Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    The opposite of a 'Tiger Mother': leaving your children behind

    Rahna Reiko Rizzuto, author of Rahna Reiko Rizzuto, author of Rahna Reiko Rizzuto says that she never wanted to be a mother.

    "I had this idea that motherhood was this really all-encompassing thing," she explained on the Today Show, where she was talking about her new memoir, "Hiroshima in the Morning." "I was afraid of being swallowed up by that."

    Ten years ago, when her sons were 5 and 3, Rizzuto received a fellowship to spend six months in Japan, researching a book about the survivors of Hiroshima. Four months in, when her children came to visit, she had an epiphany: She didn't want to be a full-time mother anymore. When she returned to New York, she ended her 20-year marriage and chose not to be her kids' custodial parent.

    Now, Rizzuto is an author and a faculty member at Goddard College in Vermont, where she teaches in creative writing. Her boys are teenagers-and, she says, they're fine. In fact, their relationship not only survived her leaving, but "has improved."

    "I had to leave my children to find them," she writes in an essay at Salon.com. "In my part-time motherhood, I get concentrated blocks of time when I can be that 1950s mother we idealize who was waiting in an apron with fresh cookies when we got off the school bus and wasn't too busy for anything we needed until we went to bed. I go to every parent-teacher conference; I am there for performances and baseball games."



    But when that 1950s mother she describes as ideal had to cope with parenthood 24/7, she didn't get to pick and choose which parts to be present for. The idea that a mother could love her children and still choose to leave them to pursue her own goals is the antithesis of being a 'Tiger Mother'-Amy Chua ignited a fiery debate with the release of her book about being a perfection-demanding Eastern-style parent, omnipresent in her daughters' lives. It also goes against our culture's definition of motherhood. But it shines a light on a glaring double standard: When a man chooses not to be a full-time parent, it's acceptable-or, at least, accepted. But when a woman decides to do so, it's abandonment.

    The decision isn't an easy one to make, no matter how you feel about parenting. "‪It took me about a year to decide once the idea came to me," says Talyaa Liera. In 2008, she chose to move 3,000 miles away from three of her four children (her oldest is an adult and out on her own).‪ "At the time I was a heavily involved, attachment-parenting Waldorf mom. I did the whole family bed, breastfeeding-into-toddlerhood, baby-wearing thing. I was at home with them for 10 years before their father and I split up, and stayed at home after that, trying to create a writing career to support myself."‬

    ‪After a lengthy custody battle and two years of joint custody, she realized that her ex-husband (a pilot with an erratic schedule) wasn't going to change, and her situation wasn't going to change, unless she decided to change things for herself. "I realized that by being so nurturing, I was in some ways keeping my children from growing to their potential," she says. "We talked about it for months and we prepared together, not really knowing what being 3,000 miles apart might look like or feel like.‬"

    When the time came to get in her packed car and drive away, she says, she felt "‪very mixed." ‬

    ‪"Yes, there is a sense of relief. I would be remiss if I did not admit that," she says candidly. But there was also pain: "‬I used to avoid Target, for instance, because it made me think of shopping for my daughter Serena. Little moments like that, and everything comes flooding in."

    Now a spiritual adviser who writes at Polaris Rising, Liera wrote about her experiences as a non-custodial parent at Literary Mama and Parenting Without a Manual. Her children are 15, 11, and 7 now and, after more than two years of long-distance parenting, Liera says she misses them but feels very connected to them. "‪Now we stay in touch by phone, IM, Skype a few times a week," she says. "I hear about their lives and give support.‬"

    ‪"I have been a mother since I was 20," she points out. "I did not have the life a normal 20 year old would have. While I don't regret that, I knew that I now have the opportunity to reconnect with who I might have been then, but with all the tools and skill sets I have learned through motherhood. I have the unique opportunity most women don't get to have, of being able to truly create the life I wish to have, do something in the world that makes a difference, and model this kind of independence for my children."‬

    After Amy Chua's story went viral, many women said they felt they needed to adopt a bit of the tiger mom mentality, that maybe they were a little too lenient with their kids. In any case, it's evident that there's no one-size-fits-all when it comes to motherhood. But does striking out on your own or being a "Hiroshima Mom" take free-range parenting to an extreme?

    "This is the question people will ask me. The question that curls, now, in the dark of the night," Rizzuto writes in "Hiroshima in the Morning." "How do any of us decide to leave the people we love?"

