Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    House of Representatives votes to strip Planned Parenthood of funding



    The House of Representatives voted Friday to end federal funding for Planned Parenthood, with republicans arguing that the amendment was necessary to prevent taxpayer money from funding abortions-even though, under Title X, the organization is already prohibited from using federal funds for such purposes.

    The amendment, which was introduced by republican representative Mike Pence of Indiana, passed 240 to 185, mostly along party lines. It still faces a vote in the Senate.

    "Nobody is saying Planned Parenthood can't be the leading advocate of abortion on demand, but why do I have to pay for it?" Pence said the day before the vote. He added that he hopes Roe v. Wade is eventually overturned.

    But federal funding for Planned Parenthood falls under Title X, which specifically bars the use of its funds to provide abortions. The vote would strip Planned Parenthood and similar organizations of about $327 million through the end of September, eliminating funding for counseling, education, contraceptives, STD and HIV screening, cancer screenings, and other medical and preventive-health services.

    Planned Parenthood president Cecile Richards told Mother Jones magazine that she believes they can win enough votes in the Senate to restore Title X funding. "We've taken this vote before," Richards said.

    During debate on Thursday, democratic representative Jackie Speier of California followed comments against abortion funding by sharing her own experience with having undergone a medically necessary abortion, after the baby she was carrying moved from the uterus through the cervix at 17 weeks gestation.

    "And that procedure that you just talked about was a procedure that I endured. I lost a baby," she told a stunned house of representatives late Thursday night. (You can watch video of her statement, above.)

    "To think that we are here tonight debating this issue when the American people, if they are listening, are scratching their heads and wondering what does this have to do with me getting a job? What does this have to do with reducing the deficit? And the answer is nothing at all," Speier said.

    Also on Shine:

     
     
    Top Locations Albuquerque Stone Mountain

    235 comments

    • M. Walther  •  Stone Mountain, Georgia  •  3 months ago
      I wonder if they care how many people they will put out of a job, or the number of women who don't have insurance and can't afford to pay $150 to go to the doctor for a prescription for birth control? How will it help our economy anymore to put these nurses and doctors out of a job and then deny low-income people the ability to access their prescriptions? On top of that, there are a countless number of people who go there for STD check-ups and treatment, and I don't know about the idiots in charge of the country, but I would take a look at other issues before trying to shut down an organization that HELPS people. Abortions are only a percentage of the services they offer, and I myself had to go for a birth control RX and pap when I didn't have any insurance! Without their help, I wouldn't have had a way to get it when I couldn't afford a doctor after my bills.
      • Chad 3 months ago
        M. Walther, I am just appalled at how idiotic you sound... Why should we pay for someone else's choices? Why is it that because their condom broke or that they didn't use protection, we the hard-working tax payers must help them? Horrible way to live. They should abstain from sex if they don't want the responsibility of taking care of that baby... not get rid of the baby just because they made a "mistake". No baby is a mistake. It's a miracle... God's gift to women... and women are essentially throwing their babies in the garbage. Ever heard of Adoption after pregnancy? Please don't you dare tell me the millions of babies aborted yearly are all from teens or older women that "had complications".... the fact would be if you researched that a big percentage of abortions are because women (teens and older alike) cannot bear the responsibility that they chose to create a life... now they are ok to KILL him/her.

        Ever thought of this? This whole economic mess we're in... WHAT IF those millions of babies became middle class Americans and worked like I do??? What if out of those millions of babies aborted that one became a powerful stock broker or became a nurse or doctor or.... you can go on and on until you're blue in the face but THEY CAN'T BE A HELP IN OUR COUNTRY BECAUSE WE ABORTED THEM (MURDERED THEM). If the baby had a choice no matter if the woman has complications or not... they would be saying "GIVE ME A CHANCE TO LIVE", "Don't kill me please". But M. Walther, they have no choice... this pro-choice crap is all about the woman and does nothing to think about the babies' choice in the matter.
    • Braxton  •  7 months ago
      Ignorant people like these republicans need to get out of the house and congress period!
    • finlander  •  7 months ago
      An average of 1,300,000 babies are killed annually through surgical abortion.The bulk of them are done through Planned Parenthood.

      Planned Parenthood clinic income is $356.9 million. Government grants and contracts to Planned Parenthood are $336.7 million. I don't want my tax money spent on abortions. Planned Parenthood is just a abortion mill hiding behind the clinics name.
      • David D 3 months ago
        Well that's the thing, Finlander. Your tax money DOESN'T go toward funding abortions. Planned Parenthood is a LOT more than just an abortion clinic. They provide dozens of neccessary health services for millions of women in this country. And the tax money provided to them subsidizes those other health services, not abortions. That's already a law.

