Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    What Is Off Limits To Criticize Women About?

    Getty ImagesGetty ImagesSome work friends and I were recently discussing things that men can not criticize their girlfriends about. It was astounding how incorrect us guys were when trying to lay out our "rights" in terms of constructive criticism. The women in the office were appalled at what we thought we were allowed to talk about. If I could figure out what I am allowed to criticize and what I should stay away from, I'd avoid arguments and do a better job of hitting on girls.

    I'm guilty of saying things to women that only their best girlfriends, gay male friends, and moms/sisters are allowed to say. I put together a list below:

    Weight

    There is no friendly way for a guy to tell a girl that she's put on weight. Even if there was a friendly way, most of the women I've talked to about it said they would not want to hear it from a guy. It seems obvious, but not all guys know this. We polled some of the guys in our office, and the prevailing male opinion was as long as she's your girlfriend, or you've known each other for a while, then you can make weight loss suggestions. I think the best policy is silence. If I"m desperate to make a suggestion, maybe I tell one of her girlfriends to do it on my behalf.

    Outfit

    I think I'm only allowed to say someone generally looks nice, or I like her shirt or whatever. Getting too detailed or negative gets me in trouble. In fact, I attempted to "add on" to a compliment I gave a girl once. I told her she looked great, because she had a new outfit on. Now, remembering those times I saw my sisters or friends bark back "thanks, and just $30 from Target," I tried to double up on my compliment: "and it looks like you didn't pay much money either." She ended up crying. I've been told by women that they dress more to impress other women anyway, and not guys. Basically, I need to stick to "you look great" and leave it there. And I should probably avoid saying I don't like something a girl is wearing. That can only lead to no good.

    Friends/Family

    We've all dated people with annoying friends. But, people consider their friends as extensions of themselves so if you criticize friends, you're criticizing your significant other indirectly. My older sister has a good system of putting the word "that" in front of any of her husband's friends that annoy her. "Oh you're going with that Mike to the concert?" It's not an aggressive attack, just a little poke. Family is the same rule, but you probably get in even more trouble if you criticize the family of a significant other.

    Driving

    Every guy thinks he's a better driver than his girlfriend. I can learn a lot from my little sister's boyfriend. One day, my sister was driving the two of us to Baltimore for a weekend. My sister is a really bad driver. She doesn't brake when she sees brake lights ahead until she absolutely has to. This leads to passenger whiplash and nausea. During this trip I said: "you know, you can brake earlier- that way you're not slamming on the brakes at the last minute and making us all sick." She said: "do I do that?" I turned around to her boyfriend for confirmation and he simply said: "no comment". My sister's boyfriend loves me because I am allowed to verbalize all the criticisms that he's thinking.

    I like the "no comment" policy. But I can't stand not to give my opinion to women, even when it's bad. I want to learn the things I should hold off from criticizing about women. Do you agree with the items above? What do you hate being criticized about by guys?

    Follow me on Twitter: twitter.com/richravens


    Posted by Rich


    Related from Marie Claire:
    27 Worst Date Stories
    Make Him Swoon: Sexy Date-Night Perfumes
    20 Secrets Men Keep
    50 Cheap Date Ideas
    Looking for More Love, Fitness & Career Advice? Subscribe to Marie Claire & Save!

    Reprinted with Permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.

     

    1,309 comments

    • GM  •  6 months ago
      Yes, I know it's an old thread. It's unacceptable to have different standards for men who criticize women than for women who criticize men.

      By the way, it's a good thing to receive criticism.
    • you  •  2 years 8 months ago
      If you don't want the truth then don't ask the question. Women are fu!@ing psycho anyway!!!
    • SMILE  •  2 years 8 months ago
      WHAT ABOUT "IT'S YOUR JOB" OR "IT'S YOUR DUTY" LIKE FOR INSTANCE,...CHANGING THE BABY'S DIAPER...(THAT TOOK YOU BOTH TO MAKE), OR DOING THE DISHES, ETC. ETC...ANY COMMENTS TO THAT?? :)
    • Will S  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Critical item is "late braking" in the car. This is potentially dangerous, especially on wet roads. Late braking does not give people behind you time to react. Plus it is extra hard on your brake pads and rotors, which are not cheap to replace anymore. Late braking is dangerous.

