Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Can Men and Women Really Be Just Friends?

    Can men and women really just be friends?Can men and women really just be friends?It's that age-old question: can men really be just friends with women? What happens when platonic turns to perverse?

    We questioned men and women of all ages and backgrounds to get their take on whether guys can really have a relationship with a girl, that doesn't involve sex.

    1. Dr. Soroya Bacchus, 51: "While men and women can be friends, it is difficult for the relationship to be entirely platonic. Our genetics simply drive our attraction to the opposite sex! The likelihood that at least one party is drawn to the other sexually is very high, regardless of whether or not anything ever comes of it. This is the reason jealousy and infidelity exists; we are not wired to be a monogamous species."

    Dr. Soroya Bacchus, 51, Psychiatrist


    RELATED: Am I Normal? Your Top Sex Questions, Answered!

    2. John Powers, 29: "Men and women often think they are nothing but friends, when in reality one person's mind or the other is thinking more. They may never share this information with their friend, but there is always that feeling that one of these days we're going to get a little tipsy and make-out."

    John Powers, 29, Stand Up Comic and Relationship Columnist

    3. Angel Lutin, 38: "I have many guy friends. They are my friends because they all started out as guys that wanted to date me or sleep with me. If you have an unattached female and male, I think sexual tension is always there. Typically the reasons they are "friends" is because one of them doesn't want more. I mean, if you get along enough to hang out, have dinners, talk on the phone, that's a big part of a relationship, right?"

    Angela Lutin, 38, Flywheel Instructor and Blogger, EssentiallyAngela.com

    4. Lindsley Lowell, 42: "Men and women cannot be friends with someone they are attracted to, and unfortunately, most men are attracted to almost every woman so the idea that they can be friends without thoughts of sex is ridiculous. Being friends in group activities is fine. I would get worried if your guy was off doing one-on-one stuff with a woman. That's called a date."

    Lindsley Lowell, 42, Author of My Knight in Shining Armor is Coming, He's Just Stuck in Traffic

    RELATED: How to Tell if He's "The One"

    5. Stefan Pinto, 40: "No, it isn't possible, especially if the woman is single. Women always do the 'match up' first for their criteria and, if not, for one of her bffs. It doesn't matter how long the woman knows the man; if he is good looking, smart, charming, resourceful, courageous, adventurous, and gainfully employed, she. will. always. wonder. what. it. would. be. like. to. be. married. to. him. Period."

    Stefan Pinto, 40, Model/Writer

    To see what more men and women have to say about being friends, click here!

    What do you guys think? Can men and women really just be friends?


    More on SHAPE:
    8 Ways Your Man Meddles with Your Metabolism
    What You Need to Know About Online Dating
    14 Things Men Wish Women Knew

     