    Like this story? Follow us on Twitter for more.

    Also on Shine:

     
    • Mister Morning Star  •  21 days ago
      I can't help but wonder what the reaction would be if a man took an overseas job then one day decided he didn't want to be a parent and also asked for a divorce.
      • Ashley 21 days ago
        The same. Another dead beat parent.
    • GhettoRanger  •  10 days ago
      Nothing but a selfish POS! Who feeds the kids? Who takes them to school? Being a parent is not a job you just quit because there are other things you would rather do, you are supposed to be responsible, you are supposed to be the two people that your children can depend on, what she doesn't mention is the devastation she caused her children. She'll get hers some day.
    • Jordan  •  Aurora, Colorado  •  21 days ago
      My father tried that. I lied, and said I was fine, and really it destroyed my life. I wanted him to be there for everything, and instead, he was living his life, and making himself happy. Once you become a parent, your child(ren) are your commitment. Period. End of story. if you can't 100% be ready to slow down your personal life, or stop the more fun, exciting part of not being tied down to one place, don't have children. Or for heaven's sake, don't walk away from them. I find it no excuse to just walk away and leave, and am shocked to hear that her "relationship has improved" with her boys.
      • Iman 15 days ago
        Dear Jordan, for me I thought it is an easy thing since everyone is doing it, no one was there to tell me the truth. Until I experienced motherhood and found out how hard it is. Athough, it is my decision and I have to be responsible for it, that doesn't make it any easier or make me happy. Some people choose to scarifice while others choose to run away. the point is you never know this fact before having children, therefore, most of us cant decide not to have children from the beginning. It is just the nature of life.
      • GhettoRanger 10 days ago
        My wife walked out on me and my daughters without a word of warning we were all devastated, I watched my girls cry their hearts out and then got pretty crazy they're better now but what she did left deep scars and the daughters that loved her so much now hate her guts.
      • Jennifer 9 days ago
        I know how you all feel. My dad packed up all his stuff and left when my mom was at work, and my sister and I were at school. We did not hear any thing from him for 6 months we thought he was dead. My point in all of this is I had to grow up really fast I was the youngest one and I had to take care of my mom and sister. I didn't feel that I could show I was upset I wanted to protect them I was 7 yrs old. Now my sister and I both have a really hard time trusting any man. I do talk to him still but that is because my mother always made us we had no choice she still stuck up for him with all the heart ache he left her with.So I do not see how any parent can just leave. he tells me all the time he left her not us but he moved to Florida which is 1500 miles away from us. My sister and I knew he just didn't love us enough to stay he always felt other woman were more important to him then the 3 of us! We never got over it and I am now 30 years aol and I don't think I ever will. So now that I have 3 boys of my own I am always bugging them telling them how much I love them and they mean to me. I know one day they will understand but until then I am the crazy mom lol. They all are still little.
    • Ashley  •  21 days ago
      My step-daughters mother took off when she was very young. They see eachother three or four times a year, talk several times a week on the phone and she has an idea of what's going on in her daughters life. She loves her mother. What her mother doesn't see and what my step-daughter would never tell her is the pain and anguish she goes through because her mother isn't there. She's 12 and in 7th grade and her mother has never been in a classroom, never met a teacher, never been to a talent show or a family night. She's never met her friends or been to a birthday party. Her mother will come to town either the weekend before or after her birthday, but the only time she's ever been there on the actual day was the day she gave birth. But parenting is so much more than scheduled events. It's those moments, those irreplaceable moments. Knowing when they are sad, hungry, happy, frustrated just by a look or a sigh. What are these women thinking? Oh yeah, about themselves. It screws the kids up! And it goes for the men, too, who shirk from their obligations. These children are your responsibility, you brought them into this world. Boohoo, "It's not what I expected" or "It's not what I want". Put on your big girl panties. I have no respect for Ms. Lierra or Ms. Riuzzo. In the end it's them that will suffer for not being there for their children. At least they are temporarily happy with their decision. Hope there's no animosty for your decision when it's time to choose your nursing home.
      • Ashley 21 days ago
        Rizutto* Sorry.
      • S 21 days ago
        I agree. While it was nice to have my mom away because I knew that's what SHE needed and her not having time alone was detrimental to the family, I resent her for not being around. I love my mom and can tell her anything, when she will take the time to talk to me. But even as an adult, I feel sad when I think about the distance she must be from her 6 kids in order for her to be a happy mom. She started off like Rizutto too - a SAHM that did everything for her kids. Then she went nuts because she couldn't handle it. Some people arent meant to have children.
