Temper Tantrums: What Your Toddler is Trying to Tell You (and How You Can Help)

When your toddler is melting down, it's easy to chalk the tantrum up to anger or frustration (and to get angry and frustrated yourself). But a new study that analyzed the sounds that tots make when their pitching a fit shows that there may be more to a tantrum than just a lot of screaming -- and may offer parents a way to cope.

In the study, which was published in the journal "Emotion," scientists recorded the sounds toddlers make during tantrums and discovered that not only does each type of sound (screaming, yelling, crying, whining, and fussing) have its own "distinct acoustic features," there's a definite pattern to the vocalizations as well.

 "Screaming and yelling and kicking often go together," study co-author Michael Potegal, an associate professor of pediatric clinical neuroscience at the University of Minnesota, told NPR. "Throwing things and pulling and pushing things tend to go together. Combinations of crying, whining, falling to the floor and seeking comfort -- and these also hang together."

So, what's really going on when a toddler is having a meltdown? "Frustration certainly is a trigger," James A. Green, head of the department of psychology at the University of Connecticut and a co-author of the study, told Yahoo! Shine. "Blocked goals can results in frustration, which leads to anger. Same is true of adults, actually."

But the scientists also discovered that, contrary to popular belief, toddlers aren't just melting down out of anger, they're also feeling sadness at the same time.

"The impression that tantrums have two stages is incorrect," Potegal said. "In fact, the anger and the sadness are more or less simultaneous."

Certain conditions can make it more likely that a toddler will melt down, Green points out. "Fatigue or illness can lower the tolerance for frustration," he points out. "Toddlers, or so the conventional wisdom goes, simply do not have as many cognitive 'tricks' up their sleeves to deal with these situations." (Older kids, however, should be better able to deal with such situations, which is why their angry outbursts are called rages, not tantrums.)

1. Wait it out. If your toddler is having a tantrum, there's little you can do other than wait it out, experts say. "My colleague and collaborator, Mike Potegal, talks about 'standing back' during the periods of most intense anger, and I think he means both physically and emotionally," Green says. "Trying to give more information to a child who has already lost control may not be very helpful."

"Best to scoop up your tyke and take her to a place where she can calm down without being disruptive to others," suggests Michelle Nicholasen, a mother of five and the author of "I Break for Meltdowns: How to Handle the Most Exasperating Behavior of Your 2- to 5-Year-Old." "Is it a drag for the parent? Oh, yes, and tiring, too. But wait out the storm and it will pass."

2. Don't threaten, cajole, or bribe. You might not be able to control the tantrum itself, but you can control how you react to it, Nicholasen points out. "Parents can make tantrums much worse by yelling at their child to stop, or by threatening them," she says.

Instead of asking questions or trying to reason with a 2- or 3-year-old, simply acknowledge that they're upset. "Toddlers who are in the middle of a meltdown are incapable of hearing our message (reasons, reassurance or warnings) until they're sure we understand and respect their message," says Dr. Harvey Karp, author of "The Happiest Toddler on the Block."

3. Offer comfort. Once children have gotten past what Potegal calls "the peaks of anger," they're more willing to be comforted.

4. Find the humor in the situation. Many parents end up just as frustrated and angry as the child during a tantrum, but as Green points out, tantrums are completely normal -- up to a point. "This too shall pass," he says. "Tantrums are normative events in development and usually decline after age 4."

While you're waiting for your tot to get over his or her anger, having a sense of humor can help. "Imagine a grown-up acting like your child, and you will soon have to stifle a smile," Nicholasen says.

5. Don't take it as a personal failure. "As parents, we are much more self-conscious about being judged when our child is misbehaving in public. The things that go through our minds are: Am I raising my child to be a wild animal? Have I not taught him enough manners? My child is acting like a little brat; what am I doing wrong? But even when you do your best, sometimes a collapse will still happen."

