A School in New Zealand Has Done Away with Recess – and It’s Working

By Ryan D'Agostino

Last week, Esquire published a story I wrote called "The Drugging of the American Boy." The process of reporting and writing the story was, in many ways, completely depressing. As an editor at a men's magazine -- and more to the point, as a former boy -- what I discovered was enraging.

To an astonishing degree, boys are being diagnosed with ADHD reflexively, absent any meaningful evaluation and, as a result, a lot of them are being put on powerful medications that can seriously mess with their health and development, both physical and mental. The problem of unreliable ADHD diagnoses and overmedication has been acknowledged before, but I came away believing that few people understand just how pervasive the problem is.

RELATED: The Drugging of the American Boy

Few people understand that it's a crisis.

One true high point of the experience was encountering Howard Glasser, founder of the Center for the Difficult Child in Tucson, Ariz. Glasser created a therapeutic method called the Nurtured Heart Approach, which is now practiced by a growing number of therapists in the United States. (You can learn about it in the article and here.)

Now, in the news, comes another glimmer of hope, from Bruce McLachlan, principal of the Swanson School in Auckland, New Zealand. (Coincidence: Glasser was nearby, in Australia, last week training teachers to use the Nurtured Heart Approach.)

RELATED: 83 Things Every Man Should Do Before He Dies

According to a story in Canada's National Post, McLachlan has rattled the world of education by doing away with rules during recess. Students can play however they please, even if someone gets hurt. From the story:

"'My son broke his arm in the playground, and I just want to make sure…" he began. "And I'm thinking 'Oh my God, what's going to happen?'" Mr. McLachlan recalled, sitting in his "fishbowl" of an office one hot Friday afternoon last month. The parent continued: "I just wanted to make sure you don't change this play environment, because kids break their arms."

Kid fell out of a tree and broke his arm? It happens. Boys are using sticks as swords? Let them. (We're assuming that deliberate physical attacks are still off-limits.) McLachlan reports that there have been fewer reports of bullying and vandalism, fewer injuries on the playground, and more focus in the classroom -- all, at least in part, as a result of his new policy, the Post's Sarah Boesveld reports.

RELATED: Boys Are Under Attack in America

We were raised among boys and would have loved such lawlessness, though we wonder how many kids would have been left standing at the end of recess. Still, we appreciate the inclination. This kind of thinking should be happening everywhere, and yet too often it's the opposite: More rules about sitting quietly and not throwing stuff. Kids, especially boys, need to throw stuff. If they aren't allowed to, they might act out in class, and then someone might try to put them on drugs.

Here, they're allowed, or even encouraged, to get their hands a little dirty. And it's working.

More from Esquire:
Let's Ban These Words From the Internet
Kareem's Guide to Understanding Women
15 Years Later, Columbine's Principal is Retiring
How to Tie a Tie