Supermarket Surprise! Smaller Servings, Same Price

Out of toilet paper so soon? Who the heck ate all of the Haagen Dazs? Why is this grilled cheese sandwich less cheesy than before?

Complaints like these - household staples getting used up faster; food not lasting as long -- are becoming more common.

No, members of your household aren't being wasteful or taking extra helpings of dessert. Those boxes of pasta, rolls of paper towels, jars of pesto and packages of hot dogs really are getting smaller. But manufacturers hope that you haven't noticed.

Same look, less filling!
A recent Consumer Reports investigation found that the amount of dish detergent, toilet tissue, and first aid spray in those same old containers has shrunk as much as 20%. Here are a handful of items that are slimmer than they used to be:


Old size

New size


Tropicana orange juice

64 oz.

59 oz.


Ivory dish detergent

30 oz.

24 oz.


Kraft American cheese

24 slices

22 slices


Häagen Dazs ice cream


14 oz.


Scott toilet tissue

115.2 sq. fit.

104.8 sq. ft.


Lancane first aid spray

113 grams

99 grams


Chicken of the Sea salmon

3 oz.

2.6 oz.


Classico pesto

10 oz.

8.1 oz.


Hebrew National franks

12 oz.

11 oz.



Blame it on the rising costs of producing these goods, such as raw materials, energy, and facility costs, say manufacturers. As their expenses rise, they've got to find ways to make up the difference: Either charge more for the product, or give less of it to you for the same money.

The latter strategy -- charging the same amount for less-generous servings -- is the safer bet: Studies show that shoppers are more sensitive to price increases than product volume decreases. And manufacturers go to great lengths to get you to overlook the downsized items in your shopping cart.

Packaging tricks that throw you off the scent
Getting you to overlook the fact that there's one-fifth less detergent in that Ivory bottle is all about subtle tweaks in presentation. To disguise downsizing, manufacturers do everything from indenting the bottom of the container to whipping pockets of air into the same old ice cream container.

As I pointed out in "5 Mind Games Stores Use to Make You Spend," be particularly wary if a company comes out with a new container that is taller than the previous version - a taller, skinnier Tropicana carton, for example. It's a classic bit of visual trickery at work: We tend to notice changes in height more than changes in girth.

It's unlikely that the downsizing trend will be reversed. Your best strategy is to pay attention to per-unit pricing - the real measure of how much you're paying for the actual product, rather than the new packaging.

What's in your shopping cart?
Have you noticed shrinking portions of the products you use over time? Have you switched brands? Gone for generic? Re-worked recipes to use less expensive items? How do you stretch your dollars at the supermarket? Chime in below.

More ways to save on everything on your shopping list:

· 4 Simple Rules for Supermarket Savings

· 5 Ways to Stop Buying Stupid Stuff

· Trick Your Mind Into Spending Smarter

Get financially fit with The Motley Fool!:

· Start out with our 13 Steps to Investing Foolishly

· Join us on Facebook

· Check out columnist Dayana Yochim is able to calculate the per-unit price on any item in less than 30 seconds. If only they gave medals for that.