      • doglover 21 days ago
        couldn't have said it better. Being a parent is not like deciding what clothes to wear. Parents aren't made during the "events", parents are made in the every day, and relationships are made in the ups & downs. This makes me ill to read it.
    • Jella  •  Denver, Colorado  •  14 days ago
      This one sided story is ridiculous. "Oh my kids are fine and we are connected" when before you left you were overtly attached? Kids don't naturally flip and flop, they need stability and love not skype and selfishness. GET REAL.
    • Candie  •  12 days ago
      My Dad left us. It was 1977 and divorce was becoming popular. I can understand bailing on marriage, but bailing on kids is heartless. As an adult, I don't know my Dad. I am not bonded to him. It affected everything about me - including my selection of a husband. I decided I did not want my "dad" in my kids life as he is like a stranger to me. He threw a fit when I told him. Funny, I never regret it - maybe I am more like my dad than my siblings are like him - I am able to ignore relationships. ;)
    • Haley  •  9 days ago
      It's all good and fine for the moms who leave their kids, but what about the dads? These women are leaving the fathers with double the parenting responsibilities so they can run off and be 20 years old again. Of course the mothers like how they've been able to walk away from everything, but this article has neglected to ask the fathers and -most importantly- the children how it's affected them. I feel like this kind of abandonment would cause some serious emotional issues for those kids.
    • doglover  •  Jacksonville, Florida  •  21 days ago
      It's a good thing she "never wanted to be a mother", because she isn't.
    • Dawn  •  Beaverton, Oregon  •  21 days ago
      I have four children and I am going to marry a man who has four children. Both of our ex spouses did very similar things. They left our children and left us with full custody and said they weren't cut out to be parents full time. It was rough at first, but my kids are doing ok. His kids are still having a very hard time. They cried themselves to sleep for months. They fight and bicker and have problems at school. It is obvious they are extremely insecure. They don't care that their mother is now feeling more fulfilled and loves her new life. They are children, they aren't capable of that kind of emotional depth. They just care that their life has been shattered, they miss their mother, nothing will ever be the same, and now they are scared every day that other people will leave them. As far as her seeming more happy now......what message does that send? That tells them (and other children in this situation) "you were so awful and unlovable that I had to get away from you to be happy." Is that the message we want to send our children? If she had just decided to pursue a career while still staying with the children, she could come home every day and see them and they could see her grow and be happy in her career AND continue to love and nurture them on a day to day basis. She should be telling them "I can find personal fulfillment AND still be a mother to you" not "I have to stop being a mother to find personal fulfillment and be happy." Every single person who has commented that we should ask how the kids feel are right!! No child wants their parent to be gone or thinks its a good situation. UNLESS the parent was abusive and unloving.
    • Tanaya H  •  Dallastown, Pennsylvania  •  22 days ago
      I just ran into this page on accident. I have very mixed feelings, after reading alot of the comments I still feel the same way. My Mother was single I really didnt see our dad. My mom drank and partied and wasnt home that oftened. I raised my sister and brother. Let me tell you that didnt turn out that well. I had a son at 15 and a daughter at 19. I did it alone for awhile, Then found a nice man to help. I just feel like it is important for a child to feel wanted and loved. I raised my children the best I could, I was always there when they needed me and i did put my life on hold. I am 31 now and my son is 15 and daughter 12. They told me they feel important and loved. I am the best mom. Lilly says Im better then some older parents. That makes me laugh, ppl still stare when I say Im their mother. Any way, I believe it damages a child for a parent (mother or father) to abandan them. You as a parent might not think you are abandaning the child because u call and skype, but its not what u think. It is how the child feels. If your child feels abandaned then you should change your parenting style. No, I dont believe that you have to throw away all your dreams but you desided to have a kid so you did chose to give up a lot. I feel sorry for the ladies who left their children. I feel bad for the children. They are missing a lot and the ladies will regret it. Hope people make the best choice for them. Mine was to spend as much time with the kids as i can. I can have a life after they have started theirs. As of right now they are my life. Even though I was a kid myself when I had them and didnt plan them, I decided to keep them. My job is to raise level headed respectful adults. I would like to runaway some days, I COULD NOT imagine life without them.
    • michi  •  Ashburn, Virginia  •  3 months ago
      If you didn't want kids from the start then you should've used a contraceptives.
    • Erin  •  New York, New York  •  3 months ago
      With parenting like that maybe it IS better to be separated by thousands of miles. The only thing worse than no parent is a self-absorbed, selfish one like her!