        Just because ignorant people like you don't know what the clinic does, doesn't mean Planned Parenthood is an "abortion mill..." I mean, what an ignorantly asinine statement.
      • Ellen 3 months ago
        Where the heck do you get your facts from?Only 3% of PP is abortions. And who are you to judge? Some of that 3% could be a women who could die if she had her baby.
        Or would you want a teen mom putting up her baby for adoption, he or she doesn't get adopted and goes through the wrecked foster system? OR have your tax paying money go to welfare towards the mom who can't afford her baby and had she of had access to birth control, wouldn't have to deal with a baby she is not equipped to handle?

        Planned Parenthood HELPS women.
      • Chad 3 months ago
        David D, ever heard of the Abortion Funding in the Obamacare legislation? It's in there somewhere... in the 2,000 some page bill that Nancy Pelosi said to "pass before we can find out what's in it".... oh ya, that woman that said we the Tea Partiers are "Astroturf"... yep, the same people that said that is the ones that crammed this legislation down our throats that a majority did NOT want. Try refuting that... if you want, I will find the place in the Obamacare bill where it says Abortion funding is allowed and if I'm not mistaken, Planned Parenthood is at the heart of Obama's decision. Anything this fraudulent regime (should be an administration) supports, you should run away from - FAR AWAY.
    • Brittany Dorsett  •  1 year 1 month ago
      This is ridiculous... I am a single mother working two jobs to support my son... AND trying to go to school. Neither of my jobs offer benefits and I dont make enough money to pay out of pocket Dr bills or purchase my own health insurance... Planned Parenthood has helped me maintain all of postpartum check ups and birth control since having my son. So what if they use some of their money to build a few fancy buildings! They are helping women such as myself!!
      • Yuberkis 3 months ago
        And that's the wonderful thing Plan Parenthood does and is great. But I think abortion should not be funded by the our tax money unless is an extreme exeption. If you opened your legs face the consequences and be responsible.
      • Ellen 3 months ago
        *Your tax dollars do not fund abortion
      • Chad 3 months ago
        Ellen, I am not sure what you mean by "your tax dollars do not fund abortion"... If you're talking about hard-working Americans (I work 2 jobs)... Abortion is funded by my tax dollars. It's in Obama's healthcare bill that a majority of America said NO to... the backroom deals by congress and yet it still passed without any real consideration from us the tax payers.
    • Harley  •  1 year 1 month ago
      DEFUND PP and let the baby killers make private donations!!!
    • Harriet  •  Albuquerque, New Mexico  •  3 months ago
      I'm very troubled that someone in political office might decide what I can do for my health. Are men threatened by a woman making her own decisions? And if abortion is not the right thing to do, how many of those who oppose it have come forth to support or adopt a child or agree to support birth control education?
      • Ellen 3 months ago
        I could not agree with you more!
    • ConnieGS  •  1 year 2 months ago
      Planned Parenthood is more than just a place that does abortions. It provides birth control for both women and men, screens for STDs for both women and men, and does preganany testing and counseling. If PP is defunded, there will be more than just women suffering.

