Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Should there be a law against all cell phone use while driving?Should there be a law against all cell phone use while driving?Note to road warriors who try to work during their commute: You may have to find another time for that conference call. Last week, the National Transportation and Safety Board recommended that states should ban all cell phone use by drivers -- including talking on speakerphone, using a hands-free device, and texting -- in order to minimize distractions. And it turns out that plenty of people agree with them.

    According to a new poll by Sodahead.com, 58 percent of respondents would support such a ban.

    The board started considering the ban after a deadly accident near Gray Summit, Missouri, in August 2010. A 19-year-old was driving his pickup truck while texting, and rammed into the back of a tractor-trailer at 55 miles per hour. A school bus then rear-ended the pickup and crushed it, and a second school bus slammed into the first. The 19-year-old driver had received five text messages and sent six, CNN reported; he and a 15-year-old student on one of the school busses were killed and 38 other people were injured.

    Drivers younger than 21 years old are banned from texting while driving, NTSB member Robert Sumwalt told the Associated Press, but the law wasn't been aggressively enforced at the time of that accident.

    "Without the enforcement, the laws don't mean a whole lot," he said.

    According to the Sodahead.com poll (which is ongoing -- there were 1,714 votes at 2:30 p.m. ET on Monday), women are more likely than men to support the ban, as are people who are old enough to have teenage drivers at home.

    "I say, stay home or pull over to use the phone," Linda Madrid commented about the Sodahead poll. "We did fine before the cell phone. People are spoiled."

    Others agreed. "I feel that it should be banned," a reader named Jenn wrote. "Back in May of this year my husband and I were struck by a car. We could see the car coming but could not see the driver, this woman was digging her cell phone out the floor of her car after she had dropped it. We were both hurt if we had not been wearing our seat belts at the time, we could have been killed."

    "And texting while driving that leads to a crash should be felony-level attempted murder," added Lanikai. "I was hit by a texting driver. Her insurance still hasn't paid the costs."

    But some respondents pointed out that banning cell phones could be a slippery slope. "If you ban cell phones completely while driving, even hands free like my sync, then you must also outlaw radios and threaten any passenger from talking to you while you drive. These are all distractions," wrote Catch224u, who voted "no" in the poll.

    Sodahead reader RobertTimsah also voted "no." Talking on your cell phone while driving is "no more dangerous than talking or arguing with a person next to you while you drive," he points out. "If someone keeps using a cell phone while they drive and cause wrecks, then they will have to take personal responsibility for it with higher premiums and lawsuits because they're too stupid to stop doing it."

    "Even if you pass a law, the people who vote "yes" will be the first ones who break the law repeatedly because they're the moms who want government to destroy our freedoms to make us safer," he continued. "However, when they get calls in the car they deep down fear it's a loved one trying to reach them in a dangerous situation so they'll answer irrespective of the law."

    The ban is popular among parents: 67 percent of about-to-be parents and 54 percent of respondents with kids said they'd support the ban. Support was highest among people age 65 and older (66 percent) and those who are too young to drive in most states (13- to 17-years-old, 64 percent). And those who are old enough to vote stayed true to their political ideals: Just 37 percent of Libertarian respondents said they'd support the ban, while 68 percent of Progressives were in favor of it.

    What do you think? Would you be in favor of a law that forbids all cell phone use by drivers, or should people be allowed to talk and text if it seems safe enough?




    Also on Shine:

    Teaching teens to be responsible drivers
    Moms, be honest: What are you doing in the car besides driving?
    1 in 5 admit to "surfing" while driving

     

