Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    5 things Jillian Michaels wants us to learn from "Losing It"

    Our girl crush, Jillian Michaels, has a new makeover show on which she will do whatever it takes to help you change your life. That means hours of sweaty workouts, dredging up the past, and lots and lots of tears. And despite the rocky start of the predictable (and slightly awkward) premiere episode, we find ourselves kind of won over by this show. Yes, it is manufactured sentimentalism, but we're willing to look past that because of Jillian herself: girl is real. And if she's just acting like she cares about these people's emotional, mental, and physical well-being, she might as well join the ranks of Meryl Streep. Here, our favorite takeaways from what could possibly be our new favorite tear-jerker show:

    The idea of change is exciting. The work of change? Not so much.

    Three episodes in, there's something it appears we can count on: Even though these people have willingly volunteered themselves as makeover subjects for this show, when Jillian calls from her iPhone and says, "I'm in Worcester, Mass! Come meet me in 20 minutes!", these people are not pleased. A look of doom and fear comes over their faces. And when they change into their workout clothes and are led through the first workout, they look like they'd be happy to kill America's toughest trainer. "I can't," they all say, over and over, when Jillian asks them to run faster, jump higher, work harder. And yet, they wanted to enough to subject themselves to a national reality show. It's interesting to watch the disconnect between wanting transformation in your life, and being totally averse to the hard work change requires. It's probably something a lot of us can recognize in ourselves.

    Don't be a victim to your own life.

    When things get tough once Jillian shows up, these people have a million excuses: I'm alone, I'm tired, I don't have any help, It's the way I've always done it. But, of course, Jillian blows those excuses to smithereens. Life isn't happening at you, she says, you are happening to life. Yet so many of us have adopted a stance of victimhood in our own lives. To more politely paraphrase the bumper sticker, bad stuff happens. To all of us. We can keep telling ourselves the story of our crappy childhood, how we've never accomplished what we wanted, how we've been wrecked by heartache and loss. But Jillian Michaels simply will not abide us being martyrs in our own lives. She wants us to start telling ourselves a new story about what we deserve and what we want. She expects us to take control and grab the wheel. And in each episode, people do. That, in a nutshell, is what makes us cry like big ole babies.

    You can't fix everything in one week, but you can put an action plan in place.

    The concept, at first, seems absurd. The show identifies a family that is coming apart at the seams, and Jillian moves in with them for five days to help them turn their lives around. Five days?! This is a very different beast than living on The Biggest Loser ranch for months. What's amazing, though, is how many wheels can be set in motion in five days. The families start an exercise routine, they learn some new recipes. Jillian gives them tools to talk to each other instead of eating their feelings. And by the time she leaves, everything isn't magically fixed, but these people have created a road map to take them where they want to go. And so far, when Jillian checks in with them six or eight weeks later, they are well on their way.

    Jillian will cut a b-tch.

    Jillian Michaels will scream in your face. Jillian Michaels will make you cry. This isn't news, perhaps, but it is surprising to see how receptive people are to tough love. Personally, I'm not into the drill sergeant approach and it can be a little uncomfortable to watch, especially when Jillian is pushing people to an emotional breakthrough/breakdown. She will make you run on the treadmill until you start crying about your dead husband/child/dream. And then she gets sweet, holds your face, and tells you to look in her eyes. It makes good television, I guess, and saves time to combine a workout with an excavation of your soul, but shouldn't these people just be in therapy?

    Transformation is a present-time activity.

    We meet Ruth in the third episode of the season. This is a woman filled with anger and crushed dreams, a woman who went through a divorce that she didn't see coming, who looks forlorn and empty when she says, "The life that I saw myself living is gone." Jillian puts Ruth through the wringer in what is probably the best episode of the season so far. When Ruth starts to give up during their first workout, Jillian pulls her trademark let-me-get-in-your-face move. "You know when transformation happens?" she barks in Ruth's face. "Right now. It's a present activity. Show me the new you! Decide the woman you want to be!" It's kind of an amazing moment, watching something click in Ruth's mind. If she wants to be different, she's going to have to do things differently, and that starts right now in this moment. It's an idea that's both terrifying and empowering, but let's focus on the silver lining: If you want to change, it's a matter of letting your actions today align with want you want in the future. And from the safety of your own home, you do just that without Jillian up in your grill.


