Great Mom Debate: Is it Harder Having One Child or 9?

undefinedBy Charlotte Hilton Andersen, REDBOOK

I'll admit it. When I read this intro to an essay titled "To the Mother With Only One Child" by Simcha Fisher, I fully expected it to be about moms with one child thinking because it's so easy for them to go shopping/make their kid behave/travel that it should be the same for those of us with more. I can't tell you how many times I've had someone say to me something like, "I don't understand why you think bedtime is hard, it's the most enjoyable hour of my day!" only to realize that they've only got one kid demanding their attention instead of the zoo at my house.

Read more: 43 Sneaky Tricks to Look Younger

But boy was I wrong! And I'm glad I was wrong. Fisher's essay goes on, "Don't say: 'Wow, you have nine kids? I thought it was hard with just my one!' " She compassionately answers the questioner saying, "My dear, it is hard. You're not being a wuss or a whiner when you feel like your life is hard. I know, because I remember having 'only one child.' You may not even believe how many times I stop and reflect on how much easier my life is, now that I have nine children."

Her life easier now with nine kids than it was with just one?! At first I couldn't believe it but as I read through her essay I too remembered how steep that learning curve is going from zero to "just one." It is hard. It's really hard. And I can't believe that only 9 years after I had my first I've already forgotten that.

Related: The Best Mom Moments of All Time

Fisher concludes beautifully, "To become a mother, I had to learn how to care about someone more than I did about myself, and that was terrible. But who I am now is something more terrible: the protector who can't always protect; the one with arms that are designed to hold, always having to let go. Dear mother of only one child, don't blame yourself for thinking that your life is hard. You're suffering now because you're turning into a new woman, a woman who is never allowed to be alone. For what? Only so that you can become strong enough to be a woman who will be left."

I cried a little, both remembering those long days of being a mom of just one and also wondering what I'm doing wrong now because my life isn't easier with four kids than it was with one. I'm not saying that the first kid wasn't a tough adjustment - Fisher nails the difficulty of that stage of life perfectly - but having four kids is much, much harder for me than having one. Mostly it's from always being pulled in different directions. No one ever gets enough love and attention from me. There's never enough time or money or gummy worms to make everyone happy.

Related: Learning to Live with Kid Clutter... and Imperfections

But there's also the technical difficulties compounded by four. With one child my house stayed reasonably clean but with four it's a disaster that might someday land us our own reality show (do 9-year-old Lego collectors count as hoarders?). With one I could run errands but with four the errands run me. As in ragged. It takes 30 minutes just to get everyone into the car and another ten to get them into the store. And it's guaranteed at least one of them will pitch a fit. With one I could put him in time out and make sure he stayed there every time he was naughty but with four the only one who regularly makes it to time out is me. And with one I had lots of people willing to cuddle my adorable 9-month-old while I got a break but with four? Nobody wants to watch them except the neighbor girl whom I have to pay a lot for the privilege of one hour's peace.

Having one kid is tough but, heaven help me, four is way harder. Maybe if I get to nine it will start to turn around?

What's your opinion? Was it harder for you going from zero to one child or harder having additional children? Take our poll! (And PLEASE leave me your advice in the comments!)

Is it harder having 1 child or 9?

1. One rocked my world. It was such a huge change!

2. Going from 1 to 2 was the hardest, it was like the work quadrupled!

3. Once they outnumbered my spouse and I, it was game over

4. The more kids I've had the easier it's gotten!

Vote here!

More from REDBOOK:


redbookstamp

Permissions: Reprinted with permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.