      Commenting on outfits is OK if you have something nice to say or can suggest something better. I hate pedal pushers. So I suggest pants which make her legs look longer. Win-win. You can criticize as long as you have an alternative to offer.
    • Jim  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Sorry, but if you can't talk about these items at all, your relationship is doomed. How is one suppose to discuss issues of real importance, like, finances, child raising, etc., if they can't talk openly about something as superficial as weight, what they're wearing, etc.? I'd actually go so far as to say that FINDING a way to talk about it openly and honestly will benefit your relationship down the road. To avoid the issue at all can simply lead to communication problems down the road.
    • Laurie  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Hair: style, color, true color or not, length, cut, thinning, etc - ANYTHING - guys don't comment about our hair, unless it is a GREAT, NICE COMPLIMENTARY comment, and then, you should still think first!
    • Cierra  •  2 years 8 months ago
      ....Hmm.....all this is true and the clothing comment DON"T EVERY SAY THAT!!!!! Literally I think you learned your lesson, but that doesn't mean I can explain it to you! When a girl spends money on a new expensive dress they want to be praised...like "You look great in that!"
      and "you look so skinny in that it fits you perfectly!" those are the best things to say...trust me I'm a girl!
    • A Yahoo! User  •  2 years 8 months ago
      i do have to agree with John. Its a good point
    • Tracy  •  2 years 8 months ago
      This article is ridiculous. Exactly what is wrong with this country, as a matter of fact, exactly what is wrong with this world. Why are people so afraid of the truth? I just celebrated my 5th anniversary yesterday (In Los Angeles that's saying something) and our 12th year together. I told my wife 45 more to go. And god willing we will get there. You know why? Because we don't follow these stupid conventions. There is also a reason why 50% of marriages end in a divorce. Nothing should be off limits in a marriage (conversation wise)! Not critical, not attacking, not demeaning but respectful and helpful. My wife knows this is where I am coming from because she is my queen and my heart. You can't discuss weight or appearance or anything else. C'mon! Let me ask this question to all of you? Why is it the first thing a person, man or woman, does after a break-up is some form of self improvement. Woman and Men start working out to lose weight and work on their appearance, because no one wants to go through life alone. So if this is true. Then what you are telling me is some possible, hypothetical bozo is more important that your current significant other. So why can't we mutually hold each other to a higher standard. Think about it Ladies and Gentlemen and stop being soft. Long lasting relationships take and need just these type of conversations!!!!!
    • A Yahoo! User  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Claire, you sound so typical; power to the people... Which is why I married happier company (spanish).
    • Donna T  •  2 years 8 months ago
      My mother tough me "If you have nothing nice to say don't say anything" So here goes________________________________________________________________________________.
    • J  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Wow, women will constantly try to "improve" them, but don't say anything to women? Wow. Talk about a double standard. This is one of the dumbest articles I've ever read in the advice area. Clearly you have no real experience in a relationship that has any real chance of survival.
    • Anthony  •  2 years 8 months ago
      This is a bunch of crap. If women don't want to hear the things that their men are feeling or thinking, then dump the stupid bitch. For Christ sake, enough with emasculating men. Once a relationship is grounded, every topic is fair game, if not, get out.
    • tybroD  •  2 years 8 months ago
      I have one thing to say to both genders and anyone who wishes to be wise in all of their relationships. That is to leave the 'COMMENTS' to inanimate objects only!!! The best way to approach someone on a possibly sensitive subject is to offer helpful solutions to what they are doing especially if what they are doing can hurt or truly upset someone.
      Thank you all for caring enough and keeping this in mind the next time.
      With Gods Love
      Dawn P
    • stevo  •  2 years 8 months ago
      ya better not comment on her hygiene or scent either.

      duh.
    • MorganS  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Some call it criticism, I call it growth.

      If we can swallow our pride (or the false image of yourselves)
      we don't need to feel hurt by criticism. Accept it, learn from it
      and move on.
    • John  •  2 years 8 months ago
      so, women can can say things about my friends and i can't say anything about hers. Relationship over.
    • justyn  •  2 years 8 months ago
      heaven forbid you let a gf know she's put on some weight. It's probably just better to keep quiet about it until she puts on so much weight she is no longer attractive to you and then just break up with her. That's probably the better policy.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  2 years 8 months ago
      No Comment
    • Rick  •  2 years 8 months ago
      Women on the other hand can criticize at will and without limit. The writer of this article has no credibility whatsoever. Get a real job and quit being a hater.

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.