Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    School Official Forbids Preschooler’s Homemade Lunch and Gives Her Three Chicken Nuggets Instead

    Healthy nugget lunch? Healthy nugget lunch? A four year-old pre-kindergartner's homemade lunch consisting of a turkey and cheese sandwich, a banana, a bag of potato chips, and an apple juice didn't pass muster at West Hoke Elementary School in Robeson County, North Carolina. Instead, a lunch monitor employed by the state insisted she eat the USDA-approved cafeteria lunch.

    According to a report in a local paper, the Carolina Journal, the girl's mother (who wanted to remain anonymous), discovered the switch when her daughter came home with her packed lunch untouched. When she asked what her daughter ate for lunch, the little girl responded, "Three chicken nuggets."

    USDA guidelines for pre-K programs stipulate that lunch (whether brown bagged or provided by the cafeteria) must include one serving of meat, one serving of grain, and two servings of a fruit or a vegetable. Speaking with the Journal, the child's grandmother suspected that the packed lunch was banned because of the potato chips and lack of a vegetable. A spokesperson for the Division of Child Development and Early Education and Child Development at the Department of Health and Human Services clarified and said it appeared, "the lunch itself should have met…the standard." School are not required to regulate added snack items.

    Additionally, the girl's mother pointed out, "I pack her lunch box according to what she eats. It always consists of a fruit. It never consists of a vegetable. She eats vegetables at home because I have to watch her because she doesn't care for vegetables." Consistent with her mother's observation, the girl only ate the chicken nuggets and the rest of the school lunch went to waste. The kicker? The school sent the family a bill of $1.25 and a note saying that that students who didn't bring a "healthy lunch" would be given cafeteria food as a replacement.

    While no one doubts the importance of childhood nutrition, rejecting a reasonable brown-bagged meal seems especially ludicrous when a few months ago Congress allowed that pizza can be considered vegetable for USDA-approved school lunches.

    Should home packed lunches even be subject to government regulations? Let us know what you think in the comments below.

    Copyright © 2012 Yahoo Inc.