 

20 comments

  • k8blujay  •  3 months ago
    Whoo! I can barely imagine 2 or perhaps 3, let alone 9.... Ain't no way Jose.
  • Raquel  •  Chanhassen, Minnesota  •  3 months ago
    i LOOve my daughter! Anyone that can raise more than one is SUPERWOMAN im a single mom and i barely get by but its all worth it
  • Just wondering  •  3 months ago
    Its not really fair for the older kids to have to help raise younger siblings. That's the job of the parents. If you can't raise them all equally (without having older kids pitching in), then you shouldn't have more; that's my opinion. An older sister or brother shouldn't have to be a surrogate parents to younger siblings.
    • sofi89 3 months ago
      But really, back in the "olden days" of larger families, didn't the older children, particularly the girls, help to take care of their younger siblings. And in some cases, if the mother died, the oldest daughter was the one responsible for running the house.
    • Emily 3 months ago
      I was the 2nd in a family of 7 and although I helped with siblings I never became a surrogate parent. If anything, being one of many taught me that I could do most things independently, but also that helping out (not doing the parents' work, though) made home a happier place and made me close to my siblings.
  • Amanda  •  Tampa, Florida  •  3 months ago
    It was hard going from 0 to 1, and hard in a different way going from 1-2, because with 2 it wasn't just double the "stuff" to handle, there was also the exponential difficulty of handling the children's relationship with each other. My brain hurts just thinking about it. Fortunately they're cute. And yes, a 9-year-old with a Lego addiction totally can be a hoarder. I have one at my house.
  • The Ap' Darrh's  •  Norfolk, Virginia  •  3 months ago
    "To become a mother, I had to learn how to care about someone more than I did about myself, and that was terrible. I had 6 kids and I am now on the opposite end, having to learn to care about myself more than them again. I think this is much harder than all the rest.
  • jk  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  3 months ago
    I raise my two little ones, and my two stepdaughters. I love them so much, but boy can four kids wreak a clean house. (of course six people can also clean a house real quick) The upside, You are never lonely, and there is always something to do, and cleaning with everyone can be fun and quick. The downside: A whole lot of laundry, it's expensive to feed all those mouths, and I can't buy just one kid a treat, unless I give all four of them a treat.
  • Joanna  •  3 months ago
    I have 2 boys about a year and a half apart, it was hard with one and a bit harder with 2 being so close at age, i am now 27 they are both 4 and 6 and they are awesome, they behaved a bit better when they were smaller, but life changes and real big adjustments caused some tantrums here and there, but ther have adjusted well and I would like to have atleast 2 more kids, before I am 35. My parents had my siblings and I at a young age, but they are able to play on summer teams with us and run around with their grandkids. i want to be like that but financially set first before adding to my awesome little family. It is true when you have an involved father, or even in my situation a loving BF who takes them in like his own, it will all wotrk out. Good luck to all Mommies and Daddies!
  • Becca O  •  3 months ago
    Much easier in many ways with more kids, we have 3 and my bff's have 4 and 5 respectively. The key to having a large family is everybody pitching in if all the kids help each other get dressed, do the chores and entertain each other it free's up time for mom.
    • PAM I AM 3 months ago
      Must be nice when your kids take care of your kids so you don't have to.
    • Becca O 3 months ago
      It's not that they do all the work but people think that have X kids means helping X kids do everything so that is X times more work than when you have 1. When really its not because you have help when are getting ready to go somewhere i do the youngest and the 2 older kids help each with zipping, buckling etc.
  • L m Magoo  •  3 months ago
    it's fun if the doctor and dentist are cheap, children can cost you so much money,I have two and I wish I have another one but sadly we can't afford it!!
  • E  •  3 months ago
    Different strokes for different folks. Some people are great with kids and some have a harder time. My SIL has three and they are trying for four, meanwhile me and my hubbie, who only have one, feel overwhelmed when we watch kids and have 2+ running around.
  • PAM I AM  •  3 months ago
    I've notice this my sister in law who pumped out an entire litter of children...she had all these kids now her oldest ones take care of the youngest ones. Feeding them, bathing them, dressing them, changing them, putting them to bed, walking them to school and helping them with homework. My SIL doesn't even get up off of her butt if the little ones need something...she just yells for the older kids to take care of them.
    So, Of course it's easier when you don't have to do all the work yourself!