    55 comments

    • Chief  •  Dayton, Ohio  •  4 months ago
      I use a handsfree device, yet very seldome use the phone while I'm driving. Too often I see drivers of all ages pauing more attention to their phones than their driving. Those people normally become one thing -- A STATISTIC.
    • Momma  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  4 months ago
      Ban cellphone is a good idea,that is for all ages. I think there will be less accidents.
    • k8blujay  •  4 months ago
      Actually as a parent, I wouldn't want a ban on cellphones... I rarely look at my phone when I use it... and I use my Sync system in my car. And in my opinion, I am more distracted in my own thoughts than I am talking to my mom on my 25-45 minute commute home. There have been times when I am so tired or just thinking about a plethora of other things that I don't even know how I got home. And so what if there is one less distraction... there are still going to be constant distractions when driving anyway... and I'm not worried about my driving, I'm worried about the person in front of me that is going to stop short on an off ramp when they were supposed to yield and had a clear lane almost causing a multi car wreck behind her (of which she wouldn't even have been in).
    • Payne  •  Tucson, Arizona  •  4 months ago
      YES, cell phones shold be banned worldwide while driving. People should pull over to the side (off driving road) to answer, talk, and make calls with their cell phones. How many times have you been behind drivers driving below the speed limit, and once you get pass them, they are on their cell phone?
    • Aldo Alday Allnight  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  4 months ago
      Forget about banning cell phones! I think we need to focus on educating drivers on proper road etiquette/procedures! Ultimately I believe people should be focused on the road, period. Keep the flow of traffic moving. Use signals. Be aware of your surroundings. Move to a slow lane for speedy drivers etc.
      • k8blujay 4 months ago
        If I could give you 1000 thumbs up I would... because I know around here practically no one uses their turn signals..
    • Joshua  •  Kampala, Uganda  •  4 months ago
      WHAT THE EYE SEES IS NOT WHAT THE BRAIN REGISTERS! Most or half of fatal accidents are caused by Driver error.including lapses in attention.One common reason is,what the eye sees is not what the brain registers.
      When drivers are looking right at something as they speak on a cell phone, they are quite likely not see it. Just because the eyes are looking at something outside the window, it does not mean the brain is going to process it.
      Talking on a cell phone, halves the amount of visual information drivers process.So, while talking on a cell phone, your eyes may be focused on the road a head, but your is often elsewhere.
      I would therefore be in favor of a law that forbids all cell phone use by drivers.
    • Joe Blount  •  New York, New York  •  4 months ago
      ban them please please please
    • pogiejo  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  4 months ago
      Seat belts save drivers,Cell phones kill drivers, Pass the law like they did for seat belts.
      Cut out the percentage of people who want it passed and those who don't ,and pass it before more people die.Has anyone lost a family member in a car accident with a cell phone in their hand. Case Dismissed,Think about it.
    • Sheila B  •  Wichita, Kansas  •  4 months ago
      YES YES YES
    • Kathy Garcia  •  Oklahoma City, Oklahoma  •  4 months ago
      well yeah cell phones should be banned while driving look at all the accident's their are they have their eye's more on the cell-phone than they do the roads...
    • Vitina  •  Jackson, Mississippi  •  4 months ago
      I feel that some one should look at the point of view that we need our cell phone while driving because of the fact that something might happen to any one and you cant use your phone because of this so called law that they are tryin to pass..If they want to talk about law it's unfair how they give you more time for selling drugs then killing and individual. Someone need to check into that before they try to stop cell phone talk,text while driving,I understand the texting part it can be a bit distractive,but completely ban cell phone while driving doesn't make sense to me cause yo eyes has nothin to do wit yo ear to a phone.Regardless of the fact accidents was happen before cellphones. For Example: DUI,Rectless drivers,speeding etc. They haven't ban that. you get a DUI and right back on da road doing the same thing.Come on people lets get it together. That's not the only reason for accidents..
    • Amanda  •  4 months ago
      I agree with banning this to some extent. I have bluetooth built into my car, it allows to keep 2 hands on the wheel and pay attention to the road. I do not text and drive, it's part of a contract I signed through my employer. You don't know how many people I pass who are swerving and texting, or talking and driving (on the phone, no headset) well under the speed limit because they aren't paying attention. People are not being safe drivers at all. I was in a car accident a few months ago and the guy that rear ended me was going about 50 mph, didn't see me put my blinker on to turn right because he was on his phone.
    • meg d  •  5 months ago
