Burrito Vs. Burger: Do You Know What Takeout Options Are Healthiest?

Photo: ThinkstockPhoto: Thinkstock

By Corrie Pikul


Chicken Tikka Masala vs. Orange Chicken with Rice

The preparation for all these dishes will vary, but we asked Janis Jibrin, RD, the lead nutritionist for Best Life, to analyze the basic recipes and track down nutritional info for chain restaurants. She found that although tikka masala has fewer calories than orange chicken (662 versus 871 for a 1.5-cup portion of the chicken dish plus 1 cup of rice), it has almost triple the saturated fat (17 grams versus 6 grams). This is because it's made with cream and, usually, ghee (clarified butter). Jibrin says tikka masala is worse for your arteries and your heart, as well as your waistline.
Healthier Tikka Masala: If you order a creamy curry, Jibrin advises limiting your portion to just 1 cup. Another idea for healthier but still-speedy Indian food: frozen entrées. Jibrin likes Ethnic Gourmet's Tikka Masala, which has only 260 calories and 2 grams of saturated fat.
Healthier Orange Chicken: Jibrin suggests ordering an all-vegetable entrée (such as stir-fried spinach, broccoli or green beans) with your chicken dish and sharing both with friends. Steamed veggies are the healthiest, but even Jibrin admits they get pretty boring. Instead, ask the restaurant to "go easy on the oil" when stir-frying, and substitute brown rice for white.


RELATED: 8 Ways to Save Your Heart


Photo: ThinkstockPhoto: ThinkstockBurrito vs. Burger

These entrées come in all sizes, so let's compare the standard Chipotle beef burrito with the basic McDonald's Big Mac: The burrito has 1,130 calories and 20 grams of saturated fat, and the burger has 540 calories and 10 grams of saturated fat. What makes the burrito so much worse? The tortilla, says Jibrin: 290 calories before you add anything else.
Healthier Burrito: Toss the tortilla and order your burrito "naked," or in a bowl. Scoop on heart-healthy guacamole and skip the sour cream and cheese to bring the total saturated fat down to around 5 grams. If you also substitute lettuce for half the rice, you'll turn your burrito bomb into a meal that's practically good for you.
Healthier Burger: Go with the puny-size patty (a regular burger from the drive-thru is 3.5 ounces, a Big Mac is 7.5 ounces, and classic burgers from family restaurants are even bigger). Add lettuce for bulk and tomato for antioxidants. Ketchup and mustard are negligible in terms of calories, but mayo has 90 calories per packet, so use sparingly. Hold the fries (but you already knew that).


RELATED: Dr. Oz's Longevity Grocery List


Photo: ThinkstockPhoto: ThinkstockTeriyaki vs. Pad Thai

Jibrin says all the ingredients in pad thai are swimming in oil, which brings calories in the typical takeout box up to 1,140 and saturated fat to 7 grams. You're better off with a similar-size order of chicken teriyaki, which has 30 percent fewer calories than pad thai and about the same amount of protein.
Healthier Teriyaki: Jibrin recommends no more than a cup of rice (about the size of two fists) and another cup of chicken with teriyaki sauce. Order an all-vegetable side, and again, substitute brown rice for white. Inquire about low-sodium teriyaki sauce. (Like all takeout, both these dishes are loaded with sodium: 2,700 to 5,200 milligrams. The recommended amount is only 1,500 to 2,300 milligrams per day.)
Healthier Pad Thai: Request double the vegetables (usually bean sprouts, onions and scallions). The rice noodles are a waste of calories, and there are a lot of them, so aim to eat only about the size of three fists' worth of this dish.


RELATED: Know Your Portions: The Healthy Eater's Cheat Sheet


Photo: ThinkstockPhoto: ThinkstockPepperoni Pizza vs. Spaghetti and Meatballs

Viva Italian Night! What do you feel like? Two slices of Domino's medium hand-tossed pepperoni pizza (440 calories, 8 grams of saturated fat) or a half-portion of Olive Garden's spaghetti with meat sauce and two meatballs (460 calories, 7 grams of saturated fat)? In terms of fat and calories, they're pretty close, but Jibrin recommends the spaghetti as a slightly healthier option. "Processed meats like pepperoni usually contain nitrites, which studies have linked to cancer and coronary heart disease," says Jibrin (they also have tons of salt). The spaghetti has no processed meat and more "real" ingredients.
Healthier Pizza: Top your pie with vegetables. If you get thin-crust pizza, you'll cut the calories almost in half. Look for a pizza parlor that serves whole wheat crusts. "The extra fiber, as well as the phytonutrients from the veggies, would make this your healthiest choice," says Jibrin.
Healthier Spaghetti: You've heard it before: Order whole wheat pasta whenever possible. Pair your half-portion size with a side salad with oil and vinegar. ("Steer clear of the premade dressings, because takeout dinners have enough sodium," says Jibrin.)


RELATED: 5 Wrong Turns That Can Lead to Cancer


Photo: ThinkstockPhoto: ThinkstockFried Chicken vs. Steak

You're in the mood for comfort food. One 6-ounce breast from KFC has 360 calories, 5 grams of saturated fat and 1,080 milligrams of sodium. A same-size fillet (about one and a half decks of cards) from Outback Steakhouse has just 218 calories, 4 grams of saturated fat and 206 milligrams of sodium, making it a much better choice. But because no one orders a piece of meat by itself, says Jibrin, typical side dishes make both these choices similarly diet-busting. Adding mashed potatoes and cole slaw to your chicken means 810 calories and 11 grams of saturated fat. A fillet with mashed potatoes and a salad with blue cheese dressing has 902 calories and a whopping 21 grams of saturated fat.
Healthier Chicken: Go for green beans (25 calories), an undressed salad (15 calories-splash on oil and vinegar at home) or a 3-inch piece of corn on the cob (71 calories).
Healthier Steak: Order a leaner cut of sirloin or tenderloin; calories and fat skyrocket in cuts like rib eye, prime rib, Porterhouse and New York strip. Avoid rich, buttery sides, and have your steak with grilled vegetables and a baked potato.


RELATED: Diet Cheat Sheet: Healthy "Junk" Food


More from Oprah.com:

Your sex questions answered
Dr. Oz's two-day wonder cleanse
The key to lasting happiness
5 hair myths busted
Subscribe to O, The Oprah Magazine and save up to 78%

Like O, The Oprah Magazine on Facebook