    Find out how Jillian can give you rock hard abs>>



    More from Real-Life Makeover>>


    Photo credit: Getty Images

     

    47 comments

    • Carol R  •  1 year 7 months ago
      Getting in people's faces and yelling harshly at them does not mean you are a good and qualified trainer. Her method is disgusting and harmful not helpful. I stopped watching Biggest Loser just because of her unbelievable (meaning I don't believe it works) tactics. I'm glad some experts are calling her out, she needs to be exposed as the phony that I believe she is.
    • Aimee  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I love Jillian. I think if more people were as motivated as her the world would be a much better place. And mims is an idiot. She obviously is not very educated. Weight loss is a mental and physical transformation, and jillian takes a great aproach to both. She is an expert, she has been there and knows what it takes to make the life changes to loose weight in a healthy way. America needs a huge wake up call before all of our children die at 30 or sooner because they have health problems due to obesity. Jillian is the perfect poster chick to help motivate and change peoples minds about food and exercise.
    • Minty Me  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I think the woman (Jillian) needs some serious therapy. She's so out of control it's not funny.
    • Melissa  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I think this lady is more than a bit scary. I wouldn't want her screaming in my face like that. Not my idea of "positive" reinforcement or motivation.
    • pizzaman  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Regi, try out a recumbant stationary bike with magnetic levels of resistance.
      I have a bad ankle too, muscle up by moving is the only way to get the fluids moving to feel better.
      Good luck, try befor you buy.....I do a half hour in the morning and another half hour in the evening.
    • Monica  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Jillian is great...sometimes what we all need is a Jillian in our lives to let us know that we going down a path that is not healthy for us!
    • A Yahoo! User  •  1 year 11 months ago
      People need to stop finding reasons and excuses why they can't work out, and find reasons and ways they CAN work out & eat healthy. What you put in your mouth is directly related to the number on the scale.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Regi, I would suggest meeting with a physical therapist. Due to a fall, my sister had three surgeries on her knee and now has chronic back pain due to a surgical complication, and she's only 28 years old. She's about the same height as you and gained about the same amount as weight as you, and she's now finally learning specialized exercises she can do and starting to lose weight again. You do have some complications that will make weight loss difficult, but it's not impossible by any means.
    • AYahooUserHere  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Hawkeyegirl - I absolutely agree that people need to take responsibility for their own health, and I understand that a LOT of people don't. And that's sad. BUT, my point is that Jillian Michaels is NOT giving anyone a kick in the pants and making them understand that they need to take responsibility for their own *health* and stop blaming everyone and everything for being obese. She's bullying people into believing that "thin at any cost" = "healthy," and even if every person she "helps" is never obese again; if they're that extreme about being thin -- they still have an eating disorder and they're still not healthy. That's why people should turn off the TV and get help from REAL professionals, not some reality TV (moron) guru with an eating disorder of her own. And it does bother me that "Healthy Living" advice columnists (as well as too many people in the American public) are promoting her unhealthy ways and feeding her bizarre ego by actually believing she is "helping" people.
    • Aimee  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I love Jillian. I think if more people were as motivated as her the world would be a much better place. And mims is an idiot. She obviously is not very educated. Weight loss is a mental and physical transformation, and jillian takes a great aproach to both. She is an expert, she has been there and knows what it takes to make the life changes to loose weight in a healthy way. America needs a huge wake up call before all of our children die at 30 or sooner because they have health problems due to obesity. Jillian is the perfect poster chick to help motivate and change peoples minds about food and exercise.
    • Carol  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I think the people Jillian has helped would disagree. You are who you believe you are, and once you change that mindset, you can move on.
    • Kari  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Seems like Nike has the right idea with their 3-word slogan. I would only add five words: Get Off Your A** and - Just Do IT. Seriously. I spent half my life talking about getting healthy and exercising and guess what? Nothing happened until I actually started the WORK - both psychological and physical. And the first thing that helped me on my way was turning off the damn TV.
    • Shannon  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I am sorry to read that some are not encouraged when they see others success on TV. That something good Jillian is trying to do for American's is raise awareness for Obesity and showing others that they do have it in them to change the status quote. I am one that would say, that I enjoy being encouraged by others success each week. I started out on the journey weighing 288 pounds, and in 6 months I have lost 139 pounds. Watching the biggest loser and now Jillian's show has helped me to what to continue on my road to success.
    • shannon  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I have alwas been a on the heavier side of the scale. Growing up it never really bugged me I was a kid and enjoying life. Now that I have a child and work a very physical job the weight has become a very big problem. I use to have all kinds of excuses about why I couldn't get healthy. Then I graduate college. I got a college degree while working a full time job on nights, doing homework, and taking care of a kid. I did this with out ever doubting myself. Then I realized that if I wanted to get better and be healty I had to apply that same mind set to this.

      I agree Jillian can be very crazy and send people to tears. I think that people need it thought. One thing that helped me was when I realized I was an emotional eater. No matter what mood I was in I wanted to eat. Watching her I learned that really it was a deeper problem. Some people need tought love I have learned food can be like any other addiction. We need to learn the problem and stop medicating ourselves.
    • AYahooUserHere  •  1 year 11 months ago
      The Mims just said all there is to say about Jillian Michaels in two sentences.

      It just makes me sad to see how many people agree that what Jillian does is "helping people get healthy." Yes, we all know that being morbidly obese is not being physically healthy (and that in most cases it's being emotionally unhealthy that lead them to pack on the weight), but extreme calorie reduction and overexercising paired with a few sessions of being bullied is NOT the way to turn around that unhealthy physical and emotional state for morbidly obese people.

