think Walmart cares about the poor, those in need or worse homeless? All that company and family full of midwest redneck misfits cares about is making $$$ not helping anyone else. Yet like millions of us I shop there to save a few dollars or even cents, which tell you everything it's ALWAYS ALL ABOUT THE $$ MAKING IT OR SAVING IT
    • Holly  •  4 months ago
      All the stores have to do is mark it low enough and people will scoop it up! The store gets some money and the customer comes back for other bargains regularly! Its just so stupid not to mark them down as "bargain basement" deals! People will always come back in numbers and buy something that is not marked down as well! If you give breaks to the customers, they will frequent your store more often...Its not rocket science...I always go where the deals are, and I end up buying other items that are not on sale always!!! Makes me sick how stupid stores are run!

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.