The Best Pies in America

We selflessly tasted over 40 mail-order pies to bring you the best America has to offer. Find out who the winners are and where to buy them. Want to make your own? Try one of our delicious homemade pie recipes!

Apple

This Oklahoma treat proves that the outside, a golden double crust, can matter as much as the inside: thick-cut Washington apples. Try these apple pie recipes.

(Pioneer Pies, $29.95; pioneerpies.com
)

Pecan

A family-owned Texas bakery spent five generations perfecting this decadent Southern standard. Try one of our delicious pecan pie recipes at home.

(Three Brothers Bakery, $19.95; 3brothersbakery.com
)

Plus: Holiday Pies & Dessert Recipes Your Family Will Love

Pumpkin

Who doesn't love pumpkin pie? Michigan's Grand Traverse Pie Co. delivers a dense, mousse-like texture and a crust detail that won our hearts. Plus: Here's how to make a crust from scratch.


($26.99; gtpie.com;
CL Deal: enter CLM for 15% discount and gift.)



Cherry

The flaky-gooey crumb topping on this Virginia dessert offers sweet contrast to sour Montmorency cherries. Want a cherry pie right now? Try one of our recipes at home.

(Mom's Apple Pie Company, $15.99; momsapplepieco.com)

Plus: Vintage Pie Birds offer an adorable way to let off steam.


Sweet Potato

Mr. Tod's launched its New Jersey business with this rich pie--so spicy and savory that it could qualify as a side dish.

($25; whybake.com)

Apple Crumb

This Washington, D.C., bakery puts a twist on the traditional apple pie with a crunchy topping of oats, brown sugar, and butter.
(Dangerously Delicious, $28; dangerouspies.com)

Want more? See the rest of our mail-order pies here.


Get more at Countryliving.com!

Easy Homemade Pie Recipes

30 Ways to Decorate Your Pumpkin

Craft Ideas for Halloween

Home Green Home: Country Living's House of the Year

Decorating Ideas for Small Spaces

Get More Creative Ideas for Your Home: Subscribe to Country Living Magazine

Reprinted with permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.