      Here's the definition of anorexia nervosa: an eating disorder primarily affecting adolescent girls and young women, characterized by pathological fear of becoming fat, distorted body image, excessive dieting, and emaciation.

      I don't care if Jillian is technically at a healthy weight for her height -- she CLEARLY suffers from this psychological disorder: she freely admits (repeatedly, and at length) that she's terrified of losing control and gaining weight, and she literally spends all of her time obsessed with not only her own body, but everyone else's bodies as well. "Learning" from that is not helping anyone become healthy.

      If you're obese (or just a little overweight) and want to change your life: first make the decision to change, then turn off the TV, stay away from any "advice" from Jillian, and go out and get appropriate help -- a REAL psychologist, a REAL nutritionist, and a REAL trainer. Make a commitment to HEALTH and learning to balance eating appropriate foods with realistic exercise and focus on losing the weight slowly and permanently without it ever becoming an obsession. That will help you become healthy -- Jillian's methods will make you become thin at any cost and freak out about it: who wants to live like that? Don't be bullied into thinking it's all or nothing and the ends always justify the means! Just be healthy!!
    • JoAnnN  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Some people don't have the money to go to a psychologist, nutritionist or even a trainer. If Jillian can help some people power to her. If people would just say "This is what I want to be by this time" set their goals and stick with it they can do it. Everyone is made up of different things, some have it and some need someone to put it in their face. I have a bad back and have lost over 37 pounds just by changing the way I eat. It might not be the most fun food to eat but we all eat way more than people did 30 years ago and with all the fast food we are killing ourselves. We just need to study and find out what is in these foods and make real like changes. Unless your happy being over weight then power to you. The world is not a perfect place with perfect people. We are all shapes and size's. Note: If you would give up all beverages besides water you would lose 23 pounds in a year. That is an example of how many calories are in the things we drink.
    • Regi  •  1 year 11 months ago
      everything is great what jillian is doing, but for me, i can't excercise due to a fall on the ice, i can't use a tread meal do any jumping of any kind, i walk with a cane, planter faschitis in my left foot, 2 screws in my patella, and a 114degree bend in my left leg, 4 herniated disc in my lower back and inflamation is my sis joint and complications with my bladder. 3 herniated discs in my neck from a previous car reck sewveral yrs ago.. I still try and eat healthy but i weigh 183 pounds and 5'4 and i am going to be 55 next month, i look like i am in my middle 40's. but i have weight more so in the stomach area that i can't seem to loose...medications has put on 30 pounds and when i was in my 3o's i had a hysterectomy , i seem to have went from 135 to 155. now 155 to 183..she gives good advice for those that can walk and be mobil...I have limitiations... alot of them. i can't swim, walk without assistance, can't run. can't jump. can't squat nor climb..can't do stomach exercises due to lower back pain, can't lay on stomach due to leg pain.hmm can't stand on both feet with all weight bearing on both feet. only 50 percent on one leg...maybe she need to consider those of handicap issue that have a weight problem as well
    • A Yahoo! User  •  1 year 11 months ago
      I've never seen her show, but from what I've read I think she is telling people what they need to hear. I'm a bit of a health nut and love to exercise and find new ways to eat better, but what I hear constantly from overwight people is excuses.

      "It's not my fault I'm fat, it's because of the stress/children/job/tragedy/whatever. And I'd love to be healthy but I don't have time/money/skill to do it."

      Bullsh*t! It absolutely IS your fault that you are fat, and you DO have the ability to change that if you really want to! There are a zillion ways to eat healthy food without breaking the bank, and just as many ways to sneak workouts into your schedule. If you make it a priority in your life, health can be accomplished.

      Basically Jillian is forcing people to take responsibility for their own health, and that's a great thing.
    • Vegas Greg  •  1 year 11 months ago
      Jillian = HOT!
    • Regi  •  1 year 11 months ago
      everything is great what jillian is doing, but for me, i can't excercise due to a fall on the ice, i can't use a tread meal do any jumping of any kind, i walk with a cane, planter faschitis in my left foot, 2 screws in my patella, and a 114degree bend in my left leg, 4 herniated disc in my lower back and inflamation is my sis joint and complications with my bladder. 3 herniated discs in my neck from a previous car reck sewveral yrs ago.. I still try and eat healthy but i weigh 183 pounds and 5'4 and i am going to be 55 next month, i look like i am in my middle 40's. but i have weight more so in the stomach area that i can't seem to loose...medications has put on 30 pounds and when i was in my 3o's i had a hysterectomy , i seem to have went from 135 to 155. now 155 to 183..she gives good advice for those that can walk and be mobil...I have limitiations... alot of them. i can't swim, walk without assistance, can't run. can't jump. can't squat nor climb..can't do stomach exercises due to lower back pain, can't lay on stomach due to leg pain.hmm can't stand on both feet with all weight bearing on both feet. only 50 percent on one leg...maybe she need to consider those of handicap issue that have a weight problem as well

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.