    36 comments

    • cerulean1979  •  3 months ago
      Sure, men and women can be friends. I have gay male friends i'm not attracted to and younger work friends I have no interest in being with because I'm like their older sister helping them navigate the very tricky field of understanding women. Good luck to them lol
      My way of thinking is that the platonic dynamic only works if you're in a relationship already or are not ready to go that route...yet. Eventually, one, the other or both want more.
    • Andrea  •  Boynton Beach, Florida  •  2 months ago
      The answer is yes as long as neither one of the friends wants to have sex with the other. I have lots of platonic male friends, but I don't want to have sex with them either. If I have sexual feelings for the guy, I can't be his true friend as in the back of my mind I would be figuring out a way to make him my man lol.
      • NeikosGirl 2 months ago
        same here Andrea. I have had more male friends over the years. They are much cooler to be friends with than females (( just my opinion )) but I can say a couple of them wanted sex but I never let it go that way because of how the friendship was going, why screw up a good thing?? But that never stopped them from being my friend, that is how I knew they were good friends.....
      • Andrea 2 months ago
        I'm with you about guy friends are way better than gal friends lol. If the friendship is a good one there's no reason to jeopardize it by giving into your sexual urges lol.
      • George Jetson 2 months ago
        I had a female friend...gave me a Make over...not crazy about the BIKINI WAX thing.
    • Arte'  •  Newark, New Jersey  •  2 months ago
      i think men and women can be friends. i dont think i could ever think of a guy friend as anything more. i know most women who date and marry and say that they are in love with their bestfriend but i just cant think that way. i dont want to date marry or sleep with a friend, i want to date marry and sleep with i guy who i see as nothing more than a boyfriend or husband. i think my thinking is different but friend and boyfriend are in two different catergories. friends are in the i would never sleep with them and boyfriends are in i want to sleep with them, i dont want to share my feelings or my sorrows, i just want to sleep with him. so pretty much a boyfriend is for me a person i see only in a sexual way and friends in an emotional way.
      • Irene 2 months ago
        Not condemning your perspective here, but I think you are missing an important relationship level from your thought processes. A boyfriend or husband is not someone you just want to sleep with. Someone you just want to sleep with is a disposable "sex partner". How do you define intimate love between a man and a woman, the kind of love that would make you want to marry and share life together as a couple? A day in, day out relationship with someone that you only want to sleep with and do not want to share your emotions with would be a very sad, unfulfilling, and loveless thing. Me thinks you are compartmentalizing sex and emotion so that you never have to experience a broken heart? Hm? Maybe? Only thing is that if you do not open yourself up to the blending of sexual desire with emotion, to that possibility of having your heart crushed, you will also never open yourself up to the joy and happiness that comes when you are in love with, love, AND want to sleep with your best friend.
      • Arte' 2 months ago
        ....i can never look at a bf as a bestfriend. i never could and i doubt i know how. i mean i rather have my cake and eat it too than be stuck in an emotional trap which is a relationship. from what i have experienced and seen, its crap and no intimacy seems a lot nicer than being stuck when the whole thing falls apart.
      • Andrea 2 months ago
        Arte' - I think what you mean is that you don't want to put all your wants and needs into one man. You'd rather have your friendships fill your emotional needs and have your boyfriend fill your sexual needs.
    • yoyo928  •  3 months ago
      Did this whole article miss the whole concept of the girl with a gay guy best friend?
    • George Jetson  •  2 months ago
      yes men and women can be just friends but you can't put things in my hair.
      we will not wear each others cloths. sometimes a female friend can cramp my style, but thats the same for women as well.
      • Country 2 months ago
        :o) Awww. But I wanted to borrow that shirt you're wearing!
      • Irene 2 months ago
        So I'm guessing that sitting on the bed in our jammies while we paint each other's toenails bright pink and talk about the hot new guy who moved in next door is out of the picture too?
      • George Jetson 2 months ago
        Country; wore this shirt to a BON-FIRE. smells like beer women. smoke and goat. we got a little tipsy and well we took some goat rides....better let me wash it first.
    • dfreybur  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  3 months ago
      This is why married couples tend to socialize with other married couples. It solves the problem and gives a yes to the question.
      • George Jetson 2 months ago
        I though it was to split the cost of a babysitter....Guess I was wrong.
    • Thomas  •  Springfield, Missouri  •  2 months ago
      if the man is attracted to the female, then it is extreamly hard to be just friends..
    • Evee  •  Salt Lake City, Utah  •  2 months ago
      My best guy friend and I had sex once....and it was horrible for both of us. We're such good friends because we know we have no sexual chemistry. Neither of us wants to get the other in bed, so we never have that tension in our relationship. It can happen, but lots of girls think guys are being "friendly" when the dude wants in her pants.
      • A Yahoo! User 2 months ago
        That reminds me of my ex and I although we never had sex because I am waiting until marriage. She was one of my best friends so I thought making out with her was going to be great, boy was I wrong. Luckily we're still friends.
    • Jonn  •  2 months ago
      Yes, I think men and women can be just friends. I have women friends that are just that, I would never think of having sex with them in a million years, there is no attraction at all. Then there are women that I only think of having sex with, that would be the one I would want to marry, the one that I only think of having sex with with no feelings or sorrows. So yes, a girlfriend would be one I only see in a sexual way with no emotions involved.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  New York, New York  •  2 months ago
      I think it all depends on the individual. One of my best friends is female, I like being able to ask her for dating advice and then check out her rig that she just put together. You can't say that about many girls.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  New York, New York  •  3 months ago
      It all depends on the situation I feel. My ex girlfriend is one of my best friends and no, it's not because I still have feelings for her, not those kind of feelings anyway. I just like having someone who is knowledgeable about girl stuff and even though we didn't work out as a couple we still have fun times.
    • sage s  •  3 months ago
      Probably it is the way I was nurtured, or maybe I am an emotional outlier. Whatever it is, I know for a fact that men and women can be just friends without one person in the friendship laying in wait for an opportunity to have sex with the other.
      After reading the entire article and most of these comments; a person who is lacking life experience or exposure to the opposite sex, would deduce that our prime objective as human beings is to engage in intercourse. To believe sex is the only thing that motivates us to interact with the opposite sex on a emotional level, would be imbecilic.