      You can't prevent every distraction like passengers and radios, but why not eliminate an unneccessary distraction that has been proven to cause otherwise preventable accidents? Some of the reasoning for not banning cell use is a little over the top- "they'll take away all of my rights" these people would be the first people to cry when their kids are killed by a texting driver or someone who looked down to dial a cell phone number- and in certain countries (like England) it is illegal to eat, drink, or talk on phones while driving and penalties are steep. Personally I think people should lose their license if they get caught on the phone or texting. I commute every day and can easily point out which drivers on on their cell phones or texting based on how they are driving. They drive too slow, block passing lanes, change lanes to exit at the very last minute, don't use indicators and are a danger to others. If is wasn't so well documented that phones and texting cause accidents, why do investigators now automatically pull cell phone records when there is a vehicle accident?
      • Trish C 5 months ago
        talking on the phone or texting is a legitimate concern, but this article discusses banning hands-free devices as well. I just don't see how a hands-free device is any different than talking to other passengers in the car.
      • colleen 5 months ago
        "They drive too slow, block passing lanes, change lanes to exit at the very last minute, don't use indicators and are a danger to others." These are not drivers using cell phones, but just bad drivers. I rarely see people use signals anymore and they do not have phones in their hands. And as far as pulling cell phone records, I find that to be a violation of my privacy. Investigators are pulling these records to Find someone or something to blame. Many people can't drive properly whiel talking or texting. Some can. Many people can't drive even without distractions. Cell phones are easy to blame, but removing the phones won't fix the problem.. which is that people don't know how to drive properly period.
      • W.R 5 months ago
        true. it's not the either or thinking. lets take it one at a time and make progress that way. I agreee.
    • MITCHELL  •  Arden, North Carolina  •  4 months ago
      Most definately. Stop people from concertrating on who and what they are talking about. And drive and keep alert. " The Life You Save May Be Your Own". TEXTING WHILE DRIVING "KILLS" Think about it!!!!!!!!
    • Rosa  •  4 months ago
      If we ban cell phone use while driving then we're going to have a bunch of idiots that stop traffic so they can take a call. The guy doing 80 in the fast lane is going to slam on his brakes and cut across five lanes of traffic to pull off on the shoulder or, if we're lucky, to take the next exit and fully get off the road. Sorry. Not gonna work. I agree it is dangerous to have people typing and dialing and talking while driving, but not sure a ban is going to fix it.
    • Linda Made in the USA  •  Denton, Texas  •  5 months ago
      I say yes. You can always go stop some where an talk. People are always hold up traffic and not watch the road and the car in front of tem. I have seen people T-ing . I really get tired of it.I have acell phone and I never answere it when I drive. But I let My husband answere my phone when I am driving and he talks to them for me. My husband was in a bad rack in 2006, disabled him for life because of that. Just think about that.......
    • mgmkid  •  5 months ago
      Drive the #$%$ car, period.
    • Greg B  •  Derwood, Maryland  •  4 months ago
      Many people text while driving, and sometimes the police personnel do not even care,
      I have seen poilice personnel look at a driver texiting, and not do anything about it. Kind of like when police see some one jay walking. Yes it is agaisnt the law, but it is a law that police do not enforce much.
    • amanda  •  Missoula, Montana  •  5 months ago
      i've heard debates of putting devices in cars that would block all cell phone use. all. cell. phone. use. that means texting and callls. i'm not saying its safe to beon the phone, but heres the thing. its peoples choice. plain and simple. texting is worse than a phone call though. but phones shouldnt be entirely outlawed. what if theres an emergency? you have to pick up your kid from school, but got stuck in traffic, and need to let the school know? or if you think you left a burner on, to call someone to check? seriously, banning things entirely takes away peoples ability to think for themselves.
      • buffalogal 5 months ago
        Amanda, If there is an emergency you should pull of the road, stop your car and make your call. Somehow we all managed to deal with "emergencies" before cell phones. As for it being someone's choice, should you be allowed to drive drunk?
    • Adela  •  5 months ago
      In CA you are not allowed to text, or have your cell to your ear while driving. yet people still do it. These people need to ask themselves, is this call really that important? I admire the one driver that I saw on the road. He had pulled all the way over and came to a full stop so he could talk on his phone. It is never safe to text while driving, and it is clear people can't seem to talk on a phone while driving either.

    Join us on Pinterest

    DAILY SHOT VIDEO

    We apologize. An error has occurred. Please try again.