Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    User post: Should Women Propose to Men?

    Remember way back in the year 2000, when Monica proposed to Chandler on Friends? It seemed daring and unusual.


    You know what? It still does. Yes, there are women proposing to men, some of them famous, like Jennifer Hudson, and some of them not so famous, like my friend Rudi who proposed to her now-husband over dinner with a home-made book.


    But, why isn't it more frequent? After all, the true surprise proposal (where the couple has never even discussed getting married before) is pretty much a thing of the past (thankfully). Today, most couples have already discussed the fact that they plan to get married, they may already be living together, and then the woman sits around and waits for the guy to ask before she considers herself officially engaged.


    Why is that? Is it just about the ring? Is it about tradition? Are women worried they'll "scare" guys?


    Over on OneWed this month we're running a great contest. Women tell us how they would (or will, or did) propose to their guy and they can win matching platinum wedding bands from jewelry designer Kirk Kara. The rings are worth $4,500, and they're gorgeous!


    What do you think should women propose, or should men still do the asking?

     

    79 comments

    • emmanuel  •  9 months ago
      I think, woman should do it. they enjoy much in relationship so they should look for us
    • yeyoman  •  2 years 8 months ago
      "should" women propose? I don't know, who "should" it's on many thing, personal beliefs, cultural, and I don't know what else

      "can" they? hell yeah!

      It really depends on the couple.
      My girlfriend and I were friends for many years, although we lost contact for some time, she has seen me trough my worst over the years. We've been together 5 months, and I'm crazy enough to propose. I'm looking at rings already, but I'll wait some time to actually propose.
      So what's stopping me? Well, she has a little girl (no, that's not whats stopping me). I'm giving her time, cause she has to be sure if I'm the right man to raise her child.

      If she beats me to the proposal, so be it, I'm "man enough" to live trough that (yes, it's quoted, because I don't think that makes me less of a man). That just tell me she wants me forever.

      Who cares who proposed. You can swear all the love in the world, offer her all the flowers of spring and give her all the chocolate from Switzerland. But if you ran away just because she asked you...
      Well, in case you need you be the one proposing and she beats you to it, say to her "no, honey, I need to ask you, but it's great to know you'll say YES... hey, it'll be fun trying to surprise you".

      But hey, don't mind me.. I'm just out of my mind.
    • bingredulla  •  2 years 10 months ago
      It's not ignorance that prevents women from proposing, it's the fact that men are no longer taking the lead in relationships that should make women think well if they are worth the proposal. Women deep down still want to be swept away by a "Tarzan" rather than a lame double-minded guy. Women may desire equality but there are still times when we need our men to take the lead and be a man. It isn't weakness, it's a woman's natural strength to persuade without words that is more alluring and their patience as a reflection of their true love. Love, after all, is not about conquering by force, owning someone. It's not about self-centered desires but respect and true devotion for each other.
      • Omipotent 5 months ago
        there are still times when we need our women to take the lead and be a lover. It isn't weakness, it's a man natural deisre to feel loved and get chased by a women. just because women want it not matter how deep down , does not mean men are born to fufil it. women are cheered for when they do not "give in" to a men desire but why must a definations of a person br decided by another person(no matter how many) deisres. we decided what it is to be a man. we may not be the man you want but we only need to care to be the man we want
    • !  •  2 years 10 months ago
      no! you know a woman asked me one time, ok thats nice hay i was going too ask
      waiting on jewlers i said no!

      w
    • Brianna  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I think women should do it. We're already doing everything else, what's 1 more thing lol? And if the groom-to-be truly loves her and is truly secure in his masculinity then everything will work out no matter who proposes
    • nikki  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I asked my boyfriend of two years to marry me on my birthday while pregnant with our second child and he said, yes!!!!!!
    • Eddieslilangel  •  2 years 11 months ago
      men should be doing the asking in opinion.
    • L.L. and G.J.  •  2 years 11 months ago
      Until I married the man, am married to now, which a widow from 84 to 2008, it seems interesting to be the one for the man, now, now that am
      married, I wish I had never mentioned the subject of marriage, or purposed the subject of marriage to him, as my first husband purposed
      marriage and we were married 20 year, this man now we been less then a year and almost weekly were at each other in verbal ways, so am not happy that he married me out of pleasing me, where he manifest his love interest in someone half my age, and he shows it, where he trys not to let me know he is having affairs weekly and loves her, and he feels trapped in this marriage as he feels now he can not afford to be freed from me, so I believe I would of been happier with someone who I feel had really wanted to be my husband..
    • Angelica  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I think it is ok for a woman to purpose to a man but personally,i still think that i will wait for my BF to purpose becouse when he porpose,he have decided to spend the rest of his life with me and i think that is very very important.I think a man will purpose onlt when they are ready-correct(me if im wrong)...
    • GlenW  •  2 years 11 months ago
      No
    • curiously  •  2 years 11 months ago
      "how special we should be?"
      Thanks for the tip but I think we should try to be normal.
      lol
    • opiniononly  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I don't understand why a woman is willing to tell a man she wants to get married but balks at asking him to marry her. Maybe because one is conjecture and can be relatively vague and the other is concrete and specific...and a risk? Come on ladies, WE have the option to say "no thank you" if/when proposed to by our guys, so why it is to terrible to reverse the roles?

      If the two of you are on the same page regarding love, life and being together, who cares who asks. It doesn't make you (or him) any less normal, or more desperate, or any of the other judgemental characterizations stated in some of these answers.
    • Jason  •  2 years 11 months ago
      yes megan fox should ask me if i want to get married
      why not
    • K  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I still beleive in tradition..don't take the excitement away from the guys doing the traditional way.. if you feel like he is not going to do it, then he's probably not going to do it.. so move on..
    • Warrior  •  2 years 11 months ago
      what ? the traditional way is better... MEN are MEN... WOMEN are WOMEN !... i don' wanna use ugly words... but this is bullshit !... keep the traditional way don't be a bastard... we're not in South Park !
    • Jenn  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I would have had no problem proposing to my current hubby :) ... but he beat me to it!
    • Umair  •  2 years 11 months ago
      women have always right jugement about thier guys. so if one analyezed that any one have true love feeling for her and cant propose her by shy feeling so women must propse him.
    • fluffy  •  2 years 11 months ago
      i'm a old fashion girl, i feel that it is the man who is to do the proposing. but time and people change and traditions are changing like crazy, but if a woman knows her partner and want to take that step go for it. my fair is that men are not alwaying a willing participant in the marriage department. but for me i want to be propose to.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I see nothing wrong with a woman proposing. In this day and age we do almost everything a man can do. But then that whole traditional thing comes into play and yeah it is nice for the man to get down on bended knee and propose because that is the only way a woman knows that he is actually committed and is serious about it. The whole ring thing..I agree with Ahleah G. It would be nice to go pick out a ring together.
    • Dubs  •  2 years 11 months ago
      I'm perfectly ok with either way. Man proposes to Woman, Woman proposes to Man. Equality for all.

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.