Follow Yahoo! Shine on Twitter, "like" us


on Facebook

Also on Shine:

 

1,024 comments

  • Tim  •  5 months ago
    Interesting article and I am proud to say I've been using these technique's on my boss for years.
    • SecondOpinion 5 months ago
      Bosses, toddlers and husbands. Some bosses and children are female but not to be excluded.
    • Linaeve 5 months ago
      This made me laugh hysterically! Thank you for the mirth!
    • Rat 5 months ago
      You Rock Tim... hehehehehe.....
  • Jen-IL  •  5 months ago
    When children arrive at a restaurant real hungry, they're going to act up. When toddlers, I used to give my kids their meal at home. When we arrived at the restaurant, I ordered my meal and they ordered the dessert of their choice. They had a good meal at home and were happy as clams eating dessert.....and I got to eat in peace. When they were old enough to sit through a meal and dessert, the routine changed.
    • Rebecca 5 months ago
      Good idea, wish I had thought of it. I spent too many restaurant meals feeding my son instead of myself. I did tend to not serve myself until he was fed at home, much more relaxing. Even that passes when they get older.
    • Tim 5 months ago
      Good plan JP! That's usin' the brain God gave ya... excellently. 2,000 thumbs up!
    • Jen-IL 5 months ago
      It took one time of them getting fussy by dessert, Rebecca. I had to come up with a plan. They're grown now, but I was a single mom of two boys and wanted peace for me, but fun for them.

      lol Thanks, Tim :)
  • Adela  •  5 months ago
    When you are at home, ignoring is fine. But when out in public, no way. My son tried to throw one once at the zoo. I told him he either quieted down or we were leaving. He then raised his voice, and I grabbed him and left. He never tried that again, and when he saw we were leaving he stopped that nonsense real quick. I definitely agree with the thing not to bribe. That just starts a nasty behaviour of, "oh I can get things when I start screaming." I hate it when I see parents do that, just as much as I hate it when they allow their children to act horribly in public.
    • Jennifer 5 months ago
      That is the key.. You do this two or three times and eventually they will learn.. Set boundries and limits and they will adhere to them. Ultimately, this is a lesson they will need to learn later in life..
    • Rebecca 5 months ago
      When you start leaving, if they stop... go ahead and leave. They will not do it again.
    • patty 5 months ago
      Amen to all !! Parents need to act like parents not like spoiled kids themselves. Don't pull yourself down to the childs level, take control and the child will be much happier!
  • Mull Master  •  5 months ago
    My Dad was a World War II Vet. His son throw Tantrams? In Public?!! Are you kidding?!!
    • Jen-IL 5 months ago
      My Dad was also a WWII vet, but he was a gentle giant. My childhood memories are good ones. I'm very thankful I had great parents.
    • Ghost 5 months ago
      My dad was Special Forces in Vietnam. I wouldn't have lived through what he would have done to me if I'd thrown a tantrum.
    • aunt_deen 5 months ago
      Guys, we're talking TWO YEAR OLDS here. I don't care how tough and disciplined you are, a child that age can't always control his emotions or understand consequences.

      Would you deal harshly with a two year old who unable to understand an algebra problem? Then don't do so with a child who is unable to understand he can't play with all the shiny things in the hardware store.
  • Kim  •  5 months ago
    It depends on your child. Everyone is different. You know your child and what works for him or her. My mom said my brother once threw a LOUD tantrum in the grocery store. She promptly left the cart loaded with food, grabbed him and took him home.
    • Rebecca 5 months ago
      I did that with my son and foster children. ONCE is all it takes. Grab them up and go home.
    • IDK 5 months ago
      Did the same thing with my daughter, and we were in the store buying her shoes. Had other things in the cart. She wouldn't get quiet, kept insisting that she wanted other shoes, and was just acting horrible. I pulled her out of the cart and promptly left the store. Haven't had trouble like this again.
    • ibelieve 5 months ago
      My son pitched a fit on the floor at a grocery store...he was about 3 yrs. old...I was checking out, got my stuff and just stepped over him and kept walking and when I was getting right outside the door, here he came...I never looked back and when it registered with him he got up and came outside the store.
  • Super Mex  •  5 months ago
    One of my Granddaughters use to throw a fit and flop down on the floor and bang her head on it until one day she flopped down on the kitchen/dining room floor which was clay tiles instead of carpet "needless to say "END OF TANTRUMS"
  • Kuel  •  5 months ago
    Please, if you litle darlin is having a fit in a restaurant take him/her outside. Thank you.
  • TexanProud  •  5 months ago
    My children are grown with children of their own and I handle tantrums the same exact way. I take them to their rooms, tell them when they are finished they may come out and close the door. Most of the time it takes only a couple of minutes for them to realize no one is paying attention and stop the tantrum. I have one grandchild however that gets angrier if the door is closed so for her its the corner in her room with the door open. I then tell them it is ok to get angry but it is best to be angry in your own room. That way they learn to respect other people and their feelings too.
  • quixoticbats  •  5 months ago
    Actually, I've seen grownups having tantrums and it doesn't make me smile.
  • Andrea  •  5 months ago
    You want to stop tantrums? Do something about it. When I was young, if I acted up in public my mom would grab me and leave. Didn't matter where we were or what we were doing.
  • Dataman  •  5 months ago
    If you take your kid out tired, walk it around the mall for hours going at YOUR pace, not the pace his little legs can manage, have him over-dressed, he's hot, or cold, he's hungry, his diaper may be full, and you keep ignoring his cries for help because you are too busy watching your reflection in the windows, texting, telephoning, or BSing with your friends, and then he goes ballistic on you, whose fault IS that, exactly? I see it all the time. So sad. Adults expecting a 2 or 3 year-old to be more adult than THEY can manage.

