10 Top-Selling Mascaras Go Head to Head

What’s a girl to do when she receives a Sephora LashStash Mascara Deluxe Sampler chock-full of the store’s best sellers? Test them all of course!-
Since high school, I've been a hardcore ... more 
What’s a girl to do when she receives a Sephora LashStash Mascara Deluxe Sampler chock-full of the store’s best sellers? Test them all of course!-
Since high school, I've been a hardcore devotee to two mascara brands: Max Factor and L'Oreal. It's not that I have anything against the others -- it's just that when I find something that works, I stick to it. So when a friend of mine recently gave me the Sephora LashStash Deluxe Sampler as a gift, my first thought was, "Um, I don't need this." But upon deeper introspection, I realized that perhaps it was time to lash out, if you will, and try something new. So I did, and was pleasantly surprised to find some keepers in the bunch. On a scale of 1-5 (5 being lovely, and 1 being lame), this is how Sephora's top-selling contenders weighed in. Prime those peepers and get ready to rumble. less 
1 / 11
Thu, Oct 6, 2011 2:39 PM EDT

More From StyleCaster:

10 Classic Songs to DJ at Your Next Party
These Tunes are Sure to Get the Party Going!

Finding Balance in Your Relationship
5 Times to Compromise, and 5 Times You Should Stand Your Ground

Don't Let Stress Rule Your Life
5 Way to Keep It Cool in Any Situation

Is Social Media Ruining Your Love Life?
How the Internet Makes Relationships Go Bad

3 Major Money Mistakes
These Slip Ups Will Cost You Big Time!

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook! And download the StyleCaster Daily Looks Widget!

Get StyleCaster on-the-go with our ALL NEW iPhone App!