      If you never wanted to be a mother, then why did you have kids?
      • LethalLaugh 3 months ago
        Shut up all of you. Men leave their families every day and nobody says "boo" about it! Equality is equality. It takes two to conceive, why is it the woman's sole problem? You jerks are all overgrown pregnant teenagers with insecurity issues. Phaugh! Phaugh on you all.
      • A Yahoo! User 3 months ago
        And because men do it, it's alright for women to do as well??? Not to mention that you're painting a very broad picture of "men" in your statement.
        Your resort to insults suggest that maybe you've done this "free-range" parenting yourself. Quite sad for the kids involved.
      • Mister Morning Star 21 days ago
        LethalLaugh - Men leave their families every day and lots of people say Boo about it. As well they should. And double Phaugh on you.
    • J  •  Salt Lake City, Utah  •  3 months ago
      had to lose them to find them?? if every parent did that, can you imagine the devastation that would occur- she should have lost all parental rights and contact- she abandoned them....what a disgrace to Vermont....
    • evelyn  •  Elmhurst, Illinois  •  3 months ago
      "leave children to find them?" Give me a break. She abandoned them.
    • MDYB  •  3 months ago
      "When a man chooses not to be a full-time parent, it's acceptable-or, at least, accepted."

      This may well be true in her cultural circle, but it isn't true around here. When a man walks out on his family, the other men lose respect for him. I see more and more women walking out on their children and men taking up both roles. I am even seeing more men that divorce their wives so that they can get the children away from the abusive or neglectful mother.
    • KatieJo  •  3 months ago
      I think this story is a gross misrepresentation of what "full time parenting" really is. A full time parent can have their own career, hobbies and interests and they should! Very few people are cut out to be modern-day June Cleavers, and this article sheds a bad light on that.
    • veronica  •  Wichita Falls, Texas  •  3 months ago
      she didn't have a "normal 20 year old life" give me a break i was 16...i finished school while working 2 jobs and raised my child.... i put giving her a life first and have returned to school to finish my degree. she didn't want to a mother any more? pleeaassse! what about the responsiblity to raise her children w/o malice? and she thinks she should be applauded for that. what are her kids relationship with the oppisite sex? can anyone say abandonment issues? selfish witch. but i guess it better than her staying and taking it out on the kids. seems the type.
    • Samantha  •  3 months ago
      The "free range model" that the women want to be (where you are a perfect 1950's housewife only a month or so out of the year) is... a grandmother. The most important thing a parent does is provide a day to day role model. Children absorb their mental and social skills by watching their parents. And yeah, everyone LOVES their grandmothers because they are so cute and nice and they're your best friend forever... but that's not the purpose of a parent.
    • k  •  Albany, New York  •  3 months ago
      Wow... you don't have to be "over nurturing" to be a mother in your childs life. This is one of the most selfish things I have ever read from a mother. Every decision she made was out of selfishness but she's trying to play it like this is some kind of new age parenting tactic. They say when you love something, let it go. That applies to romance, not your children. That's not a mother's love. There are plentyuf successful women with children, she obviously sucks at multi tasking. I can't stand people who stereotype family life.
    • A Yahoo! user  •  Skokie, Illinois  •  3 months ago
      Children who are abandoned by their mother have a great many issues because of it. I've seen if first-hand with a number of relatives, even my own husband and his siblings. Call it what you want, "free range parenting" is still abandoning your child. Has anyone asked these folks' kids what they think about this situation, I bet, if they can be honest, they'll say it stinks! How do any of you decide to leave the people you love? My answer to you is that you are self-centered and love no one and nothing but yourself. That's how. This whole situation is wrong and out of order. You made the decision to have children, now you're trying to back out of it - too late sister. What does this lady consider "normal?" There are millions of women who have been parents since they were 20 or younger, and didn't choose to abandon their young children. SELFISH! If I were her husband, I would have divorced her too. The kids are probably better off without her, how selfish can you be, and then the gall to act like you've actually done something positive and groundbreaking. Such #$%$

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.