      Even Pro-Lifers have sex and PP gives Pro-Lifers birth control and screening.
      • Sjormantec Burns 3 months ago
        Most Pro-Lifers have no problem and actually endorse almost everything that PP does, except for abortion. Elective abortion is such a detestable thing that they would rather defund an organization that does 99% good if the 1% bad is as loathsome as elective abortion. If PP said "ok, ok, no more abortions, I don't think very many logical thinkers would have any problem with PP existing. In reality, there is no amount of good that could outweigh the bad of ending the progress or life of those who are the most vulnerable amongst us.
      • Chad 3 months ago
        Um, I don't know where you get that most prolifers endorse PP... They most certainly do not. Where do you get your facts from? CNN? ABC? CBS? All those broadcasts that support Obama? I bet you do. I research and don't take someone's word for grant it.
    • Jorge Krsna F  •  1 year 2 months ago
      Santa Claus lives at the North Pole, babies are found in the cabbage patch and politicians don't lie and don't have a personal agendas. Pence is a disgrace to the human race. The deficit is obscene and he wants to put Planned Parenthood out of business and what? Where will the federal government come up with the extra billion dollars and staff to man ANOTHER federal government agency to do the work of planned parenthood. Pence has lied. Look into his allegations and find out the outcome of the criminal claims against Planned Parenthood. The house of representatives should pass a resolution that any member of congress that willingly or unwillingly misrepresents information on the floor of congress should be immediately suspended for the balance of his term in office.
      That will make a lot of these political b------ s do their homework PERSONALLY and not be able to blame aides for their blatant lies. I run businesses and the buck stops with me. I am RESPONSABLE for every mistake, lie or problem caused by everyone of my employess and my customers know that as do the employees. Yes Planned Parenthood was fined $50,000 for not notifying that there was a minor who got an abortion and did not get parental consent. All the other charges that Pence referred to were dropped and Pence didn't take the time to verify this information. He used inuendo and half truths. And the other 239 representatives should be damn glad they aren't women and poor and aren't exploited by men and have no place to turn for information on controlling their bodies.
      These people are so incredible stupid, I am ashamed that they represent the American people. LOOK CAREFULLY AT THESE TWO WORDS "PLANNED PARENTHOOD". Do you see the word abortion, sex slaves, sex trade, abuse of women? No you see something that says that this organization will help women and men plan their parenthood stage of life.
      I believe EVERY CHILD no matter where it is born and to whom it is born should be wanted, loved, cherished, desired by all members of his family, should be educated to the farthest natural abilities it posses, be free from hunger, have a roof over his head, and clothing to protect him from the elements. And if for any reason a pregnant woman does not want a child she should not be forced to have a child. Today there are millions of child waiting to be adopted all over the world and politicians and bureaucrats are making a tremendously lucrative business out of this. Orphanages are overflowing. Children are wasting away emotionally, physically and psychologically because of this outrage and 240 representatives of congress want to increase the number of unwanted children in the world.
      You are all shameless.
    • Angela  •  1 year 3 months ago
      Why am I not surprised that the same people are still here exhibiting the same nasty, childish behavior as they always have in the past?

      "Our country is broke" due to two wars one of them based on lies) the greed of corporations, and the mismanagement of republicans. Yet the same people against abortion are more than happy to support the killing of non-Christian men, women, and children in other nations. Of course, we also know that these same people overwhelmingly support the death penalty.

      And then Mia gets high fives all around for yammering about a parent's "responsibility" to teach their children (because, you know, everyone has parents, and you know, all those parents are capable of teaching their children). According to Mia, any person who has sex and is unfortunate enough to contract a disease must suffer and die from it, because she and some other unethical uneduated "folks" demand they learn the hard way for not subscribing to their invented morality.

      And then WilliamM makes the most absurd statement of all: "We can no longer afford to make every one of Maslow's hierarchy of needs into an entitlement. That is the bottom line." Yes, because we don't have a homeless problem in America or anything like that, right? American's aren't going bankrupt due to medical costs.

      I almost forgot how incredibly stupid the people on this website are.
    • JD  •  1 year 3 months ago
      If the funding is ended then we should get ready to see back alley abortions with a dirty coat hanger again. There will be unqualified people performing services and putting girls lives in danger because they want to capitalize on this. Abortions won't stop they will just be much more risky.

      I have never aborted a child but several of my friends growing up did, some at Planned Parenthood. They were counseled about their decisions and advised of all the alternatives before they made their decisions. Most of them, their parents never knew about it and still don't. Before you say my child never would you better think twice. I would much rather my child have access to a qualified medical
      staff than a guy in an alley that no one knows.
    • Joanne  •  1 year 3 months ago
      I'm just giving some constructive criticism; no one can take you seriously if your writing displays an obvious lack of education and intelligence. And if you all care about babies so much, why don't you focus your efforts on helping the ones that are already born? Any of you screeching about 'killing babies' ever adopt an unwanted child or do anything to help needy kids? And if the government is going to stop funding Planned Parenthood, maybe they should also stop funding abstinence-only education and crisis pregnancy centers. Sounds fair to me.
    • Angela  •  1 year 3 months ago
      I skimmed every comment made here. I noticed that not one person mentioned that Planned Parenthood provides healthcare, education, and family planning services to both women AND men. The services provided are done so for free to little or no cost. Those that are able to pay are charged on a sliding scale.

      Now, to those of you who insist on spreading hate and lies about Planned Parenthood--like they're only in it for the money, and that they're abortion mills--why not operate in the truth? Why not focus on the fact that abortion accounts for the least of PP services? Why not focus on the fact that PP saves lives every day by providing cancer screenings and treatments? Why not admit that what this is really about is the fact that you can't stand not being able to control others and make them do what you tell them to do?