    Helping around the house is one thing, but your kids shouldn't be made to take care of your kids.
  • m  •  3 months ago
    I think an important factor is how involved (or not) dad is. My life is infinitely easier when my husband can remove one or two from the mix if he's running and errand...and that's true even though we have four and they happen to be four good kids.
  • laughing  •  Philadelphia, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
    I have seven children, and it is hard to be a mom no matter how many you have. I have often responded to the sarcastic "God bless you, I can't imagine having another kid" with "He has, and the second one helps put the first one in perspective".
    I have seven...lots of work...and lots of reward. I love them all.
    Is this really a contest?
  • A G  •  3 months ago
    I am blessed to have the one that I have. Life would have been very difficult with more.
  • Maggie  •  Harrisburg, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
    I have two kids and knew I'd stop at 2 kids, so much so that I had my tubes tied the day after #2 was born. Thankfully they're high risk pregnancies, because it was hard enough to convince them to tie my tubes at 23! I had fun with one kid. I had fun with 2 kids. I would be krazy if I had more. Maybe because I dislike the majority of all kids everywhere, maybe because I hate squealing girls and the sound of thunder, i mean boys going upstairs. Mostly because I have a low tolerance for ill behaved children. I do think it's a wee irresponsible to have more kids than you can manage with the amount of time and money you have. 4 is spreading it pretty thin. 9 is forget about a decent prom dress for the last girls and live in nothing but hand me downs. I feel bad for 7, 8 & 9! That's gotta suck.
    • Just wondering 3 months ago
      Maggie, I couldn't agree with you more. I love well-behaved children, and can't stand parents who think their kids can do no wrong. I stopped at 2 also, because we simply knew we couldn't afford more. We have put our lives in our 2 girls and are blessed with educated (Master's Degrees!) girls, who are lovely and kind. Very fortunate. They too, can't stand bratty, spoiled, self-indulged children. There is just no reason for it! Good for you!
  • Jayne  •  3 months ago
    Have you head of birth control?

    Why keep pumping out kids when there are so many others out there that need foster homes or someone to care for them?
    • E 3 months ago
      You should be thankful your mother pumped you out instead of following genius advise like yours.
    • k8blujay 3 months ago
      1) Birth control can fail. It's not 100% (close only counts in horse shoes and hand granades).

      2) adopting or fostering can be a total emotional roller coaster with no guarantee of results (in this case ending up with a child to take care of)... and even if there is, it (like everything else in this world) isn't for everyone.
  • Brandon Sells  •  Fort Sill, Oklahoma  •  3 months ago
    I have 6 kids, 3 of em are special needs. But one was tough b/c hey it's the first kid. You don't know what to do no matter what books you had read, or what you had watched. And it hits home when you see this tiny baby and you don't know what to do! One was a nightmare at first. But then you toss in 5 more and wow. It's mega hard, but worth every minute of insanity. My spouse allows little intervals where I go to escape the chaos, so this helps. It's kinda a toss up on having one is harder or a horde is harder. It's just how you look at it.
  • JennyK  •  3 months ago
    I wouldn't know, I have twins. I don't plan on having any more because there would be a 5 year gap and the youngest would feel left out. I grew up with my brother and sister 5 and 6 years older than me and they were so much closer and I always got left out and picked on.
  • GodFree  •  3 months ago
    It depends on how dumb the woman is.
  • LJmommy  •  3 months ago
    I only have one child, and it was and still is hard making that adjustment from 0 to 1 (she is 2 and a 1/2). But I absolutely KNOW that it is harder having more than 1 child. Which is why we haven't exactly rushed to have a second. I'm not fooling myself, I'm not in the baby haze where having this beautiful little newborn just seems so perfect and romantic. I know it's WORK!
    That being said, while I can acknowledge that the parent of 2 or more children definitely has it harder than me, it is rare for the parent of multiple children to acknowledge that I maybe have a hard time too sometimes. That they were once in my position, having that only child and what an adjustment it is. So this article was a nice change for me
POLL

What gardening activities does your family help with?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options