      If you cannot have friends of the opposite sex (especially ones that are attractive) without wanting to "sex them up," then you are emotionally stunted and might forever remain that way.
      For the record, I am a very sexual person, and I lead a healthy sex life.
      I also have a lot of women (single and coupled) who are my friends. Women whom I have never had sex with, nor do I plan on using our friendship as a conduit to something else.
      We go out to dinner and catch a movie quite frequently ( just us alone, unchaperoned), and at the end of the night we might end up back at my place, or at theirs', recapping the evening and talking the night away.

      Now am I to believe, according to most of the people in the article, that I am an emotional freak. One that is so adept at separating and compartmentalizing his sexual desires, that I am among the few heterosexual men that are capable of having female friends who I view as just friends?

      I beg to differ.
      I think people that say, "well men and women cannot be just friends, because ....," are actually projecting their emotional shortcomings onto others. To me what they are actually saying is, "well I cannot be friends with a member of the opposite sex (or same sex, depending on your sexuality) because I am so weak, if I expose myself to this person on a regular basis, my undies my fall off and I might do the unthinkable."

      So stop projecting YOUR emotional weaknesses onto others, because this might sound alien or even unbelievable, but "MEN AND WOMEN CAN BE JUST FRIENDS."
    • A Yahoo! User  •  New York, New York  •  2 months ago
      I don't know, I prefer to have female friends. We can get in heated debates and then turn around and go get our nails done. They're also good for knowledge on how to handle that pesky cramping and bloating once a month. Okay, finished with my tangent, now back to the question. Can men and women be friends? Yes.
    • Melody Yeung  •  St Louis, Missouri  •  2 months ago
      yes i think guys and girls can be friends. i dont have many girl friends because i hate the drama. i have many guy friends and when we hang out and party its comfortable. non of us wants to do each other. There are many times when its just me and one other guy. Its not a date. its just two friends hanging out. so yes Guys and girls can be just friends.
    • Doug S  •  Annapolis, Maryland  •  2 months ago
      No. Billy Crystal had it right. The sex thing is always there.
    • Jeffrey  •  2 months ago
      "most men are attracted to almost every woman "

      HAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Think again. "Most" men are attracted to a small subset of women. A *few* men are attracted to almost every woman.
    • Stiga  •  Los Angeles, California  •  3 months ago
      I'm a straight guy, and I think men and women can be just friends, especially when one or both aren't physically attracted to the other. I've had plenty of female friends. It is tricky or awkward when one likes the other though, whether secretly or both know it.
    • Sarah  •  Gainesville, Florida  •  2 months ago
      Sure, I think they can be friends. However, I do think there will always be one party of the relationship who secretly wishes it was more. There will always be a bit of sexual tension.
    • Dubs  •  3 months ago
      It's human nature to always want more. Couple this with someone who you find attractive, can trust and confide in and respects you for you as well as has many attributes that you admire...that awkward moment is bound to happen. It's important to be honest with yourself but be considerate of other's feelings simultaneously.
    • daisy*kae  •  2 months ago
      i believe that men and women can be just friends. i have males that i'm close to enough that i consider them brothers. the thought of sleeping with them has never entered my mind. however, i must admit that some of my best relationships have been with men that started out as friends. we went into the relationship with respect for one another already established, so it was an easy transition.

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.