Celebrity Spring Fashion Wars

It's amazing how different the exact same dress can look depending on which star is wearing it. Check out our picks for who did four spring styles the right way.

Carmen Electra vs. Taylor Swift
When we caught up with Carmen at Fashion Week, she was wearing a strapless grey Rebecca Taylor floral dress. I immediately fell in love with the piece, but I didn't particularly love the way she put the look together with heavy leather winter boots. Taylor, on the other hand, gave the dress the casual, bohemian feel it needs with a girly headband, a long silver necklace and nude platforms.

Lady Gaga vs. Kimberly Wyatt
I feel bad for anyone who competes with Gaga in the fashion area. But this is a rare occasion where a challenger prevails. The canary yellow Dolce & Gabbana dress did NOT need Geisha-style lipstick, a wide-brimmed hat, a parasol, or 6-inch platforms. Former PCD, Kimberly Wyatt, made the dress far more flattering with black patent peep-toe heels and a chic blunt bob.

Kristen Stewart vs. Melissa George
This J. Mendel dress fits both women like a glove. But Kristen- looking uncharacteristically feminine, we might add- does it better. She leaves it looking unfussy with her platform nude pumps and pulled-back hair. Melissa adds too many components, like a blazer, which covers the sweetheart neckline, and ankle-strap shoes that shorten the look of her legs.

Kristen Bell and Katharine McPhee
Kristen does this 3.1 Phillip Lim off-white lace mini the right way, with a simple pop of color in the form of bright red pumps. Katharine takes the monochromatic feel WAY too far. The dress, the tights, the platinum hair-it's a very unflattering combo, especially with the stark black shoes.

Do you agree with our choices? Tell us what you think by emailing us or sending us a Facebook message. And be sure to vote in our poll below. We'll be back soon from our Planet Hollywood studio in Times Square with a brand new episode.