Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Thanksgiving for Those Who Hate Turkey


    Dear BA Foodist,

    I have a dirty secret: I hate turkey. And I want to do something about it. Can I just forgo the fowl this year?

    -Josephina Mccarthy, Gallup, NM

    Try Six Turkey-Free Menus from Restaurants Around the Country

    Dear Josephina,
    You traitor. Of all the unpatriotic acts to commit, I know of none more severe than not serving turkey on Thanksgiving. It's what the Pilgrims served, and it's what our grandchildren will serve.

    I'd load the musket and demand you take back what you said-if only I didn't feel the same way.

    Not Hosting? 16 Perfect Dishes to Bring to Thanksgiving

    The Foodist hates turkey. There, I admit it. I've always had turkey on Thanksgiving. I've had it roasted, brined and roasted, deep-fried, smoked, and stuffed with a chicken and a duck (Turducken). No matter what kind of turkey I cook-factory-farmed, wild, heritage breed-it always underwhelms, even when it's perfectly cooked with juices flowing. What would turkey be without gravy or cranberry sauce? Not much. And when was the last time you saw turkey on the menu at a well-regarded restaurant?

    Thanksgiving is at my house this year, and-Mom, please take note-I'm not serving turkey. I'm considering venison, rabbit, or duck. Maybe braised short ribs and roasted loin of beef with stone-ground grits, like the menu offerings on Thanksgiving at Quality Meats in New York. Perhaps even a suckling pig.

    Try Our Recipe for Roasted Pork Loin with Poached Plums

    There are other American proteins we could serve with pride on Thanksgiving. Maybe now that we've both come clean about our dislike of the bird, others will join the flock.

    More from bon appétit:

     

    54 comments

    • Harlem  •  2 years 7 months ago
      HOW could you hate turkey it is so good best part about thanksgiving. But if you don't like turkey there's always an alternative known as CHICKEN! Unless of course you son't like chicken either than there's lamb but if you don't like any of those find a selection you like. GOOD LUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    • Jett  •  2 years 7 months ago
      Oh, oops. Sorry Josephine. I mixed up the names and thought the person who answered your question was Josephine. Therefore, ANDREW, I kindly direct you to my last post.
    • Julia  •  2 years 7 months ago
      I hate turkey too :( It tastes like paper to me. Only smothered with gravy do I enjoy it.
    • Joy in Seattle  •  2 years 7 months ago
      Duh - you make a HAM! I love spiral ham way more than turkey.
    • Cherokee  •  2 years 6 months ago
      goobble, goobble, gooble de guck,,,try greasy duck
    • JR  •  2 years 7 months ago
      I hate turkey also, and since im dominican we ate pernil (pork sholder) for Thanksgiving, and for any other special occasion
    • Habanero♥™  •  2 years 7 months ago
      Angels stuffing, Mashed potatoes, Cranberry sauce, White corn niblets, Crescent rolls, Gravy....you won't miss the turkey.
    • SJ  •  2 years 7 months ago
      My "family" quit having turkey for Thanksgiving several years ago. The time and trouble it takes to prepare and serve the traditional meal of turkey, mashed potatoes, gravy, green bean casserole, sweet potatoes, etc is a bit much and getting it to the table hot or even lukewarm is an exercise in defeat. For the past few years we have gone global with our holiday meals. We have done an Asian theme and an Italian theme. This year it will be Mexican...guacamole, mexican deviled eggs, salsa, salad, enchiladas, rice. Try something completely out of the ordinary if you don't want the turkey and save a bird's life!
    • ILoveFriday  •  2 years 7 months ago
      One year when I was little, my parents ordered a couple of pizzas the day before Thanksgiving ~ we ate pizza all day on Turkey Day.
    • tasha  •  2 years 7 months ago
      Nothing but the side dishes!!!!
    • .  •  2 years 7 months ago
      I stopped doing turkey a few years ago, the only time we have it for Thanksgiving is when we go to my dad's house. I make anything else but turkey for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Prime rib, bar-b-que ribs, steak, pizza, egg rolls etc. I also skip most of the sides and won't make a pumpkin pie YUK.
    • jobena  •  2 years 7 months ago
      We have a baked ham and standing rib roast, we don't have turkey. Then we can have still have all the other good things that are still part of the special day, sweet patotoes go good with ham, mashed patotoes goes good with the beef plus all the other good things, pumpkin pie, apple pie. Make your Thanksgiving a day of family, really who cares what you eat as long as your're with family and friends. Hope all have a good day not matter what you eat.
    • PORSCHE  •  2 years 7 months ago
      I stopped serving turkey 2 years ago. It has been replaced with prime rib, and everyone in my family loves it!
    • Mhu Cao  •  2 years 7 months ago
      A quote from childhood: "You'll eat what's put in front of you and enjoy it!"
    • Angel  •  2 years 7 months ago
      As long as there is stuffing (w/ celery & onions - none of that fruity tasting kind w/ raisins) I could care less about the bird served!
    • mirr2000  •  2 years 7 months ago
      My family aren't big fan of the turkey either. We make lasagna instead.
    • Melissa N  •  2 years 6 months ago
      Hey, I am not the only turkey hater. My family is talking pork roast; I hope so, I actually started physically gagging last time I tried to eat it.
    • NikNik  •  2 years 7 months ago
      I don't like turkey either!! I know it is crazy but it's nice to know there are more of us out there. I am from the South and we just have ham. Soooo much better!! Thanks to my grandmother who also (gasp) did not like turkey. :)
    • annie  •  2 years 7 months ago
      What do you serve the turkey hater on T'Giving?

      All the sides.....
    • You dont need to know  •  2 years 7 months ago
      My son also hates turkey, and I can take it or leave it. Ham is the way to go when you have a big group to cook for. It's easy to bake and clean up after. And if someone really needs turkey there is always someplace you can pick up an one or two person order of precooked turkey.

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.