Would You Want a Black Diamond Engagement Ring?

Round Black Diamond 14K White Gold Engagement Ring from Gemvara, $4,488Round Black Diamond 14K White Gold Engagement Ring from Gemvara, $4,488By Kim Fusaro, Glamour magazine

Sure, Carrie Bradshaw could rock a black diamond-Big gifted her one in Sex and the City 2-but would a black diamond work on a real-life girl?

Related: 39 of the Sparkliest Engagement Rings Ever

I'm not sure. I mean, it's pretty fantastic, but I don't know if the whoa-that's-cool factor would stand up over time. Then again, I think a badass black diamond might be more "me" than, say, a pale pink one.

Related: 21 Wedding Dresses for Under $1,200

And-bonus!-they appear to be way cheaper than regular diamonds; the one pictured on the ring above, which is going for less than $5,000, is almost six carats. Holy bling!

What do you think? Would you want a black diamond engagement ring? Or would you prefer something more traditional? Do you want a diamond-free engagement ring?

More from Glamour:

How to Find Your Body's Best Jeans
19 Cute Celebrity Haircuts to Consider
8 Sex Moves Every Woman Should Try Once
Why He Hasn't Proposed (Yet)
10 Things He's Thinking When You're Naked