By Pater Familias, Illustration by Peter Arkle
Shortly after the birth of our only daughter, now seven years old, a veteran mama (one girl, two boys) said this to me about having kids:
"Best mistake I ever made."
She said it with a smile. From time to time I repeat her words, her way -- loving the mad Möbius mood loop of being my kid's at-home daddy, married to her mommy.
I wouldn't have it any other way. This I know because for a long time my wife and I lived looking at a terrible, irrevocable, heartbreaker mistake - waiting too long to have our baby - which thank God we didn't quite make. Right when we were giving up, TahDah! our own little girl. On the worst daddy days, I never forget how lucky we are, that the kid driving me nuts is a miracle, and that life without her would be so much less. Less hectic and maddening, sure. But also less full. Less rewarding. Less happy.
This puts me out of sync with the tone and content of All Joy And No Fun, cover story of the current (July 12) issue of New York magazine. The piece cuts between a review of research showing that people with kids are measurably less happy than those without and personal anecdote and speculation about why American parenthood, in a word, sucks.
Applause for the writer Jennifer Senior, who gives us a great, informative read. But Sheesh, Lady, is it really so bad?
Senior's article opens with an account of her own homecoming to her 2 ½-year-old boy, waiting on the stoop with the nanny. All is huggy and idyllic until the writer goes inside and sees the boy broke a toy she put together that morning. Then the kid goes demonic, throwing pieces of the thing at her, so she gives him a time out.
So far, so 2 ½-year-old, right? But listen to Mom: "I'd been in a state of pair-bonded bliss; now I was guided by nerves, trawling the cabinets for alcohol?"
A smile, in the spirit of my "best mistake" friend, would do more for her and Junior than a drink, which I sincerely hope she was kidding about.
The story, backed up by my years out here in upscale, overthinking Parentland, has me worried about the inexplicable downside focus and critical shortage of smiles. This can't be good for either children or parents. And it seems just wrong. Parenthood is nothing to fret about, or frown about.
What about you? Would life better - happier - if you had chosen not to be a parent?
Pater-Familias, is an at-home writer/father who blogs the male side of the story. Read P-F on....
Fatherly bliss, Accidentally hitting on moms
The daughterized dad, Mad bad dad
Cook, eat Father food
Listen to Music to father by



126 comments