      To the many of you here who support Planned Parenthood, you can go to PlannedParenthood.org or to PlannedParenthood's facebook page, and they will tell you how to sign petitions and also how to contact you congress person and senator to let them know that you support them. They will also tell you how can donate to them. I contacted my congressman with Planned Parenthood's help, and he stood with them! I also contacted every person in my address book to write to him and support them as well!
    • jennifer  •  1 year 3 months ago
      Well speaking from someone who started using planned parenthood @ 17 I know alittle on this subject. None of these people who want to get rid of PP have probbly never been to PP. As a "lower middle income" girl who was embarrassed to talk to anyone I knew about sex and my body, I went to PP. I had no money but knew I didnt want to be a high-school "mommy". They talked to me about all the contraception that was there and how important it was to be "sexually resposible". Gave me my first exam and supplied me with the birth control of my choosing and free condoms. I will be forever greatful. I continued to use them though my early 20's because the "luxury" of health insurance wasn't something I had. Little by little they had to charge more and more (dam Bush) and I had to stop going because I could not afford it. Having a family history of cervical cancer, every year that passed I felt like I had a ticking time bomb, because I did not know and was paranoid sexually with my partner because I was not on the pill. Now out of college and a grown women with insurance I understand what a gift PP is for those who want it. If you want to stop the abortions, keep PP open and let everyone know about there sexual resposiblities to care and protect themselves. No one wants an abortion, but if an unwanted pregancy arises and a girl knows she doen't want it this should be an option. The atrocity is all of these children who are unloved, abused, and neglected or worse murdered because of parents who were not ready for a child
    • deborah  •  1 year 3 months ago
      As a teenager I used Planned Parenthood, they never discussed abortion as the option. They provided annual checks and birth control. For those of you wanting to save your tax paying dimes...start telling your congress/senate men & women that you no longer want them to get an automatic pay raise every year...you don't want your tax dollars to pay for their insurance when they are no longer your employee, you don't want to pay for their childs education. They are our employees and we have no rights to say how our tax dollars are used in their favor. That's where the budget needs adjusted!
      It's a double edged sword, tax dollars are either going to be used for family planning or welfare.
    • Joanne  •  1 year 3 months ago
      I think it's wonderful what your husband and you are doing, I admire that. I'm not obsessed with 'dead babies', I just think that most of what PP does is provide women who don't have insurance or a whole lot of money much needed health services. I am fine with my tax dollars going towards preventing unwanted pregnancies, thus preventing abortions, because it costs less for society in the long run. And most of what Planned Parenthood does is provide free or low cost birth control for women who can't afford it. It's also valuable for women who don't have insurance yet don't qualify for Medicaid.
    • charlene  •  1 year 3 months ago
      The botton line is PP does not care about woman they care about making money and they are making plenty of it from our tax dollars. I wonder how many politicians are getting kickbacks from PP, many I'm sure.
    • Joanne  •  1 year 3 months ago
      Mia, if you want to be smart and righteous, you may want to learn how to spell properly.
    • WilliamM  •  1 year 3 months ago
      Well, you know, anyone who disagrees with Angela is stupid. Remember that and always echo everything her angry, bitter little hands type and you will not feel the sharp edge of her ad hominem "arguments". ;)

      Or, you can just realize that the opinion of someone who doesn't know you ABOUT you and about whom you don't care is about the least powerful thing in the world...
    • get30  •  1 year 3 months ago
      I will not shed a single tear if PP is defunded but I doubt the Senate will go along with it.
    • WilliamM  •  1 year 3 months ago
      While I tend to agree that some ( not all ) churches push the envelope of their side of the tax-free social contract, and have long questioned that contract...dispensing with it would probably not pass Constitutional muster. "The power to tax is the power to destroy", and I suspect that the framers had that apothegm in mind when they penned the document.

      But of course this is just a red herring to distract from the actual issue of whether or not to fund PP. That there are problems over there in Issue X has no real bearing on the problems with Issue A.

      The question at hand is not moral, at least to me, but rather wholly economic. The nation has enough actual legitimate functions to fund as it is, without making one human "need" after another into a human "right" to be funded by the taxpayers. We are reaping the consequences of decades of this sort of policy creep into the social sphere right now, and it's only going to get worse as demographic trends go against us, as rivals like China grow stronger and require more counteraction, and world resources dwindle and become more expensive.

      We can no longer afford to make every one of Maslow's hierarchy of needs into an entitlement. That is the bottom line.

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.