    If you are not doing those things, and he throws a tantrum anyway? Get down and do it with him. Have a little fun. It's like when he's doing that and a stranger walks up and looks him in the eye. He stops. Quit obsessing. Enjoy the moment.
  • keisha  •  5 months ago
    honestly no matter what you do with your toddler in public someone gets annoyed with you. If you ignore it people complain and if you take care of the situation people act like you're hurting the child. So i just do what works best for me I don't care what others think. I took my nephew out to eat one time. He got annoyed because we wouldn't let him sit by my niece because they play and don't eat and threw a tantrum. So first i told him how it was going to be in a calm voice and when that didn't work i picked him up and took him out to the car (couldn't leave we came with people) and we waited he decided that he wanted to eat and told me he wouldn't act up again and he didn't haven't had trouble with him since he knows i mean business but children are much more likely to calm down if you remain calm but you also have to be stern and follow through.
  • Chris  •  5 months ago
    Temper tantrums children and Alec Baldwin
  • Linda  •  5 months ago
    This article doesn't go far enough to discuss the issues of the tantrums that go on for years. I have three children and only one had raging tantrums. Placing my child in a safe room where she coudn't hurt herself or others meant that I sat on the other side of the door holding it closed as she tried to dismantle it and kick her way out. This went beyond naughtiness, it was an uncontrollable rage that couldn't be dealt with. It made me understand how child abuse can happen, but no help was ever given to me for the years that my child was completely out of control. As she grew out of this she became a driven, happy adult. I admire her and am glad that I found a way to cope with the rages, but I wouldn't wish this experience on anyone
  • Bob  •  5 months ago
    train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old he will not depart from it. spare the rod and spoil the child. the parent is supposed to be smarter than the child to teach it correctly.
  • Kathryn  •  5 months ago
    Its called discipline, when we were kids all my dad had to do was lean across the table and say, "Do we need to take a trip to the bathroom?" It took one punishment my entire life, after that, it only took the anticipation of possible punishment. And we are now all three successful educated members of society.
  • Skynet  •  5 months ago
    Tantrums are simply your child testing your resolve. Give in to them and you'll see many more of them. Ignore their act and they'll try a different tactic. Don't try and reason with a toddler, it won't work.
  • mad  •  5 months ago
    when my boy had a tantrum because he was told no, my wife went one way and I went the other way. Funny thing he stopped. From that day he never did another.
  • lisa summerfield  •  5 months ago
    we all tend to have a quick and easy fix however most of them the parent would be "hotlined" for. When it's your son asking you what else he can do with your grandchild you responfd differently At this point i've been teling him to ignore and walk away rather than lose his cool..
  • BeatleBabe95  •  5 months ago
    Just take the kid outside. That's what my parents did.
    And it worked- after all, I couldn't scream forever.
    Though sometimes there is a valid reason- sickness, for example. I remember throwing quite a few tantrums after puking in the car. But you can't punish a child for sickness.
POLL

What gardening activities does your family help with?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options