     
    • Karin Maaka  •  Harker Heights, Texas  •  1 month 14 days ago
      Another reason to home educate!
    • RAVEN♥  •  3 months ago
      oh yeah cuz you know, processed, deep fried chicken parts are sooooooo much healthier then turkey, cheese, apple juice & bananas. The government seriously needs to butt out of so many areas of people's lives!!
      • Debby J 3 months ago
        I second that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    • Rebecca  •  Portsmouth, Ohio  •  3 months ago
      How was a turkey sandwich and a banana worse than 3 chicken nuggets????
      I'm sorry but since when is it ok for a school to tell children what to eat!
      Instead of letting the girl eat a healthy lunch that would have filled her up they gave her THREE processed chicken nuggets?
    • Lauren  •  3 months ago
      if pizza is a vegetable then apple juice is a fruit and her lunch from home was fine. also I don't particularly care for a lunch monitor who I don't know and most likely has little to no education in nutrition to decide if my child's lunch is healthy enough.
      • Big Momma 3 months ago
        ...and the cheese in the sandwich was dairy. These lunch monitors are s t u p i d
      • A Yahoo! User 3 months ago
        You wouldn't believe what is being offered in these schools, yet all the agencies are quick to point out that all these kids are sedentary techie junkies and even go so far as to produce "go outside and play" billboards and tv ads
      • Deven Devine 3 months ago
        Actually, they consider apple juice as fruit now. If you go to myplate, which is the new food pyramid, it will encourage you to use juice to get your recommended amount of fruit juice in.
    • Ghost  •  3 months ago
      What that kid had sounds a hell of a lot better than what the school gave her. If I were her parent, that school would have one huge fight on their hands.
    • Molly  •  Phoenix, Arizona  •  3 months ago
      This teacher seems to be confused about who is actually responsible for the child's health and development. It is the parents, not her, who are tasked with keeping the child healthy. It is their job to OFFER an education and OFFER a nutritious lunch, and it is the parents who are agreeing to delegate THEIR RESPONSIBILITY for both of these things to the school. Perhaps they need a reminder that schools are to serve the community, and not the other way around.
      • Geo 3 months ago
        There was no teacher involved. "Instead, a lunch monitor employed by the state insisted she eat the USDA-approved cafeteria lunch."
    • debra  •  Fort Wayne, Indiana  •  3 months ago
      This is so stupid. They need to fine a good lawyer.
      • Bill 3 months ago
        If that was my child I would need the lawyer.
      • BoaterBob 3 months ago
        No such thing as a GOOD lawyer!
      • Tiffany 3 months ago
        well, i wouldn't *fine* a lawyer, because they most likely would win. But I could *find* a lawyer, and they could possibly help me out with the lunch room thing.
    • Bonnie Belle  •  3 months ago
      I'm not surprised. Poptarts & fruit roll-ups are considered a fruit and ketchup a vegetable according to schools in my state.... pathetic. It's time schools went back to REAL cooks making REAL food and the government butting out a bit.
    • Linda  •  Houston, Texas  •  3 months ago
      Just lucky she didn't have a peanut allergy to the peanut oil that the nuggets were fried in. What a stupid program.
    • little miss cant be wrong  •  3 months ago
      Welcome to the socialism of our country and education system. Government mandates and food monitors. I find it sick, pathetic and too much like Orwell's 1984 that it makes me nervous. Forget the indocturination of the education system as a whole, but now lunches? Whats next? Forced physical education and suspensioin if they don't?
    • Kylie  •  3 months ago
      ....because the turkey and cheese is soooo awful. She had a banana and a healthy sandwich. This is stupid. Brown bag lunches are up to the parent, not the school.
    • Rosa  •  3 months ago
      chicken nuggets are so processed. The child would have had a lot more nourishment from the turkey sandwich. And what's wrong with a banana & apple juice as healthy? These D*MNED Government officials are lording-over our little kids now. I say time to beat them back.
    • MAH  •  3 months ago
      #$%$ the brown bag lunch sounds healthier than the breaded chicken nuggets with who-knows-what filler in them that were probably at one time fried. I can understand concern from school staff (I've seen some kids in my daughter's daycare with m&m's, doughnuts, and muffins for breakfast) but this was way off.
    • Big Gil  •  Carlisle, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
      Schools are no longer just a place for the three R's, they, through the Federal, State & local governments have been intruding more & more on things that "should be" up to the authority of the parent or guardian. In this case the school apologized (Big frigg'n deal), but the mother should continue to raise h*ll through the proper channels & not only refuse to pay the $1.25, but charge the school $5.oo for her wasted lunch. Insist on everything in writing otherwise the crooked #$%$ will hold her child back from some future event due to an unpaid lunch bill.
    • Jessi  •  Roseville, California  •  3 months ago
      Where the hell in the Bill of Rights or the Constitution is the US Government granted permission to regulate what food choices we make?! It should make every American's skin crawl to hear of a "state agent" inspecting children's lunches!
    • Frank  •  Ellensburg, Washington  •  3 months ago
      I am so glad that the government, who consistantly contradicts themselves, has the fore-thought to hire a lunch monitor and give power to tell children that their parents don't know whats best for them. Don't worry that anything the government tries to control seems to blow up in our faces. Big Brother knows best.
    • Robin J. Sky  •  3 months ago
      Yay for lunch monitor not even KNOWING their own guidelines!!

      "USDA guidelines for pre-K programs stipulate that lunch (whether brown bagged or provided by the cafeteria) must include one serving of meat, one serving of grain, and two servings of a fruit or a vegetable."

      "A four year-old pre-kindergartner's homemade lunch consisting of a turkey (MEAT!) and cheese sandwich (Grain!), a banana (One fruit...), a bag of potato chips, and an apple juice (Two fruit!)"

      I'm all for offering lunches at school that are healthier than the CRAP that passes for food right now, but they will never hold a CANDLE to a homemade lunch.
    • Marion  •  Jacksonville, Florida  •  3 months ago
      No way in hell government should be able to tell you what to pack for your child. Unless day after day they child brings nothing of decent value to school, and then it shouldn't be because of the food, that would be because of neglect.
    • Lauren D  •  Richardson, Texas  •  3 months ago
      USDA CAN TAKE THAT "APPROVED" LUNCH AND SHOVE IT UP THEIR #$%$ I'LL BE THE FIRST TO VOLUNTEER TO SHOVE IT UP THERE FOR THEM.
    • Sarah  •  Eugene, Oregon  •  3 months ago
      As a child I forgot my lunch once and had to eat the "Hot" lunch provided by the school, having never eaten a corn dog in my life, I cried when I got my lunch tray!

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.